Hunger asks, What price principles?

06 November 2008 | 15:23 - By World Movies

The lines between victim and agressor are blurred in Steve McQueen's bold new film, Hunger. Review by Fiona Williams.

uploaded_image_rand_368480366

Director Steve McQueen’s debut feature Hunger is an exploration of what it is to die for a cause but when republican prisoner Bobby Sands (Michael Fassbender) succumbs to the inevitable, it’s in far from heroic circumstances.

The film opens in the midst of the infamous ‘Blanket and No-Wash protest’ at the Maze Prison in Northern Ireland, where the H Block’s republican prisoners have shunned standard-issue uniforms in response to the government’s refusal to grant them special category status.

They refuse showers, smear the walls of their cells with excrement (albeit with artistic flourish), and spill their urine into the corridor on cue and en masse. In scenes that McQueen depicts in unflinching detail, the guards’ response to the protest is increasingly violent. After the riot squad is called in to pull them into line and conduct cavity searches for evidence of widespread message smuggling, Sands ups the ante by initiating a hunger strike.

Though Hunger is clearly Sands’ story, it isn't until well into the film that the focus narrows to his experience. Until then, we spend considerable time following protagonists from both sides of the barbed wire fence.

The film has inevitably sparked criticism in the UK for ‘martyring’ Sands, but though such complaints are understandable given the recent history of ‘The Troubles’, they’re also largely unfair. Events are seen to take their toll on both the inmates and their captors, and the lines between victim and aggressor anything but clear-cut. McQueen recognises the guards’ legitimate fears of assassination, and singles out a new riot squad recruit to capture the pivotal moment at which the men are asked to inflict government-sanctioned brutality.

The cinematography and the framing of shots are stunning (a snowflake catching on a guard’s grazed knuckle is one of many images that linger), which isn’t really a surprise when you consider McQueen’s background as a Turner Prize-winning artist.

That said, the standout scene of the film is shot in a single take, from a fixed camera. When Sands reveals his plan to his visiting parish priest, Father Dominic Moran (Liam Cunningham) grills Sands over the political and personal ramifications of his decision, and points to the futility of his certain death. Sands counters with a boyhood account of sacrifice that makes him "clear of the reasons". The two actors are outstanding in this scene, as they size each other up with rapid-fire barbs, interrogate the merits of Sands’ decision, and emerge with a mutual if begrudging, respect for the other’s position. It’s a remarkable exchange that in the tradition of great theatre, works on the strength of smart dialogue and the acting chops of both Cunningham and Fassbender.

After this scene, Sands is virtually silent as he wastes away before our eyes, and it’s here that McQueen’s direction takes a sharp U-turn. Up to this point, life in H Block has been presented in such stark, silent, suffocating reality, that the third act’s attempt to venture into the dying Sands’ imagination sits uneasily with the rest of the film.

We see his youthful self sit by his emaciated elder’s deathbed, we see flashbacks to golden sunsets, and a flock of imagined birds circles the prison ward. It’s a jarring departure and of course, one that may be intentional; these scenes could well be a device by McQueen to show that the fierce and determined firebrand Bobby Sands has given in to sentiment after all.

Hunger is a confronting and thought-provoking look at personal sacrifice and the cost of unwavering conviction.

 
4/5



Share article: 
top

Comments (3)

25 Nov 2008 16:35 AEST

John Lynch

From: Tocumwal NSW 2714

Top Gear

Thank you SBS for putting the original version of Top Gear from England back on SBS last night, I thoroughly enjoyed it. The English version is just such a superior show, compared to that PATHETIC Australian version of Top Gear. Please DO NOT put that Australian Top Gear back on SBS, because, I for one, will NOT watch it, it is rubbish. Regards, John Lynch

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

22 Nov 2008 0:30 AEST

kelly

From: sydney

AMAZING!

This is one of the best films i've seen in a VERY long time. Harsh, gritting and realisitic, it is NOT for the queezy. It is a very confronting topic which has been filmed with some fantastic imagery. GO SEE IT - i can't stop thinking about it!!

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

14 Nov 2008 17:54 AEST

Eligius

From: The Peninsula NSW

I Want to See This Film

I am partly of Irish ethnic background and I want to see this film. (A warning should be given - I've been told this film contains some full-frontal male nudity. If you don't like that sort of thing, stay away. Although that's to be expected given it's a prison film, and the story behind it. Prisons have no privacy.)

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.

About this Blog

Comprehensive and unbiased coverage of independent global cinema. This is the place to discuss the films that you love, and to discover new favourites.

World Movies

 
ADVERTISEMENT