News Limited's treatment of football is bottom-of-the-barrel stuff

17 June 2009 | 16:00 - By Jesse Fink

It's not too late to jump on the Australian football bandwagon, writes Jesse Fink.

cahill-306_1081176805

My redoubtable boss here at SBS Sport, Toby Forage, sent me a link today to a radio interview in which 2GB radio announcer Alan Jones, aka "The Parrot", excoriates Neil Breen, the editor of the Sunday Telegraph, for the story his paper carried on its front page on the weekend: "SOCCEROOS COVER-UP".

I probably don't need to tell you it carried allegations that Tim Cahill, the star Australia midfielder, had been thrown out of a Kings Cross nightclub called Trademark in the wee hours of Friday morning after the Australian Football Awards ceremony on Thursday.

It's been the talk of football circles for the past few days and Cahill, apparently, is considering taking legal action against News Limited, the publisher of the Sunday Telegraph.

"A blind drunk Tim Cahill has shamed Australian soccer on its biggest day by getting kicked out of a Kings Cross nightclub after a fracas with bouncers," the paper thundered.

"Several witnesses told The Sunday Telegraph Cahill got into an altercation at Trademark when he was told to leave because he was 'so drunk he couldn't even stand up'.

"Cahill's disgrace soured the most important fortnight for the game in Australia which is trying to secure either the 2018 or 2022 World Cup… [the incident] is an unwanted blemish on football's reputation in Australia, where it has largely escaped the nightclub dramas associated with league and Australian Rules in recent years."

Football Federation Australia quickly cleared Cahill of any wrongdoing. The Kings Cross police did not have any issue with what was alleged to have occurred. So Jones, rightly, gives Breen a massive dose of his mind on the issue, ostensibly calling up the editor for his and his reporters' failure to name the names of witnesses to the event quoted in the story.

I won't quote the exchange but it's well worth listening to and doesn't offer much comfort to anyone who might one day get on the wrong side of the Sunday Telegraph.

Breen's defence for his reporters' tactics, which included knocking on the door of Cahill's sister in the middle of the night, and the decision to not name witnesses quoted in the story, is that it was "usual journalistic practice".

Well, god help Australian journalism.

I have expounded on the issue of declining standards in Australian journalism, especially in regard to the Matthew Johns affair, and this is just confirmation that it is getting worse.

Cahill broke no laws. He did not get involved in a fight. He did not piss out a window. He was, according to reliable accounts, asked to leave along with everyone else in the club. He may or may not have been over the limit – who can really say if he was not breathalysed? – but most people are in a pub or bar at any given time.

I live just near Trademark. People are asked to leave the premises at closing time every single night it's open for business. So what is the public interest in the story and why is the Sunday Telegraph reporting it?

The answers are there is none and they should not be. As far as I can see, the Telegraph has impinged on the privacy of a private citizen and essentially defamed him and his sport with no real evidence to support the allegations made against him.

I'm not the only person to have noticed the barrage of invective directed at Australian football that has come out of News Limited in the past seven days. Indeed I wrote about it last week in my column for The Roar.

And when they're not dishing out bile against football they're writing, well, nothing about it at all. I picked up the Daily Telegraph the other day to read with my morning coffee and was hoping to find some coverage of the FIFA Confederations Cup, the massive football tournament that is taking place in South Africa at the moment and which I am writing daily columns on for ESPN in Asia, such is the interest in the tournament in our region.

Not one word.

What exactly is News Limited's problem with football? Is it because they have so much money invested in rugby league, a game that is falling apart? Is it because their executive sports editor, Phil Rothfield, hates football? (I do not know if he does or not, but from the tenor of his recent comments about the game he doesn't seem to like it an awful lot.) Or is it because it's a game they simply can't get their heads around through their own ignorance of its history and its geographical and economic reach?

Whatever the reason, there is no excuse for the campaign it appears to have been waging against football, a campaign that has now ensnared one of Australia's biggest stars, Cahill.

Football is open to everyone: men, women and children of all ages, colour and creed. It is a celebration of the richness of our world and the people who inhabit it. If News Limited didn't have such a closed view of that world, it might appreciate its beauty, too, and share in the joy that comes from being a part of this wonderful global sport.

Instead it keeps its head in the proverbial sand, only to occasionally emerge to snipe and complain about something it knows absolutely nothing about.

The football family will still welcome you with open arms, News Limited, but the goodwill is starting to fade.


:: For more Fink musings on the big issues in football, check out Half-time Orange on The World Game.

Share article: 
top

Comments (35)

Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next 10

02 Jul 2009 15:40 AEST

Tim

From: Australia

SBS and FOOTBALL

I was sooo sooo dissapointed and very upset when I heard craig foster on the spors section of SBS News said that AFL is football, and calling Rugby league, Rugby and AFL other codes of football, made me upset. Football is Football, there is NO other sport thats called football, NOT AFL NOT RUGBY LEAGUE

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

02 Jul 2009 15:37 AEST

Tim

From: Australia

Football and News Ltd

BI, I agree with you, its FOOTBALL!!!!

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

02 Jul 2009 15:33 AEST

Tim

From: Australia

Football and News Ltd

When will news Ltd wake up, and realise that Rugby League and AFL are dead? All i see in these 2 sports is players getting into troube or thjey are degrading women. Those 2 sports are also gettin wrecked by their commentaors who everyone is sick of listening to. When will AFL and Rugby league going to stop calling a ball a footy or a football? Football is the biggest sport in the world they must take their blinkers off and stop being self centred.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

21 Jun 2009 8:03 AEST

Chris Fileman

From: Sydney

Telegraph Journo's

Phil Rothfield and the Sydney Telegraph are football haters, always have been. The sooner he realises the game he loves is dying at all levels and gives football the level of and unbiased coverage it deserves the better. The Timmy Cahill affair is just another example of their small mindedness. Long live the world game.

Agree (6 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

20 Jun 2009 22:37 AEST

Mike B

From: Adel

Agree Jesse

I thought you might find it interesting that i "attempted" to post a responce to the above mentioned article on the Tele's website but for some reason my responce was never published. It appears that they don't even support honest debate on their website... Pitty News limited is the only "local" paper we can get in Adelaide because i certinalty wont be buying a paper until something with a little more journalistic integrity is available.

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

20 Jun 2009 16:24 AEST

Muyoyeta

From: Sydney

SBS Twisting football facts

Unfortunately it is not only News Limited, but even SBS as a network are twisting history records just to appease Italian fans. During the Confederation Cup game between Italy and Egypt, your commentator Dave Wood repeatedly kept on saying that it was the first time ever in history that an African national team has beaten an Italian team. This comment was even repeated by the studio host. This is not only highly misleading statement but it is also a clear distortion of facts about football history records. Please be informed that Zambia beat Italy 4-0 in a famous and well documented win at the 1988 Seoul Olympic Games. Therefore to say that an African team has never beaten Italy until yesterday morning Australian Eastern time at the Confederation games is either pure ignorance of football history or a deliberate twist of facts. Please I implore you to go on air and correct this untrue statement and apologise for misleading your viewers. You are a television station with many viewers, many of them look up to you for their source of information.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

20 Jun 2009 2:11 AEST

gerson

From: sydney

Sue the tabloid Timmy

I felt that if Timmy felt he had been defamed or wrongfully accused, he should use his millions and sue the Daily Telegraph. I would if i have enough evidences to prove myself innocents. Some journos in Telegraph are uneducated and they got their jobs through cadetship or social connections and hence their journalistic qualities are sub-standards. If you have read the comments made by Rebecca Wilson or Piers Akerman it'll sometimes boil your brain to the limit!! That's my opinion anyway!!

Agree (2 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

19 Jun 2009 16:00 AEST

mikie

From: Melbourne

bob...

ur a tool. thankfully they do not own the rights to broadcast WC2010. Thank you SBS for the worlds best coverage of the worlds best game. I got a better plan ppls!!! STEAL FOXTELL AND HELP OTHERS DO THE SAME!!!

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

19 Jun 2009 14:28 AEST

bob

From: sydney

HYPOCRITES

So are all you fools calling for a ban on News Limited and Murdoch organisations going to stop watching the Murdoch owned Fox Sports now? No Premier League, no Socceroos matches anymore? What small-minded hypocrites you soccer fans are.

Agree (4 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

19 Jun 2009 10:34 AEST

Yawnography

From: Perth

Sad persecution complex continues - STOP SOOKING

Your blog is another expression of Australian soccer's persecution complex. Tabloid papers do this to every sports star who gets into a kerfuffle at a nightclub, but you interpret it as an attack on soccer. Australian soccer fans have been whingeing for decades about the lack of media promotion. Now you whinge about stock-standard tabloid journalism. I believe the bouncer's version: that a drunk sports star and his cronies were acting like tools. Jesse and soccer people: STOP SOOKING.

Agree (5 people agree)    Disagree (4 people disagree) Report this
 
Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next 10

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.

About this Blog

The Finktank is more of what you've come to expect from Jesse Fink, The World Game's enfant terrible, but with a bent on the big issues in sport. No sport, no personality, no subject, is off limits. 

Jesse Fink Jesse Fink is one of Australia's most popular football writers and sports columnists. He is the author of the book 15 Days in June: How Australia Became a Football Nation (Hardie Grant, $29.95) and writes twice a week as "Half-Time Orange" for The World Game and weekly for ESPN Star Sports in Singapore. He lives in Sydney.

 
ADVERTISEMENT