World Cup war questions Australia's national identity
If Australia's bid for the 2018 or 2022 FIFA World Cup does nothing else it has, at the very least, kick-started a debate about what this nation is today and what the nation may or may not want to be in the future.

Will culturally diverse Australia get behind the bid to host the 2018 or 2022 FIFA World Cups? [GETTY]
- 53 Comments | Join the discussion
The unwitting fire starter has been the now well-publicised and misleading comments by the disingenuous chief executive of the Australian Football League.
As you by now know, AFL boss Andrew Demetriou claimed on one hand he is supportive of the World Cup possibly coming to Australia but revealed a fiery flipside claiming (incorrectly) the tournament might destroy his sport's season, as well as bankrupt a few AFL clubs.
[Side note: As one colleague pointed out to me, "If the AFL and Football Federation Australia have met 14 times in 18 months, as has been claimed, why have they not achieved anything?" Good point.]
This issue has arisen over use of scant venues in Melbourne with Demetriou doing his job as best he could – making sure his Aussie Rules benefits from a football (that's soccer) World Cup being held in his backyard.
But the subtext became headline news.
Melbourne's media and many of the town's footy "celebrities" took Demetriou's calculated stand as the enabler to let loose a whole lot of hate.
This was, in turn, picked up by an element of the great unwashed Melbourne public.
"Soccer" is foreign.
"Soocer" is for cheats.
"Soccer" is un-Australian.
The "indigenous game" is "our great game" (the use of "indigenous" is interesting, using it to signify pride and strength rather than describe a group of people often allowed to live in Third World conditions).
Keep our "Aussie" kids away from soccer, is the message, because before you know it they will want to know what exists beyond the boundaries of Glen Waverley, Footscray, Ballarat, Wodonga, and - even - the horizon.
Meanwhile, the internationalist World Cup cheer squad in the other corner feel the naysayers are a bunch of VB-swilling bogans, village idiots stuck in the 1950s who only care about what's being grilled on the backyard barbie.
Oh, and maybe who won the Preliminary final between Carlton and Hawthorn.
Not that there's anything wrong with that.
Heck, some people even find Daryl Somers and his Hey Hey It's Saturday TV show funny.
Australia's World Cup bid is fast becoming a cultural civil war.
Another battleground is Australia's relationship with the United Kingdom, particularly England.
England, of course, is mounting a bid for 2018, so is a direct rival to Australia's ambition.
Its bid has recently hit the skids but the recently-arrived High Commissioner to Australia (that's an "ambassador" in plain English) has declared England "cares more about 'soccer'" than we do so should host 2018.
Baroness Valerie Amos, for she is she, was previously a member of England's bid committee so should be expected to hold such a view.
"I think England is a place where you have people from across the world who all support 'soccer', as you would say here," she said.
"They would be really interested in going out and supporting teams from right across the world."
"Supporters of football come from everywhere in England. They come from all walks of life, from every part of the country, they are male and female, they are culturally diverse … the next year will be all about making sure people understand how keen we are."
Sound familiar?
The baroness could easily have been speaking about Australia.
Even, perhaps, Melbourne.
:: For those that know about these things, follow me on Twitter here
Comments (53)
21 Jun 2011 17:53 AEST
From: http:
Employee Surveys
Thanks for supporting the idea of Employee Surveys. I’ve seen it create division in senior teams when handled incorrectly and seen transformation happen when used elegantly. It’s all about the intention and skill of those who facilitate the process.
23 May 2011 14:28 AEST
From: sam@cctvdirect.co.uk
No offense to Australia
No offense to Australia or it's many soccer fans but t seems that for a country with economic struggles and reeling from natural disasters to be expending so much time and capital chasing what is ultimately an expensive exposition seems irresponsible. Yes, the world cup does give the host country a small economic boost (only after huge expenses, including the construction of stadiums which later become a burden to maintain and will never again see the same level of attendence as during the games
10 May 2011 17:58 AEST
From: London
Odd Pair
Of course the words ‘soccer’ and ‘Australia’ are an odd pair but not as bad as ‘Russia’ and ‘soccer’.
23 Apr 2011 22:24 AEST
From: sagarbunkar1984@gmail.com
Lets watch
World Cup war questions Australia's national identity article is great but in future what happen lets watch. Yes, I totally agree with this article and just want to say that the article is very good and very informative article.I ensure reading your blog, thanks
03 Jul 2010 17:27 AEST
From: NY
27 Jan 2010 12:35 AEST
From: Melb
Misinformation was started by fairfax soccer journos.
Anyone stating the AFL are over reacting and ignorant - needs to remember it was MIchael Cockerill (SMH Oct 22 2009) who ran the story "Rival codes face two-month Cup shutdown". No surprise the AFL would want to know one way or t'other. FFA still don't know. What's the problem for the FFA to ask? Is the FFA scared? It's not for the AFL to write blank cheques for the FFA. 'No worries' doesn't work. btw - in Oct 2009, the NRL said 'unworkable'. AFL was still offering qualified support.
27 Jan 2010 12:31 AEST
From: Melb
cont - re AFL vs State Govt.
So, for Vic State Govt to 100% fund the Bubbledome for 2 real and 2 imagined (at the time) rectangle code teams whilst drip feeding funding to Melb based AFL clubs (whilst they get screwed to pay for non Govt funded MCG and Docklands) - to then have the FFA suggest the full expansion (as was heralded by State Govt) of Bubbledome to 40,000 + is too hard or too expensive....that is weak by the FFA and the AFL can not let the State Govt off the hook. AFL is fighting Spring St, not the WC bid.
27 Jan 2010 12:28 AEST
From: Melb
Forget the culture subtext - in Melb, is AFL vs State Govt dating back 30 years.
In Melb - the State Govt thwarted the then VFL in expanding VFL park to over 100K and holding their own Finals there. Fully owned/built VFL property. State Govt wanted to keep GF's at MCG. AFL had to put up with MCC members and MCC run archaic property. AFL agree to 40 year contract to fund Great Sth Stand in '92. AFL sells out of VFL park and buys into Docklands. Total non Govt spend on MCG and Docklands is almost $1 billion - tied to AFL long term contracts. Only $77 mill from Govt. tbc
29 Dec 2009 16:02 AEST
From: Palmwoods QLD Australia
African Cup Of Nations 2010
Is SBS Sports going to show the African Cup Of Nations. Cantact me on suoton@bigpond.com Thanks
15 Dec 2009 17:28 AEST
From: melbourne
soccer
THat is a first time in history that you find some stupid people standing against their counrty to bid such a big events like world cup
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
- World Cup war questions Australia's national identity (53)
- Melbourne: Sporting capital of the world (except for the World Cup) (43)
- Is Park Ji-Sung Asia's best ever? (24)
- Nelson Mandela & the Aussie backyard BBQ (invite only) (23)
- Jolly good show, England (19)
- Socceroos to make the World Cup Final? (15)
- In Istanbul, special is normal (13)
- Gaza and the home ground advantage (12)
- Where to now for rugby league? (10)
- Australia's World Cup bid: sugar, tea, & the truth (10)
About this Blog
Sport, without spin, from around the world. Matthew Hall considers the issues behind the headlines and tells the stories that others don't.
Matthew Hall Sport, without spin, from around the world. Matthew Hall considers the issues behind the headlines and tells the stories that others don't. Matt is a writer, author, and filmmaker, originally from Perth, he now lives in Brooklyn, New York.
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Joe Ward
- Tom Palmer
- Bridie O'Donnell
- Sarah van Boheemen
- Stuart Randall
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Kate Bates
- Al Hinds
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Wed 19 Jun 2013 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top
Blog Home 
Previous 10 |
