Rewarding mediocrity: A-League's minor problem
Is it right that Newcastle Jets, who finished 14 points behind "premiers" Sydney FC, can still be crowned A-League "champions"?

Sydney FC captain Steve Corica holds the Premier's Plate aloft, but are the Sky Blues the true champions? [GETTY]
- 4 Comments | Join the discussion
So Sydney FC finished top of 2009/2010 A-League table after playing 27 matches, losing "just" a third of them but winning one more game than closest rivals Melbourne Victory.
Hooray for them.
The past season has been quite a turnaround for the Sky Blues.
Almost as much as it was for Adelaide United who finished in second place last season but were stone-cold last this year.
Sydney's low-key Czech coach Vitezslav Lavicka did exactly as his job description required by making Sydney the best football team in the land.
Didn't he? But what's this?
Sydney FC have won only the "Minor Premiership" – according to many media reports.
It seems Football Federation Australia still has some work to do in branding the achievements of A-League teams.
The governing body claims Sydney became "Premiers" by being the best team over 27 matches.
To demonstrate this, FFA Chairman Frank Lowy presented the team with the Premier's Plate – a trophy that to most of us more resembles a pewter fruit platter.
Yet "minor premiers" prevails.
Of course, having grown up in Western Australia, I know that our sporting culture dictates a "finals series", a four-week crap shoot where what matters is what happens on the day and a poor decision from an errant match official can wreck an entire season's planning.
Australian Rules football competitions (not just the AFL) and rugby league competitions follow this pattern and the A-League (and the National Soccer League before it) has joined the party.
(That FFA Chief Executive Ben Buckley and A-League boss Archie Fraser are former AFL employees has nothing to do with this so conspiracy theories can be kept under the bed, for now.)
Admittedly, it's a great system for adrenaline junkies, especially in high-scoring sports decided by attrition where the strongest team is pretty much guaranteed of winning and results are decided by broad factors.
One of the beauties of the A-League is that mediocrity is rewarded.
A team that finishes sixth – out of 10 teams – gets a chance to be crowned A-League "champion", thanks to this finals format even though Newcastle Jets – for it is they – finished a whole 14 points behind Sydney.
So just who is the best team in Australia this year?
Sydney – who consistently performed better than ever other team in the league over the past six months or the Jets if they can put a run together over the next four weeks?
Like German Pierre Littbarski before him, you can guarantee Sydney coach Lavicka will be telling his mates back home he's steered his team to the top.
Nothing that happens over the "finals series" will convince him or them otherwise.
The rest of us?
Cutting down tall poppies and upsetting the top dog is a national characteristic.
:: For those that know about these things, follow me on Twitter here
Comments (4)
Champions League places for top two league clubs
Keep the finals, but make the Asian Champions League places available only to the top two teams in the league (regular season). That will help fans, and the media, realise what the players and coaches believe is more important - the league season. Everyone will still want to win the grand final for now, but if the finals series dies out - who cares? A cup competition is also an absolute must. That would provide 'finals' type football, that cut-throat environment, but in a more traditional football sense.
17 Feb 2010 8:33 AEST
From: Sydney
Yes it's a MAJOR premiership, but what's wrong with finals?
They are something distinctly Australian, the atmosphere at them is great, the fans love them and they rate well. If Newcastle can navigate their way through a series of sudden death away matches to win the title, more power to them. I'd rather take steps to ensure that Breeze etc don't stuff the finals up, than do away with them all together.
16 Feb 2010 20:28 AEST
From: Perth
Cup Tournament instead
It is high time that the A-League scrapped the archaic and AFL-like finals system and instead made the grand prize the premiership which is what Sydney have already won. I have said it before many times to people - we need a cup competition to take place during the season instead with the final for that to be played after the end of the regular season. This would allow for more games and could possibly be a way to bring in state premier league teams to compete against A-League sides - more exposure for the clubs, more interest in young up and coming second tier players, great for the game.
16 Feb 2010 16:55 AEST
From: sydney
Rewarding mediocrity: A-League's minor problem
Mate, you said it all. After a whole season of playing your best football to be top dog, you have to pick yourself up and do it all over again for 4 weeks for a "premiership winners medal". What for? Haven't Sydney FC done that already? But from a financial standpoint it pays to have a finals playoff. Finals playoff games draw so many more fans, it brings extra cash, sponsors vie for extra exposure, TV gets more viewers etc. An unfortunate but seemingly necessary evil for football to continue to exist as a spectator sport in Australia.
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
- World Cup war questions Australia's national identity (53)
- Melbourne: Sporting capital of the world (except for the World Cup) (43)
- Is Park Ji-Sung Asia's best ever? (24)
- Nelson Mandela & the Aussie backyard BBQ (invite only) (23)
- Jolly good show, England (19)
- Socceroos to make the World Cup Final? (15)
- In Istanbul, special is normal (13)
- Gaza and the home ground advantage (12)
- Where to now for rugby league? (10)
- Australia's World Cup bid: sugar, tea, & the truth (10)
About this Blog
Sport, without spin, from around the world. Matthew Hall considers the issues behind the headlines and tells the stories that others don't.
Matthew Hall Sport, without spin, from around the world. Matthew Hall considers the issues behind the headlines and tells the stories that others don't. Matt is a writer, author, and filmmaker, originally from Perth, he now lives in Brooklyn, New York.
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Joe Ward
- Tom Palmer
- Bridie O'Donnell
- Sarah van Boheemen
- Stuart Randall
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Kate Bates
- Al Hinds
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Sat 25 May 2013 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top
Blog Home 

17 Feb 2010 13:12 AEST
S.Hope
From: Fremantle