Close to 98 years after the sinking of the then world’s largest vessel,
the SBS documentary drama Unsinkable Titanic is a reminder of
the potential vulnerability of ships at sea, says Bob Wurth.

- 10 Comments | Join the discussion
When subjected to the vagaries of nature, technical miscalculation and bad luck mixed with human frailty, it’s a truism that no ship is unsinkable.
Ever bigger ships are being built. Some gigantic liners are now of more than 220,000 gross tons and carry 6400 souls and every conceivable safety device.
The improvements in technology built into today’s ships and advances in navigation and communication, ensure that everything humanly possible is done to prevent disaster, and if calamity strikes, to effect a speedy rescue.
But it is this human factor that consistently has been found wanting.
The tale of the so-called ‘unsinkable’ RMS Titanic, which struck an iceberg and sunk on April 15, 1912 with the loss of 1,517 lives, is a case in point. Although the technology that went into the Titanic is some 100 years old, there are still lessons to be learned about the human factor.
Unsinkable Titanic, directed by Patrick Reams, not only takes us through the well-known litany of miscalculations and blunders, including unexpected flooding over five bulkheads and the owner’s reduction of 48 lifeboats to 16, but it also explores another, newer reason for the liner sinking so rapidly.
Scientist and author, Jennifer Hooper McCarty, discovered flaws with some of the rivets used in fixing the plates of the Titanic. The shipbuilders used both steel and wrought iron rivets. Under an electron-microscope, McCarty found large slag impurities embedded in the structure of the wrought iron rivets.
"It created a weakness in the heads of the rivets. During the collision that night those weak rivets couldn’t withstand the force and their heads popped. As a result of them those rivets next to them had to carry more load and those heads popped and so you get an unzipping of the seam along the starboard side."
Human nature played a major part, the production insists. The builders of the Titanic allegedly didn’t order the purest grade of wrought iron, but settled for a lower grade with impurities.
"If you have good wrought iron," says McCarty, "you don’t have that weakness... the rivet will fail, but it’s going to last a little longer and 1,500 people – their lives would have been saved. And then a boat could have gotten there and rescued people before the ship was doomed."
The Titanic’s builders, Harland and Wolff, deny McCarty’s rivets theory.
Disbelieving Australian tourists were among the 1,195 passengers of the MV Sea Diamond which hit a reef in calm waters inside the caldera of the fabled Greek island of Santorini on April 5, 2007.
Some were huddled in lifeboats that had to be chopped free from davits only to crash many decks to the water below. That evening the passenger ship rolled over and sank. A Frenchman and his daughter were lost.
An investigation appears to have cleared the shipowner and master, according to shipping experts writing in Lloyd’s List. Court appointed experts reportedly agree that the Sea Diamond hit a reef 130 metres from shore when it is marked on charts as being only 57 metres from shore.
Could another passenger ship sink after hitting an iceberg in view of the lessons from the Titanic? Surely not?
Well, in fact, one passenger ship did go down only seven months after the 2007 sinking off Santorini. The small cruise ship MS Explorer with 154 passengers and crew aboard struck submerged ice in Antarctica near the South Shetland Islands.
A nearby Norwegian cruise ship plucked the survivors from their lifeboats.
Lawyers will continue to debate responsibility for sinkings at sea, but so often the human factor is there in disasters and - as every mariner knows - there still is no room whatsoever for complacency.
Comments (10)
Previous 10 |
Page 1
| Next 10
30 Dec 2010 13:33 AEST
From: adelaide
the unsinkable titanic documentary
any chance to repeat this episode in the lost worlds series? the unsinkable titanic was first shown in Feb 2010 would love to watch it again please thanks kats
03 Mar 2010 22:28 AEST
From: Australia
Yes the theory of the dodgy rivetts has been done before. I didn't realise the key for the binoculars had been removed. I didn't realise the bulkheads had been moved.
03 Mar 2010 19:36 AEST
From:
Worst Narration ever
I just finished watching Unsinkable Titanic and felt compelled to google "unsinkable titanic narrator" It came up with the Channel 4 webpage. Quite a few other SBS watchers left comments there too. I leave this comment not from a sense of annoyance but of curiousity to how such a polished doco copped a third rate narration. The narrator sounded like a high school teenager reading her essay to the class. I found it quite distracting to an otherwise polished doco. No real problem given that SBS is still one of the best TV channels in the world.
23 Feb 2010 21:44 AEST
From: Sydney
Titanic documentary
Glad to see that something is being done about any future showing of this doco. I would however, like to know the source of the program. Was it the National Geographic Channel as part of their "Seconds from Disaster Series? Or a UK Channel 4 program? Either way it was a pretty poor documentary with nothing new to add to the story of the tragedy.
22 Feb 2010 16:18 AEST
From:
Narration
SBS would like to apologise for the version of "Unsinkable Titanic" broadcast last night. The narration on the version we received did not match the original narration on the documentary. We will be receiving a new version with corrected audio which will be used for future broadcasts.
22 Feb 2010 13:19 AEST
From: Perth
Narration
Interesting doc but who on earth did the voice-over? It was the most amateurish thing I had ever heard and was also very distracting.
22 Feb 2010 9:25 AEST
From:
Interesting ... but the bogan voice-over was so bad I couldn't concentrate much on the actual content!
21 Feb 2010 21:04 AEST
From: Adelaide
Just confirms most accidents/disasters are never due to just a single cause or reason
21 Feb 2010 20:40 AEST
From:
21 Feb 2010 20:39 AEST
From: hobart
this documentary brought no new information to light following the sinking of the titanic. Study into these bulk head and rivit issues have been investigated thoroughly since the ship sank and for this woman to claim them as her own investigations degrades those who have worked so hard. the narration/voice over was appauling. some good recreations - but not much. 2/10
Previous 10 |
Page 1
| Next 10
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
About this Blog
Bob Wurth's books include 'Justice in the Philippines' and 'Saving Australia' and he was a contributor to Dorothy Horsfield’s 'Paul Lyneham, a Memoir'.
Bob Wurth Bob Wurth is a journalist and author based on Queensland's Sunshine Coast. He has written four books on the Asia-Pacific region, including 1942, Australia's Greatest Peril, and Capturing Asia, which is to be published by ABC Books in June, 2010.
Wurth is a former ABC news editor, foreign correspondent in Asia, and ABC manager for both Asia and Queensland. He has traveled Asia extensively.
He was the 2009 visiting scholar to the John Curtin Prime Ministerial Library and a fellow at the Australian Prime Ministers' Centre, Canberra.
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Joe Ward
- Tom Palmer
- Bridie O'Donnell
- Sarah van Boheemen
- Stuart Randall
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Kate Bates
- Al Hinds
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Sat 25 May 2013 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top
Blog Home 
