Using the 'what if?' approach to history, Rory Medcalf argues the pros and cons of alternatives to the Vietnam War.

- 4 Comments | Join the discussion
Can a couple of bullets really seal the fate of millions? Virtual JFK
introduces audiences to virtual or counterfactual history - the 'what
if?' scenario. It asks: what would have become of the Vietnam War if
President John F. Kennedy had survived the assassin's bullet in 1963 and
been re-elected in 1964? Would there have been a Vietnam War at all?
It is all well and good to say that Napoleon would have won the battle
of Waterloo had he made more sensible breakfast choices (and thus not
been plagued by stomach ulcers, constipation or other digestive
ailments), or that the Roman world would have skipped a vicious civil
war if Cleopatra's nose had been shorter or Mark Antony avowedly gay, or
that Europe's golden age would have continued if Archduke Ferdinand's
car had taken a different street in Sarajevo in 1914, or that there
would have been no Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989 if a few of the
Chinese Communist Party's faceless men had been less worried about their
next promotion.
However, if we're going to do virtual history properly, we need to go
further than this documentary and think about how one player's choice
intersects with another's, and put together an argument about where all
this leads in the long term. Sometimes in history, what seems the right
decision at the time turns out to have all sorts of unintended,
unforeseen consequences - good intentions do not always yield good
results.
This example of counterfactual history asks the right question - and
builds a strong and riveting case through narrative, logic and images to
prove that this is the right question - but then barely begins to give
the answer.
The case that JFK would have opted out of Vietnam is built using
illuminating examples of Kennedy's decision-making on questions of war
or restraint. These include the Cuban missile crisis, that horrendous 13
days in 1962 when the world came to the brink of
nuclear conflagration and when the US military bluntly saw war as the
only choice; the little-known beginnings of the conflict in Laos; and
also the Berlin Wall confrontation, when the president personally had to
stop provocative US tank deployments.
The documentary leaves us in little doubt that a second Kennedy
Administration would not have opted for the creeping military enmeshment
in a Vietnamese civil war, let alone the wholesale deployment of
hundreds of thousands of young Americans and the massive unleashing of
air power, napalm and the rest.
But what would have happened next? Would the 1960s have been a decade of
peace, light and love if the United States had decided that Vietnam was
not its problem? The alternatives to the Vietnam War might have been
bad, too. And how differently would the Cold War have turned out?
For completeness, it would be fair to ask Southeast Asians today what
they think of the war and what might have been. There would still have
been conflict and suffering, even if on a much smaller scale. No matter
how distasteful it might be, there's an argument quietly prevalent in
some circles that the Vietnam War bought time for most of the
recently-independent nations of Southeast Asia to develop with relative
peace and protection, and that it is one of the reasons why most of Asia
for the past few decades has been calmer and more prosperous than at any
other time in history.
Previous Post
|
Next Post
Comments (4)
Born to lead and make peace
JFK was born to be a leader and this can be seen in the interviews we see of him answering questions. Always articulate and responses with great ease. There is no doubt there would not have been a Vietnem war had JFK lived. In fact, perhaps we should consider where the world would be today had he lived.
11 Dec 2010 0:19 AEST
From: Wales
Can we see this in the uk sometime?
I'm probably not the only physicist who speculates about all of the other possible histories and would love to see the comment and opinion of others. For example, could the world have switched production off tanks guns and gas guzzlers in 1995 when the climate change hockey stick chart became obvious, and activated full speed installation of windmills and solar, to avoid having the 2003 second Iraq oil war? worries*worries=worries^2 and alternate histories look like worries^N with very large N. So how to we pick the best future for everyone else who follows our generation? In my opinion, maximisation of GDP is the wrong goal and gets chosen for us by the rich people, as illustrated in the '60's by some choices related to Kennedy.
18 Oct 2010 8:26 AEST
From: Australia
Kennedy counter-history
Great hot-doc this one was, a great companion to the Robert mcNamara "12 things I learned in war and business" one played a year or two back on SBS.I love things about the Kennedy-johnson-nixon era in America.
08 Oct 2010 7:06 AEST
From: Queensland
Response to Making History
If you were to shakedown one particular draft dodging Deputy Sheriff, Menzies dejavu, Australia would never have been involved in Vietnam, Iraq or Afghanistan if certain lying bastards were less worried about the next election.
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
About this Blog
Rory
Medcalf worked variously as an intelligence analyst, diplomat and
journalist before joining the Lowy Institute in March 2007.
Rory Medcalf In a wide-ranging career, Rory Medcalf has specialised in understanding the politics of war and peace.
He has worked as an intelligence analyst, diplomat and journalist, studied conflicts first-hand from Kashmir to the Pacific to Northern Ireland, and now directs the international security program for the Lowy Institute in Sydney. His formal diplomatic
experience included a posting to New Delhi, a secondment to Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, truce monitoring following the civil war on Bougainville, and contributing to nuclear disarmament projects including the Canberra Commission on the Elimination of Nuclear Weapons. He then served as a senior strategic analyst with the Office of National Assessments, Australia's peak intelligence agency.
Rory's earlier work as a newspaper journalist was commended in the Walkley awards. He
maintains a close interest in India, and convenes unofficial dialogues between Australian and Indian policy thinkers.
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Joe Ward
- Tom Palmer
- Bridie O'Donnell
- Sarah van Boheemen
- Stuart Randall
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Kate Bates
- Al Hinds
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Wed 22 May 2013 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top

21 Nov 2011 1:49 AEST
Harpo Marx
From: Australia