Cadel can still do it

25 October 2010 | 0:00 - By Anthony Tan

With the presentation of the next year’s Tour and Giro announced, Anthony Tan’s certain Cadel Evans can win either – or both – if all goes to plan.

evans_310_aap_604507201

Cadel Evans (L) and American teammate George Hincapie at the 2010 Tour de France (AAP)

“Certainly, I think two or three would be [possible]… Conservatively, I’d say two.”

This was the response from a battered and bruised Cadel Evans on July 20 this year, the evening following the sixteenth stage of the 2010 Tour de France. At his team hotel on the outskirts of Pau, a famous spa town in thrall to the mighty Pyrenean mountains, I paid him a visit and asked him straight-up: “Realistically, how many chances do you think you have left to win the Tour de France?”

It turned out Evans was a little more than bruised. Pummelled might have been more apt a term.

A week and a half previous, his crash six kilometres into the eighth stage to Morzine-Avoriaz created a hairline fracture of his left elbow and although he took the maillot jaune that day, the incident would precipitate an insidious series of events over the following 48 hours, causing him to fall out of contention in the most inhumane way possible.

That for the next fortnight, he doggedly battled on all the way to Paris was just another defining moment in the career of perhaps the gutsiest modern day cycling champion of the 21st century; that he finished an anonymous 26th overall, 50 minutes and 27 seconds behind Alberto Contador, is irrelevant.

So... with two bona-fide chances left, and possibly three, I guess what all Australian cycling fans want to know is: Does the parcours of the 2011 Tour lend itself to a rider of Evans’ characteristics and capabilities?

Regardless of the course, I can say Cadel’s characteristics and capabilities lend themselves to Grand Tours, full-stop. So even before the route of the Tour, and this past weekend, the Giro d’Italia, was announced, the parcours favours him.

Why?

Well, as BMC’s sports doctor, the renowned Max Testa, told me at this year’s Tour: “I think Cadel is a special combination, somebody definitely very physiologically gifted and also mentally strong. Cadel is probably the rider who covers all the possibilities: a good time trialist, and he can climb with the best climbers.”

The four mountain-top finishes and two hilltop finishes make this 2011 Tour the most climber-friendly in recent history, and the seven summit finishes at the 2011 Giro do likewise for that race.

What’s more, given the downward trend in ITTs at the Tour de France since 2006 – 116km, 117km, 82km, 55km, 59km and now just 41km (excluding team time trials) – organisers ASO clearly want a pure climber to win next year’s edition of La Grande Boucle.

Gifted against the clock he may be, I don’t believe the lack of individual time trials – 41 and 46.5 kilometres, respectively – will affect Evans’ chances at winning either race, for the reasons Testa’s mentioned. His ability to adapt to the course, rather than bemoan the lack of time trialing kilometres or steep mountains or whatever, is one of the Victorian’s greatest assets.

From what I saw at both the Giro and Tour, the greatest area for improvement in terms of enhancing Evans’ chances of winning a Grand Tour before he retires is the strength of his team. This was particularly evident at this year’s Giro, where he found himself either caught out in a dangerous situation, unsheltered from the elements, or alone when chasing down a breakaway.

That BMC Racing’s owner and team manager, Andy Rihs and John Lelangue, have addressed the shortfall by signing eight new recruits so far including Manuel Quinziato and Ivan Santaromita (from Liquigas-Doimo), Greg Van Avermaert (Omega Pharma-Lotto) and the recently-crowned American U23 World TT champ, Taylor Phinney (Trek-Livestrong), bodes very well indeed.

And should he decide to ride both the Giro and Tour, BMC’s power upgrade will surely be noticeable when it comes to the team time trials: 21.5km on Stage 1 (Giro) and 23km on Stage 2 (Tour) – let’s not forget that abysmal performance by Silence-Lotto at the 2009 Tour, where Evans’ team conceded two-and-a-half minutes to Astana over 39km around Montpellier.

For Evans at least, I somewhat disagree with Team Sky Sean Yates’ assessment that the majority of Tour contenders will likely skip the Giro because of its difficulty: “I’m not expecting many of the Tour favourites to be competing because I think it’s simply going to be too hard to do both races in such a short space of time,” he said after the presentation of the 94th edition of ‘la Corsa Rosa’ Saturday in Turin, the start town of the 2011 race.

If the past two years have shown anything, it’s that Cadel is capable of riding well in two Grand Tours per season, and excluding circumstance and bad luck, he generally goes better in the second. In fact, it was at January’s Tour Down Under where he said to me it was his performance at the 2009 Vuelta a España that convinced him it was so.

“Previously, I had a bit of preconceived doubt [about riding two Grand Tours in one season), but last year, I proved to people that matter to me – me and my coach [Aldo Sassi] – that we could do it. I think I’m one rider who’s capable of doing two good Grand Tours in one year, and 2010’s the year to find out,” he said.

We’ll never know how Evans would have fared had he not fractured his arm at the Tour, or how he would have gone had he not been so alone at the Giro.

But enough ifs and buts. What I know – and I’m sure Cadel does, too – is that he’s still very much in the running to win either.

Or, should everything go perfectly next year, possibly both.

In a future blog, I’ll discuss what Evans told me is one of his strengths, which can also be an impediment when it comes to targeting three-week Tours.

Share article: 
top

Comments (10)

Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | Next 10

31 Oct 2010 21:50 AEST

Carlitos

From: Sydney

--

From what i saw of Contador and Andy this year, Cadel has no hope unless one of two things happen with the other two. They get banned for doping or they have bad luck. On talent and ability he has no chance.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (5 people disagree) Report this
 

29 Oct 2010 9:16 AEST

Rob

From: Hampton

--

This article is great, it put the facts out there. Cadel is a once in a generation rider and we are lucky to be witnessing his career develop. Remember, with a little bit of luck, Cadel would be a two time TdF and one time Vuelta champion already.

Agree (25 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

27 Oct 2010 12:55 AEST

tim

From: melbourne

--

how can max testa say cadel can climb with the best climbers. surely this is the fundamental issue - in the clinch cadel can't match schleck and contador on the mountains (the best climbers), this has been proven and it is not going to change at his age. whats more his time trial strength late in a grand tour like anyone's can not be as consistent, andy schleck proved that this year when he was strong in a time trial at the back end of a tour - but he is no time trialist. he's a great rider but his best chances are behind him

Agree (5 people agree)    Disagree (40 people disagree) Report this
 

26 Oct 2010 17:42 AEST

Rich

From: Sydney

--

If Contador races the TDF, I think he's unbeatable at the moment so personally I'd like to see Cadel race the giro and the Vuelta to give him the best chance of winning a grand tour. Realistically, i realise that BMC need him to ride the Tour to get a return on their investment. Given how difficult the Giro looks this year, I can't see Cadel backing up for a decent shot at the Tour if he does the Giro first. I say, ride the Tour and the Vuelta like 09. It's great to see more positive chat about Cadel after his fantastic 2010.

Agree (41 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

26 Oct 2010 12:50 AEST

Christian

From: Camden

--

Individually Cadel can win a tour, but when he is one man against strong teams it is hard. I still recall the attacked from Sastre and both Schlecks back in 2008, how can anyone combat that ? Hopefully BMC is strong next year, they looked pretty good in the 2010 our so a little more talent and experience with help. Fingers crossed he finishes his career with at least one Grand Tour under his belt, I don't care which, but he deserves one. Nice artcle Anthony.

Agree (20 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

26 Oct 2010 12:33 AEST

Heath

From: Toowoomba

--

I would love Cadel to go to both the Giro and Tour however I feel this year proved to back up at the Tour will be too much, particularly with the Mountain stages on the 2011 Giro. Basso certainly faded in week three of the Tour this year after a very strong win in the Giro, and it would of been interesting to see how Cadel went injury free in the third week. I also think Contador and Schleck will prove to strong in the coming years for Cadel to upstage them in the Tour. Just quickly the photo of Cadel winning stage 7 at the Giro would have to be the best cycling pic of the year!

Agree (18 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

25 Oct 2010 22:40 AEST

Mike

From: Brighton

--

Agree with Sam from Perth. Too many writers on this site not objective about Cadel....the Tommo dribble about Andy Schleck a good example. I wonder if Andy or Contador could have finished the tour in 26th place had they fractured their elbow, not had strong team support and in Andy's case had Cancellara protest when Andy was behind and have the leaders wait for him. Hoping Cadel silences all the crictics. Apart from Quinziato, Santaromita, Van Avermaert & Phinney, BMC also recruited some strong climbers Moinard who road well at TDF, Tschopp who won Stage 20 of the Giro over the Gavia pass and the youngster Yannick Eijssen. This bodes well for Cadel.

Agree (60 people agree)    Disagree (20 people disagree) Report this
 

25 Oct 2010 18:22 AEST

Andy

From: Sydney

--

I dont think that there is any chance of riding that Giro route and backing up for the tour. I think Cadel should go into the tour at 100% freshness and ride a Ardennes Dauphine Tour Vuelta calender like in 09. Sure that wasnt his best tour but his form in the Dauphine matched contador's and his form in the Vuelta matched Valverde's so if he hits form at the right time he can beat anyone. The only bad thing about that plan is that he would most likely miss the TDU and we wouldnt see him in another GT for another 9 months!

Agree (40 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

25 Oct 2010 17:01 AEST

Sam

From: Perth

--

One of your best pieces, Anthony. Hopefully you can influence your friend phil gomes that cadel can win the tour also. Some of his articles and other writers articles on this site were very uncalled for during and after the tour about Cadel. Some posters were also not very fair on Cadel also. He can win the tour!!!! Don't give up on him!!!

Agree (35 people agree)    Disagree (4 people disagree) Report this
 

25 Oct 2010 15:45 AEST

Dallas

From: Waitara

--

Good article I concur Cadel has what it takes to win a Tour!

Agree (52 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 
Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | Next 10

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.