A criterium question

06 January 2012 | 10:00 - By Philip Gomes

Which is more prestigious? A stage or series victory at the Jayco Bay Cycling Classic criteriums or a national championship in that discipline, asks Philip Gomes.

giacoppo_640_gunter_1908370607

Anthony Giacoppo, National Criterium Champion (Mark Gunter)

Sorry to say but it's very likely that each of the four Jayco Bay Classic Criteriums are more prestigious than tonight's Aus Crit Champs. The above was a very interesting tweet from Australian cycling legend Scott McGrory last night, prior to the opening event at the Mars Cycling Australia National Road Championships.

Now to a certain extent I get Scott's point. And who is better placed to make that point than a former Bay Crit stage winner and Olympic Gold Medal winning speed demon?

And Scott had Twitter support in the form of SBS's cycling analyst David McKenzie, which makes that view hard to argue against, but I'll give it a shot anyway.

By any objective measure the Bay Crits sported a deep and classy field, but what did that depth mean given that the early season start and style of racing was unlikely to suit some riders?

The four race series was largely a leg stretcher for the majority, particularly the WorldTour guys who have a long season ahead of them.

It was also obvious at the Bay Crits many of the big hitters were keeping their powder dry for the main games to come, the road nationals and the Santos Tour Down Under.

At least at the national criterium championship race you had a self selecting field more likely to be skilled and motivated in that short fast form of racing, which in theory makes for a better competition.

And then there is the fact that the field at the Bay Crits was beaten twice, by a 17 year-old.

Yes, young Caleb Ewan looks the goods as a future pro but I'd suggest his wins could also be attributed to elite riders running with engines yet to be fully tuned.

So, pedals were turned at the Bay Crits but probably not with as much anger as you would see if something really serious was on the line.

And at the criterium championships that is exactly what was happening - there was a green and gold motivator.

I'd agree that the criterium championship is secondary to the prestige of an open road title but wearing the green and gold for a year at races around the world or at home is something that matters in a way that a Bay Crits jersey does not, no matter the event.

And I have no doubt our new national champions, Genesys Wealth Advisers Anthony Giacoppo, and Alexis Rhodes of the GreenEDGE-AIS squad sees the green and gold they are going to wear on several continents this year, as more important than any stage win at the Bay Crits.

Of course there is an easy solution to this little debate. Make the overall winner of the Bay Crits the National Criterium Champion.

Sure it wouldn't be a part of the official national championships week but it's a perfect fit and I reckon you would have a winner beyond reproach.

Twitter: @Philip_Gomes

Share article: 
top

Comments (10)

Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | Next 10

08 Jan 2012 9:30 AEST

Dave

From: Sydney

Two issues with making the winner of the bay crits the national champion. One, to fit in with the new non-open format that would exclude any foreign riders from the bay crits which may reduce the quality of the field. not really true this year but maybe in others. Two hate the fact a rider that did not win a race would go on to be national champion.

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 19:20 AEST

Lucho Herrera

From: Colombia

I think i'd prefer to see a national Hill Climb championship. Maybe then Australia would produce a guy who is a natural climber of world class quality, and not just another sprinter/rouleur type.

Agree (8 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 14:41 AEST

SlowRider

From: Gungahlin

"My only doubt with this idea is that you could end up with a national Crit Champion who didn't actually win a single stage of the event" - Just like at any of the grand tours...

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 14:34 AEST

Sprinter

From: Queensland

You're on your own here I fear Scott McGrory. Surprisng comment for a man who wore the national colours on many occasions. The Bay Crits are great but give me a national title anytime.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 12:34 AEST

josh

From: Creswick

I seem to recall there was a time when the National Criterium Championships was incorporated in the Bay Crits. It didn't work and so the event is a stand-alone in Ballarat - and rightly so. It's a championshp and not a "Mickey Mouse" season warm-up to stretch the legs as the Bay Crits usually are.

Agree (7 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 11:38 AEST

Andrew

From: Hobart

Perhaps it comes down to scheduling? If like in the past it was Crit on Wed, TT or Fri and RR on Sunday then it may have given the Crit/RR guys an extra day to recover? Cannot question the validity of the championship if Greenedge riders do not wish to partake for a chance to wear a National jersey. You can't decide national title with Bay Crits if international riders are included as per RR. If it has to be then include Ballarat and make it double points? At the end of the day a worthy podium

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 11:18 AEST

snappydon

From: adelaide

My only doubt with this idea is that you could end up with a national Crit Champion who didn't actually win a single stage of the event

Agree (5 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 10:59 AEST

Django

From: West Sydney

Gomes, you're misconstruing Mcgrory's point. He was talking about the EVENT, not the title. The Crit Champs featured a reduced field from GE, whereas the Bay series saw most of them racing. Prestige is a judgement made by the audience, it doesn't have to be a 'correct' one. Full credit to AJ, though, as Renshaw and Hoff are by no means chumps.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 10:51 AEST

Robert Merkel

From: Melbourne

Nice idea. The only problem is that it would exclude the "honorary Aussies" who compete at the Bay Crits, such as Greg Henderson and Koen de Kort on the men's side, and Judith Arndt in the women's.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Jan 2012 10:12 AEST

GrahamWKidd

From: Kew

Dear Lycra Lout, Absolutely spot on. Make the Bay Crits winner the Aussie National Crit champ. Even include a Crit in Ballarat as part of the Bay's, to keep Ballarat happy.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 
Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | Next 10

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.