If we are to embrace the true spirit of sport, the national road titles should not have their place cast in stone, argues an obstreperous Anthony Tan.

Mathew Hayman leads the peloton at the Mars Cycling Australia Road National Championships (Mark Gunter)
- 30 Comments | Join the discussion
Over time, the jersey will lose some of its lustre because Buninyong rewards only a certain type of rider. I respectfully disagree with latest blog to emerge from chez Mike
Tomalaris, ‘Don’t bounce Buninyong’. (I warned him about skolling
copious amounts of Kool-Aid from the Ballarat corner store.)
It
was a great elite men’s race, one of the best in years, as many of you
have already said – that much I agree. However, that doesn’t mean as
long as the national road title is held on the Buninyong circuit, it
will always be great race.
If you want to use your argument,
Tomo, then we might as well run the Tour de France route over the same
parcours as last year for the next 20 years, because that was a great
race and had massive crowds, too!
For the overwhelming majority of other countries, the national road championship is held on a different parcours each year.
Doing
so encourages, not detracts, interest (each year, how much is the Tour
course analysed, dissected and debated before a pedal is turned?); it
also produces different types of winners; and it does not favour those
whose have ridden more than a few national titles on the same circuit.
I’m
all for rewarding experience, but race experience – not experience in
terms of familiarity with the course itself. The latter should only be
reserved for the Monuments of the sport – San Remo, Flanders, Roubaix,
Liège and Lombardy – and even those intransigent elderly beings have
their route modified from time to time.
* * *
Let’s face
it: as exciting as Sunday’s race was, “it was always going to come down
to three or four”, as Matt Lloyd, eventual second on the day, said, both
before and afterwards.
Why should the likes of Mark Renshaw, Mat
Hayman, Michael Matthews, Chris Sutton, Bernard Sulzberger et al – all
worthy champions, I think you’d agree – keep showing up, when, even in
top nick, they stand little-to-no-chance of claiming the coveted green
and gold jersey?
Yes, Robbie McEwen won the title in Buninyong in
2002 but that was then; comparatively, a much weaker field. Much has
changed in 10 years, not least the depth of riders Australia now boasts –
hence the split in the men’s elite and under-23 fields (from 2007
onwards), and, for the first time this year, restriction to those
holding anything other than an Australian racing licence.
Isn’t
the essence of sport about giving all competitors a fair go? Over time, I
imagine, the jersey will lose some of its lustre because Buninyong
rewards only a certain type of rider.
If other States, such as
New South Wales, Western Australia and the Northern Territory, are not
as strong in terms of their cycling fraternities, then one way of
attracting those into the sport and building less established
communities would be to stage a marquee event like the national road
titles, no?
And for those States that are well established –
Tasmania and Queensland come to mind – then let’s see what they have to
offer and discover why they’ve become hotbeds of cycling talent.
While
we’re at it, why not alternate with one year in regional/country area,
one year in a capital city? Do we have to be so steadfast or defeatist
and say it’s too hard, too expensive, too highbrow, too whatever?
* * *
Since
I’m high on my soapbox, can people stop calling it an individual race?
(Those who continue to spruik so must think we’re thick as Chris Hoy’s
legs.) The GreenEDGE guys may have paid for their own entry fees but
that’s about the extent of their individual commitments, getting
themselves to Ballarat aside.
Let me demonstrate by way of some
quotes from our worthy winner Simon Gerrans, from the official press
release: “I just capped off some great teamwork from GreenEDGE today, I
am so proud of all of the guys”; “with a couple of laps to go, Cameron
Meyer ran out of gas and it became an even playing field as we had the
same amount of guys at the front as a lot of other teams, so it was
pretty much every team for itself and we lost our advantage”; “we just
really tried to dominate the race with numbers at GreenEDGE”.
To
quote a famous Tweet from Lance Armstrong, after he and Alberto Contador
butted heads at the 2009 Tour de France: There is no ‘I’ in team.
So
good was Gerro Sunday, he may well have won the race on his own.
Nonetheless, after Cam Meyer blew like a trumpet player in the West
Australian Symphony Orchestra, his GreenEDGE team-mates placed him the
best position possible, which, quite naturally, he took full advantage
of.
I also think in the spirit of fair play, teams should be
restricted to seven riders. To have the next largest ProTeam
representation (that being Team Sky, who fielded four men) just a
quarter the size of Le Groupe GreenEDGE makes for a lopsided race.
Again,
should this become enforced, regularly changing the course would ensure
most, if not all, Australian GreenEDGE riders would get a run.
A
credit to all involved, Buninyong/Ballarat has been and is the
bellwether for future national championships – but that does not mean
they should stay there. If, by next year, it’s too hard to change the
location, then please, Mister Craven and Cycling Australia, at least
change the course.
Twitter: @anthony_tan
Comments (30)
16 Jan 2012 15:39 AEST
From: adelaide
Totally different context, so rack off. It's ours. btw: they actually *change* the course from year to year.
13 Jan 2012 10:31 AEST
From: Mentone
To open another can of worms the same could be said of the TDU, should it move to other states as well?
13 Jan 2012 6:44 AEST
From: Brisbane Qld
It is still technically an individual event is correct obviously its raced as a team event. I agree best practice would be change the course every so often. This years was a fantastic event and those that enjoy the style of racing such as Tomo we saw on Sunday would want this course again, others not. If it were a flat sprinters course with a team train for a sprinter I would think the arguement then would be that course needs to change. No course is going to make everyone 100% happy.
12 Jan 2012 12:35 AEST
From: Melbourne
The World Championship RR was a sprint finish, yet it was anything but boring
12 Jan 2012 11:42 AEST
From:
Cynical I know but did anyone else ponder the pro and con opinions coming a day apart to get the debate flowing? It may be contrived but it is a very good discussion with both sides having merit. At the end of the day the ultimate decision will not be cycling based but will depend on a willing host city, sponsors and the corporate bang for buck. Ballarat had a crack and won the rights because it ticked all of the boxes listed above.
12 Jan 2012 10:28 AEST
From:
Ummm, Frank? You're making it sound like they only do the climb once.
12 Jan 2012 0:13 AEST
From: Melbourne
A Nats road race with a high liklyhood of a bunch sprint finish is just a very long means to an end, does not reward individual effort like the current course & is mostly boring viewing. What are the Crit nationals if not a forum for a sprinter to display his sprinting ability? Still green and gold up for grabs. I would prefer that our champion is a rider willing to pull himself inside out to win rather than a rider who keeps out of the wind for 99% of the race & then pops out for the win.
11 Jan 2012 21:44 AEST
From: Casino
Must agree with the Tan man, we could become very boring!
11 Jan 2012 15:54 AEST
From: Robe
10 Jan 2012 22:02 AEST
From: SA
Grand Tours and National titles internationally do change their venues and routes, but only after towns and cities make it known they want the event, and compete for the right to host. So, if not Buningyong, where? Who else exactly is making it known they definitely want to host the Australian National Championships?
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
- TdF Files: It’s in the bag (101)
- TdF Files: Defying logic (87)
- Gun-shy ‘bout Bertie (66)
- On shallow ground (59)
- TdF Files: Historic, euphoric (49)
- Tour Files: The Teflon Spaniard (46)
- TdF Files: Unforgettable (45)
- TdF Files: Seeing is believing (41)
- TdF Files: Stalemate (40)
- How'd you like d'em apples? (32)
About this Blog
Anthony Tan
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
- Ricardo's Business
- 180 degrees
- Reporters' Blog
- The Hashtag
- The Other World Game
- Window on Africa
- Pop, Cultured
- PJ's Notebook
- The Sweet Spot
- Back of the.net
- Source Code
- The Road to 2012
- Candid Canberra
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Al Hinds
- Sophie Smith
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Thu 24 May 2012 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top
Blog Home 
Previous 10 |
