Julia Scott-Stevenson

Julia is a writer and researcher of all things documentary, and even dabbles in making them herself from time to time.

Top ten innovative archival documentaries

20 March 2012 | 9:30 - By Julia Scott-Stevenson

Archival material, at its basic level, is often the tired mark of authority in documentaries. It shows a filmmaker has done research and provides a necessary back story perhaps, and then we wait to get back to the real material -- the now.

archival_2032816953

This list highlights documentary films that have taken archival material and done something fresh with it - it's not just supporting a story, it is the story; or it's repurposed, remixed, reimagined and reinvigorated.

This archival material doesn't necessarily have to be in audio-visual form - some of the most interesting films have tackled the challenge of incorporating other types of records

10. Capturing the Friedmans
The Friedman family was a seemingly normal Great Neck, NY family with three sons, until in 1987 father Arnold and son Jesse were arrested for child molestation, supposedly occurring during private computer classes held in their home. The Friedmans had a long habit of making home videos and continued this practice throughout the investigation and trial, recording a family buckling under the pressure of the allegations and ongoing events. Director Andrew Jarecki was given access to these recordings to incorporate into his documentary, presenting an intriguing mix of filmmaker-mediated and rawer scenes unfolding simultaneously.



9. Exit Through the Gift Shop
Thierry Guetta filmed hundreds upon hundreds of hours of video over years, of anything and everything going on in his life and then also particularly graffiti artists going about their work. Never editing them, he placed the tapes in boxes, and they eventually emerged to form a core of this film. Whatever one thinks about the veracity of this film (I tend to think the very existence of a debate qualifies it as a documentary), Guetta is certainly an intriguing character and the boxes of videos play their own role in the film beyond just providing extra footage.



8. At the Death House Door 
At the Death House Door is the story of Carroll Pickett, a now retired Texan pastor who was a death row chaplain for many years. Pickett made tape recordings of his thoughts after each execution, and now he listens to his younger self while the camera catches every facial expression and response. These tapes are woven through other stories including one examining the innocence of one of the prisoners, and the gradual collection of experiences builds to a fascinating repudiation of the death penalty without ever feeling like an activist film. Pickett's own stance on the death penalty is not revealed until late in the film, a masterful stroke.



7. Burma VJ
Burma VJ uses material captured by video journalists in Burma during the period of the monks' uprising in 2007. Grainy and jumpy video footage is riveting as it presents an unfolding drama, narrated by some of the participants and also incorporating recreations of some of the communication at the time. The bravery of the journalists in a country where simply holding a camera is a major political act is astonishing, and the knitting together of their pieces makes a powerful work.



6. Bear 71
Bear 71, which I reviewed in a recent post [http://www.sbs.com.au/documentary/blogs/view/id/125677/t/A-slick-and-grizzly-webdoc], is an online interactive documentary that tells the story of a bear in the Canadian wilderness. The filmmakers drew on a store of existing footage from motion sensor cameras dotted around the forest, capturing animals in their native habitat that is being gradually encroached upon by humans. The viewer can roam the forest and follow the animals, viewing these vignettes bookended by other archival footage of the capture and tagging of bear 71.

5. The Green Wave
The Iranian protests around the last election provided a fertile ground for media making. Phone cameras were out in force capturing the protests, while others took to Twitter and blogs to vent their frustrations and alert the world to what was happening. The Green Wave incorporates not only some of the footage captured at the time but also a number of the blog posts, using animation to illustrate the stories being told in graphic detail and allowing a deeper reflection on the events than that offered by grainy phone footage.



4. Senna

The recent crowd pleaser, Senna, is that rare film entirely built from archival footage yet gripping the whole way through. Audio from present-day interviews is added to provide some analysis, but the story stays within its archival chronology. The sheer amount of footage available meant the director, Asif Kapadia, spent eight months sifting to find the bits he wanted, and he has managed to craft a tight and coherent narrative. I was also relieved and impressed to see the footage of Senna's death played in the film only once - all too often we find ourselves in a media world that needs to see gruesome events played over and over again.



3. Standard Operating Procedure

Everybody saw the photographs of Iraqi prisoner abuse in Abu Ghraib, but any context was lost in the following maelstrom. In Standard Operating Procedure, Errol Morris sets out to find out the stories that go with the photos. Early on a graphic depicts thousands of photographs as if spread throughout a universe, perhaps hinting at the reach of this inexplicable behaviour. The perpetrators have their time in front of the camera to try and explain, but rather than building an understanding of their personal actions, the film creates a bigger picture of the futility of the entire system that produced them. At the end, it's still the photographs that have spoken the loudest.



2. Chicago 10

A fascinating courtroom trial is revisited in Chicago 10, a film covering the fallout from the 1968 anti-Vietnam war protests. While it does incorporate regular archival footage from the time, the standout approach is the film's bringing to life of the trial transcript using animation. Filmmaker Brett Morgen was conscious of needing to appeal to a contemporary audience, and for that reason didn't want to use talking heads of the now much older participants looking back. Through this approach, a dry historical record leaps up and becomes so much more relevant and riveting.



1. Shut Up Little Man! An Audio Misadventure

Filmmaker Matthew Bate achieved an impressive feat by creating an engaging feature length documentary that centres on audio cassette recordings. In the 80s, friends Eddie and Mitch lived next door to two crotchety men, Peter and Raymond, who would drunkenly sling loud abuse at each other, and Eddie and Mitch recorded their hollering. The film traces the cultural phenomenon that grew out of these recordings, exploring ideas of privacy, copyright and art.

Share article: 
top

Comments (5)

29 Mar 2012 9:36 AEST

Julia Scott-Stevenson

From:

So many to see...

Thanks for the comments all! Wow, so many films I now need to chase up and watch. In my (fairly lame) defence of them all being recent, older docos are just damn hard to find, so I generally skew towards films that I've watched when they were released in any of my top ten lists. (Looking forward to an Aussie hulu/netflix/etc for better access - doesn't quite exist yet). Adam Curtis will be first on the list for seeking out docs - shamefully I've never seen any. Agreed that there are huge problems with SOP, but I still thought it was a very interesting and controversial choice to only have the voices of the soldiers and no Iraqis. I also think the huge gaps between their explanations and what they actually did serves to make them look probably worse, while still drawing attention to the awful system they're within.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

24 Mar 2012 10:29 AEST

jon kelland

From: chicago

good list, but...

as i noted in twitter response, it seemed odd the list skewed so new with the oldest being FRIEDMANS in 2003, jumping to CHICAGO 10 from 2007, three each from '08 & '10, and 1 each from '11 & '12. an earlier classic is THE ATOMIC CAFE (1982) that uses WWII footage (usually newsreel) that once was used to champion the US and its atomic (war) endeavors but now appears completely horrific. jill godmilow has two earlier films i love - WHAT FAROCKI TAUGHT (1998) and FAR FROM POLAND (1984) - both radically commenting on documentary and the archive. your early date of 2003 has a couple of noteworthy faves - LOS ANGELES PLAYS ITSELF and TARNATION. it's been a while since i've revisited TARNATION, and not sure i'd _completely_ vouch for it, but i think it does stand in as a noteworthy benchmark of a certain DIY/Gen-Y[?] archival autobiography. more interesting is Thom Anderson's LOS ANGELES essay on filmic representations of place - here how (primarily) Hollywood portrays LA on screen. essential. (back to the autobiographical use of archive, Alan Berliner is someone to be familiar with. though i don't love his work, i think it's worth a look.) James Marsh (better known for MAN ON WIRE and PROJECT NIM) gave us 1999's WISCONSIN DEATH TRIP, based on a photography project, WDT grounds itself in the news-stories from a small WI town l19c. Bill Morrison's 2002 DECASIA is a brilliant reflection on the physical limitations and decay of the objects of the archive. also from 2002 is BUS 174, a compilation of news footage from a hostage stand-off in Brazil which does an interesting job of filling in archival holes. 2010's THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF NICOLAE CEAUCESCU is also quite fab. the filmmakers use the state archive to stitch together a portrait of Ceaucescu's (self)representations over his reign to make a point about the folly of the (self-serving) archive. just as interesting, last year's SCENES OF A CRIME does a masterful job at using the archive against its owner - in this case looking at the problematics to be found with police interrogation by building a film around a video-taped two-day, ten-hour interrogation. (something else just slipped my mind 8), i'm assuredly spacing many great ones. onto your list: as a rule of thumb, i leave CAPTURING THE FRIEDMANS off any lists unless it addresses unethical practices in documentary. from both the perspective of allegedly forcing the family to cooperate with his dropping the intended clown doc and shifting to the sensational story it became, but also from the fact that jarecki thought friedman was innocent, though his treatment of him, and the family, in the film does little to suggest that. aside that, i find the treatment he did cut as highly troublesome at best. likewise, with STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE, i find morris' defense and coddling of his subjects uncomfortable. i feel he taunts the audience with faux-philosophizing (which he clearly loves) by suggesting the soldiers' actions are rebellious and moral by the mere presence of their existence - a position i clearly disagree with. further, it is interesting to compare the "testimony" of Lynndie England in SOP and Rory Kennedy's GHOSTS OF ABU GHRAIB, which i think reflects negatively on morris. that said, i appreciate his efforts in grounding the film in the photos, but didn't come away as impressed as he likely assumes we should be. i thought SENNA was terribly over-rated, given credit for the great-looking race cinematography. i thought to be more effective the non-race aesthetic should have played-off the race cinematography. further, i thought the film offered little but a generous portrait of a spoiled racer, though suggesting a couple arcs that would have been likely better. i totally agree with CHICAGO 10 and EXIT THROUGH THE GIFT SHOP - both entertaining and exciting uses of the archive. in the same spirit is 2008's WALTZ WITH BASHIR, grounded in interviews. animated. on commenter Montreal's suggestion of Curtis, i'd agree that he's worth a look, but he suffers from the self-important pseudo-intellectualizing pose that hampers other notables like Morris and Herzog. there's a great send-up/take-down of Curtis on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1bX3F7uTrg thanks again for the list :) i'll return when i remember something i should have posted :)

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

23 Mar 2012 8:48 AEST

Omar Majeed

From: Montreal

More archival docs

Great list. Agree with many, have added some to my must-see list. I'd add just about any film made by Adam Curtis (especially Power of Nightmares), who is a master of archival. The great doc Marlene about Dietrich (made by German actor Maximillian Schell), that features only archival clips from her films since she refused to be photographed. Black Power Mix Tape is a recent doc, amazing and all archival...really brilliant and put together amazingly. Another recent film that made good use of archive was Under African Skies, not amazing -- but a good film nonetheless. I also love the way Julian Temple weaves archival footage through his music docs, its very artistic.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

22 Mar 2012 5:18 AEST

Ant

From: Brunswick West

Another great Doco

the staircase documentary

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

21 Mar 2012 10:43 AEST

John MacFarlane

From: SBS Documentary

Nice!

Great list. I'd have to have Project Nim and Man on Wire on mine, though they're not purely archival. Although, as usual, I've seen only three of your entire list.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.

About this Blog

Julia Scott-Stevenson Julia is a writer and researcher of all things documentary, and even dabbles in making them herself from time to time. She lived in the Pacific Islands of Fiji and Samoa for a few years, where she made a documentary about the inaugural Miss Tokelau beauty pageant and a short documentary about climate change in Samoa, which screened at the inaugural Pacific Climate Change Film Festival. While in the Pacific she was subjected to limited internet connectivity, and was staggered to discover the possibilities in online documentary on her return at the end of 2008. She has since been making up for lost time by undertaking a PhD researching cross-platform documentary, and also working on a database documentary about volunteers. Julia is also on the programming team for Antenna International Documentary Film Festival.

 
ADVERTISEMENT