Heavy handed

07 April 2012 | 9:00 - By Anthony Tan

Some of the most eagerly anticipated match-ups of the entire week have been ruined by a bunch of overzealous commissaires, and in the eyes of Anthony Tan, sullied the spirit of track racing.

pendleton_640_getty_1375932041

Simona Krupeckaite (L) and Victoria Pendleton (Getty)

Friday evening, judges were right to have relegated Victoria Pendleton in the first heat of her match sprint semi-final against Anna Meares, for the Briton clearly deviated from the red sprinter’s line before hip-sliding to a halt.

In the second heat, the roles were reversed as Meares moved abruptly above the sprinter’s line, her back wheel almost coming into contact with Pendleton’s front, forcing the fetching Brit to back off at risk of coming a cropper again.

The third was fought fair and square. Pendleton’s gamble of using a much higher gear ratio than at the London World Cup paid off in spades, her long sprint enough to send Anna into a race for bronze, where she nailed Ukraine’s Lyubov Shulika 2-0.

But it was the gold medal final between Pendleton and Simona Krupeckaite that I’m dirty about.

Just when the packed house at Hisense Arena thought they were going to be treated to a nail-biting decider, as the Lithuanian levelled the match one-all, judges ruled that Krupeckaite did not hold her line in the finishing straight.

Did you see it? Enough to enforce a relegation? I don’t think so.

“I thought I could win today,” a dejected Krupeckaite said afterwards. “The judges were not fair, I think.”

“It’s not the way I want to win,” Pendleton said, who nevertheless broke down in tears after almost slicing her shoulder, elbow and hip to the bone in her clash against Meares, as she digested the enormity of becoming a six-time world sprint champion. The Liz Hurley lookalike also said that when she learned she would face Meares in the semis, she honestly thought she’d be racing for a bronze medal.

But how much better would it have been if Pendleton had actually got to beat Krupeckaite in a decider, rather than through a technicality and what ostensibly amounts to an arbitrary interpretation of the rules?

Though I should have known, for a portent of what was to come from the commissaires came earlier in the week.

In Wednesday’s qualifying round of the team sprint, no less than five nations (four men’s teams, one women’s) were DQ’d for failing to negotiate a correct ‘exchange’, the narrow 30-metre window deemed acceptable for the lead rider to swing up and off and the rider behind to take up the pace-setting.

Two of the men’s teams relegated included Germany, the reigning world champions, and Great Britain, the reigning Olympic champions.

Dave Brailsford, British Cycling’s performance director, said that while he agreed that the decision to DQ his team was a correct one, he could not remember a past world championship where such a rule had been so steadfastly enforced.

The consequences proved auspicious for the trio from Down Under, who delivered our first gold medal of the track worlds, but did we see the best team win?

That’s an answer we’ll never know.

I spoke to Jamie Staff, one of the gold medal-winning British team sprint trio from the Beijing Games who is now USA Cycling’s sprint director, and who said his biggest gripe is the inconsistent application of the rules.

“Having looked at the video, you can’t argue with their decision. The only thing is, I feel they haven’t been really consistent with those calls during the season,” he said. “I mean, I can’t remember the last time someone got disqualified for that.

“It was very close, and obviously the commissaire watching was very strict on (the application of the rule). The rules are the rules, but perhaps if they could be a bit more consistent at the (track) World Cups; you want it to happen at the World Cups, so you can address it later in competition (at the Worlds or Olympic Games).”

Staff also raises another valid point: “It’s one of those rules where (you ask yourself), ‘Is there any major advantage?’ I don’t think so.

“It happens so fast; you’ve got to realise these guys are shooting around the track at 50 miles an hour (80km/h). It’s hard to see a bit of black tape just painted on the track, especially being rider two or three, you’re looking at the guy in front of you, you’re not focused on where the point is.

“I did make a comment to the UCI, and said if there’s any way they can put something on the track to designate the change box, that would be greatly appreciated. So I think they listened and hopefully they might do that.”

But should it have taken this for the UCI officials to instigate such a change, or should they have thought about this before soiling such an important event?

Twitter: @anthony_tan

Share article: 
top

Comments (13)

Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | 2 | Next 10

09 Apr 2012 17:19 AEST

LMH5

From:

Stan - at least you didn't make the mistake of calling a non-Anglo Australian a convict this time. That's progress, I suppose.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

08 Apr 2012 12:36 AEST

Mike

From: Melborne

Women's sprint world title winners since 2005: 2005, Los Angeles: Victoria Pendleton 2006, Bordeaux: Natalia Tsylinskaya 2007, Mallorca: Victoria Pendleton 2008, Manchester: Victoria Pendleton 2009, Pruszkow: Victoria Pendleton 2010, Ballerup: Victoria Pendleton 2011, Apeldoorn: Anna Meares 2012, Melbourne: Victoria Pendleton Stop whinging.

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

08 Apr 2012 9:51 AEST

Fred

From: Queensie

e·nor·mi·ty/iˈnôrmitē/ Noun: 1.The great or extreme scale, seriousness, or extent of something perceived as bad or morally wrong. 2.(in neutral use) The large size or scale of something: "the enormity of her achievement". ........just saying

Agree (4 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

08 Apr 2012 8:35 AEST

Batman

From: Gotham City

The Worlds have been ruined for me. Surely the "sprinter's lane" rule should only be applied if the other competitor was impeded. Kenny should never have been DQ'd. A brilliant race has been sullied.

Agree (2 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

08 Apr 2012 4:16 AEST

Stan Seathwaite

From: Oxford, England

Hi BMan - I'm not sure what I am meant to be retracting here. I was simply telling Tan Man that the word "enormity" is used incorrectly in this article. We were taught that the word means "evil". So you could say "the enormity of the Holocaust", for example. But not a bike race, that's all. As for the Keirin ( not "Kieran", Mike ), I think you're wrong to take it seriously. It is a bit of a joke, let us be serious. Pendles is neither lucky nor a girl. She's brilliant, but 31 years old....

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

08 Apr 2012 0:16 AEST

Craig

From: Canberrra

I just watch Sir Chris Hoy come out of the sprinter lane on Shane Perkins (round 1) and was not relegated. Is Sir Chris Hoy immune? Then Jason Kenny did the best sprint I've seen in years and as he deviated inside the sprinter lane he missed a chance to have another crack. The Frenchman was never coming pass. Seriously if this is the Commissiare then cycling needs help! Victoria Pendleton won the gold last night with a very suspicious ruling.

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

08 Apr 2012 0:07 AEST

"Shane"

From: Geelong

Would love to see a direct comparison between Kenny's move for relegation and Sir Hoy's on Perkins for nothing. They'll be riding with baskets and streamers next year.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

07 Apr 2012 22:55 AEST

Mike (Brighton)

From:

And tonite in the Kieran Anna Meares 1st , Pendleton 12th. And Anna actually rode for the win whereas Pendleton won the sprint by default! Then Sir Hoy only got a 3rd and the French won the gold.....swings and roundabouts.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

07 Apr 2012 16:42 AEST

BMan

From: Melbourne

Stan, please! Pulchritudinous? So, what did you really do with the money your Mother gave you for school tuition? Skipped class, but kept the dictionary? I suggest you look up enormity and then repost with a retraction and apology. Pendles is a lucky girl. Raced 5 times last night, was first across the line in only 2, but has the rainbow jersey. That's racing though and she is a worthy champion and class act.

Agree (2 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

07 Apr 2012 13:58 AEST

Old Major

From: Owl Farm

Another way to appraise these events is that it has been every OTHER track event that has inconsistently applied the rules, whilst the Aust Worlds have simply done things correctly. Well, perhaps not, as Meares came out the sprinter's lane in the 3rd heat with no penalty. Had Pendleton done the same, that the scorn would have been deafening.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 
Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | 2 | Next 10

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.