Prudhomme's vision blurred by Sky
When Christian Prudhomme announced the course for the 2012 Tour de France, he underlined it as a rouleur's race, but one, he maintained, offered ample opportunity and variety for those not gifted against the clock to make up their losses with long-range attacks, and mountain raids.

- 76 Comments | Join the discussion
"The champion who is afraid of time trials will have to make the difference in the mountains,” Prudhomme said at the Tour's official route presentation.
In truth, it was a course almost custom-designed for French darling Cadel Evans to repeat his 2011 achievement. Bradley Wiggins' ability was still a big question mark over three weeks and at the Tour, with his 2009 fourth place and Vuelta podium the only major marks of significance ahead of the 2012 season.
More than 100 kilometres of time trialling was an oft-quoted stat, and the effect of which likely to all but decide the yellow jersey come Paris.
The crashes of Ryder Hesjedal, Alejandro Valverde and Robert Gesink on Stage 6 and Andy Schleck at the Dauphine, only served to further crystallise such a feeling.
The extraction of such major opposition from an already restricted contest, only heightened the slanted importance placed by Prudhomme on the Tour's three time trials, and the sense of fait accompli the race was set to deliver.
And although Wiggins in yellow is not Evans, the Tour has so far transpired more or less as predicted - a paradox in a sport that savours chaos and the unknown.
The next two days, while hard, are unlikely to shift the Briton out of that colour. Perhaps the only real challenge will come from within his own team in Chris Froome, but even that seems doubtful.
So is the race as good as done? No, but it's not far off. The Tourmalet and Peyresourde, now Wiggins' main, and only obstacles.
Arguably as early as Stage 7, La Planche des Belles Filles, such a prospect was staring down Tour spectators lining the roads of France, and across the globe tuning in on their television sets.
After Stage 9, in Besancon, such a belief was only reinforced, and although chinks appeared in both Wiggins's armour and Sky's solidarity on Stage 11 to La Toussuire, the end result was the Brit distancing his main rival in Evans.
In a sense, the strength of Sky has nullified much of the battle, not that any criticism should be directed toward it. Edvald Boasson Hagen, Richie Porte, Michael Rogers, Christian Knees, and Bernie Eisel have been magnificent in leaving an imprint on the front of the race, all while being one man down.
They've been tactically astute too, barring an error-marred first week, riding exactly as they've needed to. Their rivals have simply had no answer.
But playing into Sky's hands has been the parcours. The same course that Prudhomme believed would allow, nay encourage long-range moves, has so far failed to do so.
Why? Well in part it's because while Prudhomme's motives were noble, they may well have also been ill-conceived.
Andy Schleck's do-or-die attack on Stage 18 of last year's race was the stuff of legend, and no doubt will long-live in Tour de France folklore, but such moves rarely come off.
Among the day's hypothesised to induce similar displays were last night's run to Foix, and Stage 10 over the Grand Colombier.
While the latter succeeded in baiting Nibali out of the pack briefly, the success of such a move always seemed bound for failure.
Although overshadowed by tacks and nails, Stage 14, like Stage 10's chances of yielding a successful break including a GC rider, were stymied from the outset, with the near 40 kilometres from the summit of the Mur de Peguere and the finish rewarding a reckless rather than a calculated move.
SBS's own Anthony Tan suggested that Prudhomme's course was possibly "anachronisitic to modern day racing", while CyclingNews editor Daniel Benson "doubted whether riding like the days of Bernard Hinault as (Prudhomme had hoped)" would achieve a better outcome for any of the riders in the top 10.
"The Tour holds too much importance for riders now . . . for them to risk even a top-five a top-10 finish," Benson said.
And Frank Schleck questioned just how real the possibilities for a climber are in any case.
"There are only two very hard stages for climbers," Schleck said of the 2012 course to CyclingNews a few days ago.
"In the other stages, we do not know what to do.
"The organisers wanted to make an exciting Tour with earlier attacks but what will happen, what has happened is the opposite."
Evans remarked on Saturday afternoon something in a similar vein.
"These climbs are a long way from the finish and with the defence that Sky do, there's not a lot we can do to combat that.
"It closes the race down a lot."
Not that the blame rests entirely at Prudhomme's feet either.
BMC and Liquigas-Cannondale should accept some responsibility for the slightly deterministic way the Tour is playing out. Neither team has been able to match Sky in man-to-man power. Isolating Wiggins and Froome has been a supremely difficult task because of both team's lack of relative depth.
The most imaginative moves, like Evans linking with Tejay van Garderen on the Col du Glandon, and Nibali linking up with Peter Sagan the day before, were crushed by the diesel of Sky. Both were made when the British team still had surplus domestiques to bring such moves back, but they had to be made then because neither team has the rider resources to do otherwise.
Not that it's been dull. The journey has been thoroughly enjoyable. Does it give reason for a rethink next year? Well, perhaps.
Follow @al_hindsComments (76)
25 Jul 2012 20:47 AEST
From: Eltham
3500 km time trial sounds great and you said this years TDF was boring. You obviously know nothing about cycling
24 Jul 2012 2:39 AEST
From: London
Sure, Cadel showed up for the Tour de France, but can you honestly tell me that he put up a great fight in defence? I think not judging by the first ITT. Don't get me wrong, I know he has got courage, I witnessed it last year. What I am saying is Aussies are saying Bradley is a boring rider but what could he have done about that if Cadel and everybody else did not take the fight to him?
22 Jul 2012 10:27 AEST
From: Cairns
Is it time to limit the number of members of a team so we can see if it is the best rider not the one with the strongest team or limit how many of the one team can ride in a train. This year's ride has been boring. I would like to see an all individual ride, no teams , no radios just go for it. No drafting get out and ride and see who the best is after 3 weeks, might be some pleasant surprises.
22 Jul 2012 9:06 AEST
From: yarraville
cadel hasn't put up a fight? !!!! bonecrusher, with all due respect, i ask you when are you next in the saddle for 3 weeks @ international standard? cadel has shown much courage & guts... (ahh it misses the point that the world only loves a winner) we'll support you cadel - particularly @ those times when you're not in the spotlight
21 Jul 2012 2:24 AEST
From: London
This Tour is only boring to Aussies because Cadel is riding like a little girl on her tri-cycle! If he had put up even a little bit of a fight he would have no doubt made you Aussie fans a little less bitter. That goes for the other GC contenders too who so far have all failed to turn up for the race. It makes me wonder what Brad could have achieved last year had he no crashed. He is obviously way too strong for Cadel.
20 Jul 2012 23:08 AEST
From: Cambridge
Dave, you're obviously new to cycling. They are defending the yellow jersey and its up to others to attack them. The problem is teams like Liquigas and BMC have not had the strength in depth to sustain attacks. And why the dig at England. Sky are British registered with many nationalities. Including Australian
20 Jul 2012 22:29 AEST
From: yarraville
ada, ada, ada... you should go play lawn bowls in albania
20 Jul 2012 22:17 AEST
From: yarraville
hey richard, that australian commentator who is on right before phil & paul is great! i cannot remember his name but if you don't think he's any good you ought to give up the ghost and watch rugby league...
20 Jul 2012 17:23 AEST
From: Brisbane
Yes me too, I have found the hard drive useful this year as its not worth staying up to watch this boring race. I know that sounds tuff because they are the greatest sportsman but its not good television.
20 Jul 2012 17:19 AEST
From: brisbane
I need to say I agree, this years race is boring, not exciting at all. Sure Sky may be a great team but how boring has this been to watch. Some exciting beak aways but Sky and the boring pace of Wiggins leaves much to be desired. Lots of great riders in this years tour but the route and then the lead by sky from the time trial just shut the whole race down with the occasional breakaway. I also fell asleep this year and thats a first. I am not a fan of team time trials either so bring on 2013
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
- Prudhomme's vision blurred by Sky (76)
- Desperate for denouement to Armstrong saga (75)
- An inadequate admission (43)
- Reassessing our approach to doping in sport (39)
- Can Evans rise above? (36)
- Loyalties tested (33)
- Should White have gone? (31)
- Rebel without a cause (30)
- Holding all the aces (24)
- Five things to take from Paris-Nice (21)
About this Blog
Al Hinds
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Joe Ward
- Tom Palmer
- Bridie O'Donnell
- Sarah van Boheemen
- Stuart Randall
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Kate Bates
- Al Hinds
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Wed 19 Jun 2013 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top
Blog Home 
Previous 10 |
