Fiction and food labels

27 July 2012 | 11:25 - By Matthew Evans

It’s with a sad heart that I will go to this week’s farmers’ market. After nearly four years, at two different markets, selling pork, sometimes lamb, sometimes beef, sometimes felafel, it may be the last under Rare Food’s current incarnation. Not that Ross and I have a sign to promote our brand on the tent. Or any kind of decent attempt at a good-looking stall. But we have built up our business to the point where it’s reasonably busy, and we sell a lot of our beloved pigs directly to the punters, albeit in the shape of ham, or rillettes, or bacon.

Problem is, both of us are busy with other projects. Both of us have farms to run, a toddler to wrangle, families to foster, and bigger ideas to pursue. And we live a good two hours and a body of water away from each other, which makes transferring the market kit, or the market produce, somewhat fraught. Ross has the commercial kitchen and appropriate licenses. I have easier access to Hobart. Our pork is stored two minutes from my place, and a long way from Ross.

I was going to have a bit of a rant about produce this week, about the need for growers to give direct selling a crack. About the desire for consumers to look their producers in the eye. About the synergy that is created between those who nurture produce from the soil, and those that would like to eat that produce. Also, what that produce means to those who buy it – in terms of its cultural, ecological and nutritional importance, and the only way it will continue to be produced by small growers is if there’s someone there to buy it.

And then I read, finally, after an inexcusably long period since its publication, In Defence of Food, by acclaimed US author Michael Pollan, and found so much of what I’ve been thinking had already been put into print. Albeit in the guise of nutritional advice (or, rather, the advice to ignore nutritional advice).

It did put one of our market responsibilities into context. One of the bugbears of small producers is the impost of the system. In my case, it’s a food labelling system that has been foisted upon us because of the shonks out there. The charlatans and industrialists who have taken what should be food, and put all sorts of non-food-sounding things in it. Like emulsifiers. And preservatives. And soy isolates. The labelling laws exist because food isn’t food anymore; rather a place for industrial chemicals, faux food-like substances masquerading as something that came from the land, from a bakery, from a cow.

If I sell you a product at a market, say I make six wild rabbit pies, I not only have to tell you the ingredients, but also construct a nutritional panel from the same. Even if I never make those pies again. And even though a nutritional panel of those pies will not actually represent the true nutrients in the pie, and certainly it won’t represent the nutrients that are available to you as the eater of the pie. That’s because to come up with a nutritional panel, I use a (Federally funded) web page that doesn’t recognise the inherent difference between wild rabbit (that eats leafy greens and hence has lots of novel things in its body, like those very trendy omega-3 fats) and a caged (ie farmed) rabbit that has a completely different profile. It also doesn’t recognise that people from different genetic backgrounds, and individuals from within the one family, absorb nutrients differently. Add in the fact that nutrients interact one with another, and with other things in the diet, and a nutritional panel for a batch of six one-off pies is a fiction. That’s just rabbits. Try comparing my fat, free-range, green-leaf-eating pigs with the confinement animals that the government-provided internet link presumably uses as its “pork” in the ingredient list, and even the levels of macronutrients (fat, carbohydrate, protein) are hopelessly inadequate. That’s before you even get to the nutritionally dubious distinction between saturated fat and polyunsaturated fat.

Anyway, I won’t go into a rant, because I don’t want to be a target when I come back to the market. And come back I will; be it in a month, three months or a year, because I love to sell direct to the people who will buy my produce. To see the faces and share stories with those who are the final destination of things I have helped bring onto the plate. And I hope they like buying off the person who creates sustenance from sunlight, dirt and air.

Share article: 
top

Comments (13)

Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | 2 | Next 10

12 Nov 2012 13:13 AEST

Peter

From:

Series

Does anybody know if there will be a series 3?

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

19 Oct 2012 12:08 AEST

Robyn

From: Central West NSW

Govt and Labelling requirements for Soap

We sell our Goats milk soaps at various markets in the local area. Even we are required to have a Govt licence, which costs money and doesn't give us anything really and abide by reams of labelling laws - and this items isn't even consumed.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

24 Aug 2012 7:00 AEST

Steve Tankersley

From:

Thank you

Mathew, Perhaps the beginning of a rant, but quite appropriate. Thanks for the inspiration. Please do not stop. Doing the right thing doesn't have to be popular and doesn't have to be "approved". Love the show, love what you're doing. Keep it up!! Steve...in distant Bahrain

Agree (9 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

09 Aug 2012 17:05 AEST

Lou

From:

sad state of affairs

it's a sad state of affairs......... we tried to buy a couple of fresh wild bunnies from the bunny man at the market in gippsland last week............. NO RABBITS....... awaiting accreditation from some bureacracy or other to confirm his rabbits are properly stored or is it to confimr his real rabbits are actually real rabbits ? they look like rabbits............etc.............................

Agree (7 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

06 Aug 2012 22:29 AEST

Cecilia Gunther

From:

Real food is good.

Good morning. I am a New Zealander who lives on the Prairie in the US. When I first moved here I could not find any real or fresh food to eat in the supermarkets. Here people eat food to feel full cheaply. Most of it is not food. Sad. So now we grow our food. Eggs, beef, lamb, pork, fruit, piles of veges, wine, cider, honey, etc And I blog it to show that it can be done. By anyone. And for all the reasons you have discussed so eloquently above. And thank you for being so eloquent. cecilia

Agree (11 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

03 Aug 2012 14:19 AEST

Mattia

From:

Takes only one bad apple to ruin the whole bag

Our food allergies, weak immune systems, our fear of germs have mostly been caused and cultivated by the same charletons and industrialists - the rest has been caused by people in the food industry who want to make a quick buck and cut corners resulting in the Food Labels. We can start with small steps, we need to be serious about growing food we KNOW is real food & buying from farmers markets or neighbours who have excess and reduce the reasons for the labels. Cheers to better health!!

Agree (13 people agree)    Disagree (6 people disagree) Report this
 

01 Aug 2012 17:36 AEST

Rachael Wedd

From:

Real food - please!

They make it next to impossible don't they (the Authorities)?! People love 'real food', and I certainly have no need to see all the silly things like nutritional panels - I'm more than happy to see an ingredient list to know what's going in my mouth. Small producers should be able to have different legislation - surely!

Agree (25 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

30 Jul 2012 12:32 AEST

Damnthematrix

From:

sustainable labelling

Actually, Anna's just given me an idea for a label....: This contains REAL food, organic, grown from sunlight, dirt and air with NOTHING added.

Agree (13 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

30 Jul 2012 12:21 AEST

Anna Kurz Rogers

From:

Spread the word....

Whole real sustainable foods are exactly what author, speaker and controversial nutritionist Cyndi O'Meara has been talking about for the past 20 years in her book Changing Habits Changing Lives. This extremely educated and knowledgable lady is coming to Tasmania. She will be speaking in Howrah on Sunday 23rd of September and again in Devonport on Tuesday 25th of September. For more information or to making a booking please click here: http://changinghabits.com.au/BookingRetrieve.aspx?ID=20561

Agree (1 people agree)    Disagree (3 people disagree) Report this
 

30 Jul 2012 12:18 AEST

Anna Kurz Rogers

From:

Sustainable farmers are our way to better health

Sustainable farmers who breed/grow from the sunlight, dirt and air are the ones the government should be supporting to keep our population healthy and free from dis-ease instead of making a trillion dollars from the medicines made by the pharmecutical companies that are making our population sicker and sicker!!!

Agree (21 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 
Display: 20 | 40 | All comments per page
Previous 10 | Page 1 | 2 | Next 10

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.

About this Blog

Ever wondered what it’d be like to leave a cushy city job and set up a small farm without any experience of rural life? Join Matthew Evans as he adjusts from being a restaurant critic to learning exactly where his food is coming from, on a farmlet in Tasmania’s beautiful Huon Valley.

Matthew Evans was once trained as a chef, before crossing to the dark side of the industry and becoming a restaurant reviewer. After five years and 2,000 restaurant meals as the chief reviewer for The Sydney Morning Herald, Matthew realised that chefs don’t have the best produce in the land, normal people who live close to the land do. So he moved to Tasmania, to a small patch of earth where he’s raising pigs and sheep, milking a cow and waiting for his chickens to start laying.

 
ADVERTISEMENT