One of the usual memes you see every time an Olympiad comes around is fans of a particular sport questioning the value of having another sport in the Games. Something more recently amplified by Twitter.

Caroline Buchanan, Australia (Getty)
- 14 Comments | Join the discussion
Why is synchronised swimming in the Olympics? That’s not a real sport. Same for dressage, Show jumping, the modern pentathlon or more recently, mountain biking and BMX. Some wonder why ‘professional’ sports like Tennis are included. Shouldn’t the Olympics be reserved for the amateurs? As if today’s full-time shot putter or javelin thrower is an amateur in the true sense of the word.
Similarly, if you were an Olympian in either mountain biking or BMX, you’d be wondering what you need to do to get a little respect from some corners of the cycling world.
Cycling doyen Phil Liggett was quoted in Melbourne’s Herald Sun tabloid as saying these newcomers to the Olympic family would have founder Baron Pierre de Coubertin “laughing his head off”.
"It is absolutely disgraceful what they have done. They have devastated the track with the new events and taking out the iconic events of the Olympics," Liggett told the paper.
"They have taken out the exciting and interesting events - the individual pursuit, the 1km time trial and the women's 500m time trial, and put in an omnium that no one will ever understand.
"There is only one rider from each country in the omnium and they are a jack of all trades and master of none.
"Nations and riders complained, but the UCI (International Cycling Union) wanted equality," he said.
"They got that but they also took out women's events. They introduced BMX. Great, but I am sure (Olympics founder) Pierre de Coubertin would have laughed his head off if he found out it was an Olympic discipline.
"It might be exciting but we are talking the Olympic Games.
"We have never had a good mountain biking event. Thousands will watch them but they are not Olympic gold medal events.
"They weren't meant to be in the Olympic Games."
Both mountain biking and BMX may be relative newcomers to the cycling family but they have some of the best athletes in the world in their ranks. Mountain bike world champion Jaroslav Kuhavy of the Czech Republic and Australia’s BMX stars Caroline Buchanan and Sam Willoughby among them.
Cadel Evans is both a mountain bike Olympian and Tour de France champion. Unworthy in one but worthy in the other? Giro d’Italia winner Ryder Hesjedal also rode from the dirt to the tarmac. The list grows when you look deeper. And in fact mountain biking appears to be a fertile field in which to grow Grand Tour riders. It can be like looking into the future.
I’d argue that cross-country (XC) mountain biking more than deserves its place because it is a larger more broad based sport than track cycling. More so when you look at specific events. The XC Enduro scene is vibrant in a way local track cycling is not, with hundreds of athletes competing regularly on weekends. Check out the ABSA Cape Epic in South Africa some time. There isn’t a similar participation rate for any individual pursuit that I’m aware of.
The practical focus of track cycling is at the elite level while in mountain biking it is community. Surely there is a place for sport with a different kind of appeal in the Olympic Games?
Don't the athletes of mountain biking and BMX deserve their chance at further development and a spotlight on the world’s biggest sporting stage?
Ligget’s comments have placed many in the mountain biking and broader cycling world on the defensive, including Cycling Australia’s Graham Fredricks.
“The deficiencies with the current track program have nothing to do with BMX,” said Fredricks. “Track could easily be enhanced with the cooperation of the UCI and the IOC addressing the mix of events and considering a couple of extra medal events without any requirement to increase the number of athletes.”
Puzzled Canadian mountain bike Olympian Geoff Kabush is one rider who spends a bit of time crossing over.
“I think there are great events across all cycling disciplines,” said Kabush. “I ride the road a lot, and I’ve ridden a little BMX for fun, and I’ve even gone around the track a few times. There are exciting races in all disciplines, and unfortunately at the Olympics they can’t have them all. It’s the nature of the Games.”
It’s not that I disagree with Liggett about the decimation of the track program at the Olympics. His observations are correct and he is voicing what many of us have said since the changes came into effect.
But the Olympics is not just any sporting event.
It needs to be an evolving spectacle or it will end up like its founder, six feet under and oblivious to modernity. It needs to evolve because it is equally an entertainment extravaganza as it is a sporting event, and it needs to attract new demographics to remain relevant in an ever-changing world.
Cycling evolves too. Outside of a few special events we don’t ride (or race) Penny Farthings on a daily basis any more, do we?
Remember too that elite cycling already controls its own destiny on an annual basis, in events that I would argue, are far superior to any Olympic Games, the various world championships.
These really do bring the best of each sport to each event and are not generally hamstrung by the artificial scarcity imposed on the Olympics, running a full slate of events.
Have we already forgotten the UCI Track Cycling World Championships in Melbourne? It had everything. And it was epic.
This year’s UCI Road Cycling World Championships will not only feature the usual wide variety events but also reintroduce a previously run spectacle, a teams time trial. There is something you won't see in the Olympics. That already makes the worlds a more highly anticipated event. And you will get to see it streamed live right here at Cycling Central.
Comments (14)
05 Nov 2012 17:30 AEST
From: ACT
Cleary never tried MTB then... x-c mtb is worthy of being in the olympics as its a race to the finsh line for the fittest and fastest. BMX less so, its a bit of a lottery...win the start, don't get knocked over. Just like long course speed skating is the real deal and short couse is a lottery...just ask Steve Bradbury! IMO, all olympics sports should be for fittest / fastest. All games out, all 'judged' sport out, that's not saying the participant's aren't atheletes, just their events.
02 Aug 2012 16:12 AEST
From: Perth
Yep totally agree. Swimming is the silliest sport full stop. I totally understand Freestyle, but why do we have 3 other clearly inferior ways of getting from a to b in the pool. There is no 100m skip, hop or sack race on track is there? Rowing as well - 2 man, 4 man, 6 man, 8 man all with either one paddle each or two. How many gold medals do we give away for EXACTLY the same sport? Canoes and Kayaks? Get rid of the pro sports as well - Ok rant over
01 Aug 2012 21:14 AEST
From: Springfield
DH MTB would be an excellent addition. Some of the best, most agile and explosive bike handlers and riders in the world on display, with some imaginative coverage it could be a very popular addition. All events are products, just waiting to be presented right. DH is a perfect example of this, one with great potential.
01 Aug 2012 17:20 AEST
From: Uganda
Anyone who takes anything Phil Liggett says seriously deserves to be offended at his comments. A reminder, this is is the guy who thinks Lance Armstrong competed clean.
01 Aug 2012 15:38 AEST
From: Sydney
Didn't know about the road titles having a team time trial. That will be bloody awesome - I love em. Thanks for the heads up Phil.
01 Aug 2012 15:34 AEST
From: Sydney
"Cadel Evans is both a mountain bike Olympian and Tour de France champion. Unworthy in one but worthy in the other?" - That is the strangest comment. Worthiness isn't down to an individual, it is the sport they participate in. And BMX and Mountain Biking are not worthy. They are boring, and make a mockery of the games. I turn off Cycling Central each week when it gets to the mountain biking section.
01 Aug 2012 15:29 AEST
From: Guildford
I reckon Mr Liggett is a bit of a fossil on this one. Señor Gomes, you are right, sports evolve and the Olympics must evolve with them or become irrelevant. Frankly I'd ditch the Keiren. I mean, seriously, a cycling event with a motorbike towing them along for 2 1/2 laps? Thanks to the exposure by Cycling Central I reckon downhill MTB would be a brilliant addition. Net result? A good balance of track, road and offroad.
01 Aug 2012 15:00 AEST
From: Croydon Hills
Sorry Phil G, but I'm with the other Phil on the subject. On a broader scale though, some of the gymnastics, horse dressage (I watched 9's abysmal coverage of dressage the other night and came away not one bit the wiser for how it was scored) and the doozy of them all, beach volleyball seriously need to be assessed for their Olympic worth. Next we'll have pub darts, dwarf tossing and paper aeroplane flying. Back to cycling though, and yep, I'm all for equality but the omnium is not the answer.
01 Aug 2012 14:41 AEST
From: melbourne
Cycling enthusiasts need to stop fighting amongst themselves and instead try to get the Olympic organisers to focus on other sports like swimming. I mean, do we really need butterfly, breaststroke, backstroke AND an infinite variety of medley events not to mention the medley relays. Agree that tennis does not belong.
01 Aug 2012 12:51 AEST
From: Taree
Not a particular fan of either BMX or Mountain Bikes but they DO fulfill my criteria for being a sport, that is if you can measure it it is a sport, if you can't for example ALL the gymnastic disciplines, than it IS NOT, is an artistic endeavour, worthy of respect, but desperately in need of some alternative venue. But even if a discipline is a sport it doesn't mean the Olympics is the greatest thing to ever happen to it! My sport triathlon has suffered badly from being jammed into the Olympics
Join the discussion
PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.
Most Popular
About this Blog
Philip Gomes
Other Blogs
TV
- Living Black
- Italian Food Safari
- Thalassa
- Luke Nguyen's Vietnam
- Behind the Scenes: The 2009 Deadly Awards
- My Family Feast
- Costa's Production Blog
- Eurovision 2011
- Swift and Shift Couriers
- Global Village
- My Bogan Diary
- The Road to the White House
Food
Films
Documentary
- Britt Arthur
- Catharine Lumby
- John Birmingham
- Rory Medcalf
- Mark Jones
- Emily Booth
- Bob Wurth
- Andy Martin
World News Australia
Sport
- The Circus
- The Interchange
- The Hangover
- Lip Service
- Deep in the Dust: On the Dakar trail
- Dakar Dreams
- The Finktank
- Open Season
About SBS
Business
Internet and Technology
Cycling Central
- Joe Ward
- Tom Palmer
- Bridie O'Donnell
- Sarah van Boheemen
- Stuart Randall
- Rochelle Gilmore
- Matthew Price's Broom Wagon
- Anthony Tan's Velo Files
- Matthew Keenan
- Kate Bates
- Al Hinds
- Philip Gomes
- Scott Sunderland
- Mike Tomalaris
Sat 25 May 2013 | 

Email to friend
Print
Enlarge text







top
Blog Home 
Previous 10 |
