Balance at Buninyong?

10 August 2012 | 10:00 - By Al Hinds

The news last week that Ballarat will host the national road championships until at least 2017 reignited a long running debate over the suitability of a venue which continues to polarise, writes Al Hinds, but perhaps solutions that please both parties are not as unimaginable as they seem.

cromwell_640_gunter_1444444334

Tiffany Cromwell outsprints Rachel Neylan for second place during the women's 2012 National Road Championship in Buninyong, near Ballarat ( Mark Gunter Images)

Orica-AIS cyclist Tiffany Cromwell's comments in reaction to the announcement were just some that came from many professional roadies, who felt a chance to change up the venue had been missed.

Take a look at the winners since 2007: Darren Lapthorne, Matt Lloyd, Peter McDonald, Travis Meyer, Jack Bobridge, and Simon Gerrans, all of whom can hold their own uphill.

It's no coincidence. The three kilometres of climbing per 10 kilometre lap unequivocally lends itself to a climber. It's a hard course and one likened by some to a 'classic'.

And It means that if a rider like Matt Goss or Mark Renshaw wants a chance to wear green and gold in the European season, they have to be at their best.

Even then, see Renshaw this year, and Goss in 2011, the possibilities are still far from guaranteed.

The answer, and the push from detractors of Buninyong like Cromwell, is for diversity. Diversity in parcours or diversity in location, although it's the former that is most easily adjusted, particularly now with the announcement to keep the race in Ballarat.

Don't get your knickers in a knot, that in itself is not such a bad thing. The idea of creating an event with real attraction for spectators, media hype and riders at a single location carries weight and should not be completely demonised.

John Craven famously envisioned the championships with a potential akin to the Australian Open tennis, or the Melbourne Formula One Grand Prix, a fixture with its own identity.

After six straight years in Ballarat, 2012 showed that at least part of the vision is becoming a reality, a resounding success, that speaks brightly of the future.

Cycling Australia, the new owner of the event, will no doubt want to capitalise on that growth to make the most of its investment. The financial side for CA is attractive, and I can sympathise with its desire to keep the championships in Ballarat for four more years. How big can this event get?

Is it so far fetched to imagine a Geelong world championship-esque crowd in Ballarat by 2017? Who's to say otherwise? And that's a goal that should be pursued.

But I'm only OK with it on the proviso that the concerns of the riders are listened to. There is no reason why Ballarat cannot host a different road race course each and every year. The most famous cycling event in the world, the Tour de France, hits the Champs Elysees every year, but the three weeks beforehand are barely recognisable.

That prospect is exciting. Why should Ballarat City, which last time I checked was a pretty big area, be any different?

Robbie McEwen, now retired, is one who has been outspoken over the nature of the course before and says organisers should not baulk at experimentation.

"There are lots of different routes in and around Mount Buninyong, even into the city of Ballarat," he said.

"Nationals should give a range of riders a chance to win, and as it stands that's not the case.

"Even if Buninyong had to host the race, there are simple things that could be done, like adding additional distance to the existing 10 kilometre loop to allow riders more time to recover."

The most interesting point McEwen raised, however, is an idea which should please both Cycling Australia and riders calling for change.

"When was the last time Cadel Evans turned up at the nationals?" McEwen said.

"The fact is, and we've seen this, as it stands the race turns away riders who are serious about peaking later in the season. Why? The course is too hard. You can't just turn up and roll around Buninyong, it's a very hard slog.

"A change opens it up for guys like Cadel to turn up, and that's what you want to encourage."

Of course, you have to be wary of going too far one way and alienating the ability of climbers to animate the race. The scales are already firmly titled away from climbers at the domestic level in the National Road Series.

But a balanced course, a changing course, keeps things interesting. Cycling Australia says it is open to the idea of change, and is already looking into potential alternative routes.

There are lots of reasons to make those alternatives a reality, and I hope that the governing body goes down that road.

The final announcement for the 2013 course is expected later this year. Make your voice heard in the comments below.


Share article: 
top

Comments (9)

12 Sep 2012 12:41 AEST

Neil Braszell

From: miners rest

Different courses

I have been to all but one of the Nationals at Ballarat and the event as a spectacle for the fans is second to none, to see thousands of people around this classic course is something cycling has been missing in Aus for as long as i can remember.It is not all that long ago that no spectators turned up to watch the Nationals or for that matter state titles and even the classic Australian races , this interest in the Nationals at Ballarat is something to be embraced and worked on for the future.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this
 

13 Aug 2012 21:28 AEST

Chus Blanc

From: Brisbane

I'd like to know the process of the extension of the commercial arrangements at Ballarat, was it a competitive process? Did cycling get the best outcome? I know that it is hard to believe but cycling is practiced in most other states and Territories of Australia. Now this might be controversial but how about supporting growth of the sport in other geographic areas of this country?

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

11 Aug 2012 22:52 AEST

george

From: townsville

there are more important races for renshaw to train for than the nationals, its such a boring course with all the greenegde riders that will be there gerrans will win again and then everyone will be calling for change

Agree (2 people agree)    Disagree (3 people disagree) Report this
 

11 Aug 2012 8:38 AEST

Trent

From:

Uphill finish please? At the very top of Mt Buninyong?

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this
 

10 Aug 2012 18:17 AEST

Andrew

From: Melbourne

I would like to remind Tiffany that most years there are some very different scenarios occur. Buningyong is such a great course and I am not so sure that if it were held somewhere else that you would get the same support.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (6 people disagree) Report this
 

10 Aug 2012 13:29 AEST

Gerard O'Brien

From: Horsham

It's a National C'ship.!! Not a race for a half-fit sprinter to turn up, sit on and be lead out for a soft win! Sprinters have done well in the past, so if riders like Renshaw really want the title, then train for it !!

Agree (19 people agree)    Disagree (6 people disagree) Report this
 

10 Aug 2012 12:32 AEST

Sam

From:

Variety is the spice of life! if it's good enough for the World Champs course to change each year it should be good enough for us. Would love to see Mark Renshaw wear the jersey.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (3 people disagree) Report this
 

10 Aug 2012 12:14 AEST

BRJ

From: Melbourne

I do agree with Tiffany and AL. I'm not sure I'll be going this year, I've seen it all before :-( What I love about the TDU, is, each year the changes keep it fresh whilst retaining its flavour. There are so many great places to ride around Ballarat surely different routes can be used. Ask the riders what they would like. Ask the spectators at the event what we would like. The event itself is fabulous, but really the race is starting to let it down. Change in moderation please.

Agree (9 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

10 Aug 2012 11:42 AEST

Robert Merkel

From: Melbourne

If the TDU keeps its hilltop finish, that gives the likes of Gerrans and Porte something else they can target for a home win, so it does open it up for alterations to the Nationals course. It would be a shame if they completely took the climb out of the course, though; it has to be close to the best roadside view of a bike race anywhere in the world.

Agree (6 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this
 

Join the discussion

You have characters remaining.
Validation (
) :
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.