rss

Mouthful

What in the world are you eating?

Back to Basics

16 July 2010 | 0:51 - By Phil Lees

If you were a child that grew up during the 1980s in Australia and had a parent who showed even the loosest interest in baking, you are no stranger to the Women’s Weekly Children’s Birthday Cake Book. As the Facebook group says, it's awesome.  If you’re not aware of the book, it is a magazine-sized, lovingly photographed set of instructions to carve cakes into festive shapes and whose sole gift to cake decorating is that it unleashes the decorative potential of licorice bullets and butter cream icing. The cakes are pure pound cake kitsch from an era when kids would demand a cake not based upon Pixar intellectual property.

I was a little scandalised when I read back over the recipes to find that the book recommended buying a packet cake mix to make the cake that you’d shape into the form of an evil duck. There is a recipe in the front section for a basic butter cake, but each individual cake recipe specifies using an industrial alternative. I had always taken cooking cakes from scratch as a given because the ingredients are always on hand.

The idea of 'cooking from scratch' is recent because until the 1940s, starting from a base set of relatively unprocessed ingredients was the only option. The diligent home cook was not exactly milling their own flour but there was almost no option to begin baking using a prepackaged good. Cake was the same as it had been for hundreds of years: liquid, eggs, flour, sugar and fat in various proportions. The classic pound cake is a quarter each of eggs, flour, sugar and butter; where a sponge cake is roughly half eggs. The method for making cake was either to aerate the fat and the sugar for butter cakes or aerate the eggs and sugar for anything that is loosely like a sponge.

From around 1910, these proportions and methods of making cake changed radically due to two innovations. Firstly, the development of hydrogenated vegetable oils made the aeration of cakes easier (and were 12 per cent of the price of the butter they substituted). This development alone reduced the onerous task of beating a cake batter by hand.

Secondly, the development of low-protein 'cake flour' allowed manufacturers to develop packaged mixes which could stay light and moist while the amount of sugar in them could rise well above the amount of flour. Cakes became easier, cheaper, sweeter and packaged. Instead of any specialised method of aerating the batter, all the ingredients could be poured into a bowl and mixed in a single hit. It removed any skill from baking a cake, and while the result tastes like a packaged cake, it otherwise appears like a perfect cake every single time. Once the packaged cake became popular in the 1940s, the idea of cooking from scratch crept into the vernacular.

Share article: 
top

Comments (5)

   
22 Jul 2010 11:24 AEST
Kimberly
From Rosehill
Haha I had that book, baked many a cake from it, my daughter would pour over it langourously every year in aniticipation of her birthday, right up until her 17th mind you; then passed it on to my much younger cousin!

Report this

Agree (0 people agree)
Disagree (0 people disagree)
18 Jul 2010 04:13 AEST
DJ
I couldn't let the photo pass unnoticed - now Phil, I'm sure the recipe says to either beat those eggs lightly before adding, or to add 1 at a time, mixing well.... :) did the cake turn out ok?

Report this

Agree (0 people agree)
Disagree (0 people disagree)
18 Jul 2010 02:52 AEST
Lee
From Burnside QLD
I lived in the USA and held cooking classes in my home showing how to make baby food. Some didn't even know what puree is, it was an eye opener for me. I have always home baked, grew up with only home grown/ baked food, butter, meat etc. I craved bought food. Now my kids are one of the few that only get home baked in their lunch boxes. I have one egg allergic, even with no eggs, the cakes are fine. Its all about technique. Teaching kids how to bake, brings in science, math and english.

Report this

Agree (0 people agree)
Disagree (0 people disagree)
17 Jul 2010 12:10 AEST
HL
It was amazing watching the young chefs on Master Chef trying to replicate baking from the past. Is it a lost skill? Maybe the packet cakes need to be left on the shelf and the skill of simple cooking revived.

Report this

Agree (3 people agree)
Disagree (0 people disagree)
16 Jul 2010 05:37 AEST
From Mount Stuart
Hmmm, I had to just write a little note to tell you that the flatpack Bakers are (very modestly) revolutionising the ?packaged cake? . By going back to basics and using great ingredients, organic flour and the right recipes, we have been able to produce some pretty fine cake, brownie and muffin mixes that do not contain any of the nasties that contribute to that cake mix flavour associate with the mainstream supermarket brands. Maybe our cakes don?t rise quite as stupendously high, but we do get fantastic feedback from all our customers.

Report this

Agree (1 people agree)
Disagree (1 people disagree)
   

Comment on this blog


http://

You have characters left.
Validation ( What's this? ) : This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.

PLEASE NOTE: All submitted comments become the property of SBS. We reserve the right to edit and/or amend submitted comments. HTML tags other than paragraph, line break, bold or italics will be removed from your comment.

ADVERTISEMENT

Featured Food & Recipes

Hot Tips

Chilli

Chilli is an addictive spice, start out by using less hot varieties and remove the seeds before using.

Glossary

Chestnuts

An autumn crop that can be eaten raw, roasted or boiled after removing the tough outer skin. Chestnuts grow in cooler climates and come in a round spiky case.

 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT