Traditional hunting 'not animal cruelty'

22 Jun 2012, 4:26 pm   -   Source: Stefan Armbruster, SBS
Share This
1 
+ Comment
7

EXCLUSIVE: Torres Strait islanders are warning the Queensland government that its plans to apply animal cruelty laws to traditional hunters could end up in the High Court.

Turtles, dugongs hunted in Torres Strait

The SBS MP3 Player requires the Adobe Flash 8 Plugin. You can get Flash from here...

RELATED

Torres Strait islanders are warning the Queensland government that its plans to apply animal cruelty laws to traditional hunters could end up in the High Court.

For thousands of years the islanders have hunted turtles and dugongs for food and to preserve their ancient custom. But there's anger in the islands: they feel they've been portrayed as senseless slaughterers.

The state government says the changes will not affect native title rights, which are protected by an international treaty, and will hold talks with indigenous groups before the amended law is enforced.

“It's our tradition to go out and hunt,” said Toshie Kris, chair of the federal Torres Strait Regional Authority. “It's our lore and we need to give recognition and respect to that law through legislation.”

The Torres Strait Treaty with Papua New Guinea guarantees the islanders' traditional hunting rights, overriding federal and Queensland law.

Toshie Kris condemns the secret filming earlier this year by ABC Television, which allegedly showed the cutting up of a live turtle.

“It did portray us very bad, with the cutting of turtle and dugong, the practice and methods used,” said Mr Kris. “[It] was a completely a different perspective on how traditional owners practice traditional hunting in the Torres Strait.”

Broadcast during the Queensland election campaign, the footage caused outrage on the mainland and the opposition Liberal National Party (LNP) vowed to act.

Now in government, the LNP plans to remove existing exemptions to animal cruelty laws covering all traditional hunters.

“A court would find that the butchering of a turtles while they're still alive is absolutely cruel, and I would expect the majority of the population, including the Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander population would agree with me on that,” said John McVeigh, the Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries minister.

Under the Queensland Animal Care and Protection Act, cruelty breaches are punishable with a $100,000 fine and up to two years in jail.

“If for example a complaint is received, we'll have specialist investigators from my department, with assistance from other agencies, that would investigate the alleged offences,” Mr McVeigh said.

“Depending on the community, that may be done with or through community leaders, on a very cooperative basis.”

But Torres Strait islanders said they were not properly consulted and are keen to negotiate with the government, to a point.

“You could see traditional owners over our region getting up and standing up for their birth rights and if needed be take it to the High Court,” Mr Kris said.

Following this month's 20th anniversary of the High Court recognition of Mabo and native title rights, Queensland could again face a costly legal battle.

Watch this story on YouTube:

Native Title , Traditional Hunting , Animal Cruelty

  • Follow us: 
  • Follow us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Follow us on Youtube

Your Comments

I love to eat dugon

My face - from Atarmon, 7 months ago

I love to eat turtle

Unacceptable

barefootman - from Sunshine Coast, 11 months ago

The right to hunt is not a licence to inflict cruelty. Respect where your food comes from.

Be humane towards food

Jakob - from Sydney, 11 months ago

If one is a meat eater an animal does have to die. That being said the animal should be killed in a quick respectful and humane way (Halal and Kosher slaughter) by someone who is skilled in killing animals and not be slowly killed, tortured or cooked alive and no one should have immunity from this no matter what culture they come from. If someone needs to eat meat the least they can do is respect the animal they are eatting as they to were once living

Animal activist for dugongs and sea turtles

colin riddell - from cairns, 11 months ago

Pity you neglected to mention qld is the only state or territory without cruelty laws on indigenous hunting. They did not want SBS TV to film a kill ,THIS IS WHY!!! http://youtu.be/a2viq3DBdjo

Traditional hunting

oncewas - from bribie island, 11 months ago

Of course it is cruel to dismember live animals and to drown them by towing behind a boat. If traditional hunting is so important to these people, then give up the boats and outboards, grab a spear, hop in your dugout canoe and hunt in the traditional way. Don't pretend.

Be humane towards food

Jakob - from Sydney, 11 months ago

If one is a meat eater an animal does have to die. That being said the animal should be killed in a quick respectful and humane way (Halal and Kosher slaughter) by someone who is skilled in killing animals and not be slowly killed, tortured or cooked alive and no one should have immunity from this no matter what culture they come from. If someone needs to eat meat the least they can do is respect the animal they are eatting as they to were once living

Traditional Hunting Rights

JohnB - from Melbourne, 11 months ago

I fully support the idea of those Torres Strait islanders engaging in hunting traditional food sources. However one might ask just how traditional are speedboats and outboard motors ? As for the footage we saw of the cruel slaughter of a live turtle, well if you're gonna use the aluminium boat with an outboard motor, you might like to know there are modern ways to kill the turtle or dugong, relatively painlessly, before cutting it into pieces. The cruelty laws should apply equally to all.

Join the Discussion

Name
City / Suburb E.g. Artarmon, Sydney
Title
Comment
You have characters remaining.
Validation
What's this?
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.
All submitted comments become the property of SBS. They are moderated, so we reserve the right to edit comments and remove HTML tags. Not all submitted comments will be published. Publication does not mean we endorse the opinions expressed. Please read our terms and conditions for more information.