Hughesy, it's okay to leave

19 March 2010 | 14:00 - By SBS Sport

You don't get many opportunities in Test cricket, something Australia opening batsman Philip Hughes needs to learn.


That's out... Philip Hughes watches his ill-advised slash outside off stump fly to first slip [GETTY]

It has been a tough initiation to Test cricket for Philip Hughes, and his detractors will be out in force again after his latest failure when stepping in for the injured Shane Watson for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington.

Hughes looked reasonably comfortable, racing to 20 from 23 balls, before playing a dreadful shot at a wide delivery and being caught at first slip by Ross Taylor off Brent Arnel, who was bowling his first over in a Test match.

Actually, the word dreadful is an understatement.

Arnel's delivery pitched on off stump and moved sharply away towards the three slips and gully. For a Test opening batsman early in the first session of the first day, it was a regulation leave.

Instead, Hughes's front foot made its customary first movement towards the leg side, and he took an unbalanced, reaching swipe at the away-swinging ball.

People might say 'but that's Hughes's game'. 'He's the swashbuckling type who loves smashing the ball through the off side.'

Yes, he should play his natural game, but there is also the responsibility of a Test opening batsman to see the new ball off, especially on what was a decent pitch against a tepid bowling attack.

Often in Test cricket the shots you leave are as important as the ones you play, and if "PH408" was still updating his Twitter account, he may have quipped "Hmmm... shoulda left that one!!!!"

Seen as the heir to the Langer/Hayden era after his breakout domestic season in 2007-08, Hughes made a duck on Test debut against South Africa at The Wanderers in February 2009.

However he followed that up with a top score of 75 in the second innings, and two centuries (115 and 160) in his two digs of the second Test. The boy from Macksville had booked his ticket to England for his first Ashes tour, aged 20.

Hughes played just three innings of Australia's losing Ashes series, where he was crudely found out by some menacing short stuff from Andrew Flintoff. The stunning emergence of Shane Watson as an opening batsman followed, and Hughes found himself on the outer less than 12 months after his Test debut.

An injury to Simon Katich saw Hughes return to the Test side for the New Year's Test against Pakistan at the SCG. The 21-year-old should have been out caught off the first ball of the match, had it not been for the hard hands of Umar Akmal at gully.

But Mohammed Sami would get his man, and Hughes eventually departed for an ugly 10-ball duck, caught at second slip, before playing the anchor role with 37 from 83 balls in his second innings.

Watson's recent injury gave Hughes another chance at the Basin Reserve this morning – one that the young batsman threw away after getting a decent start.

It is likely Watson will return for the second Test in Hamilton next week so, barring further injury in the Australia batting department, Hughes has one more opportunity to show Australia selectors and fans that he can cut it at the top.

I'm a fan of Hughes and feel he needs to be a part Australia's Test cricket future. I just hope he can learn to leave when it's necessary.

:: More from The Interchange

Share article: 

Comments (3)

07 May 2011 18:27 AEST


From: sweaters for women


sweaters for women who are adored with the absolute egg-shaped shaped face, can advertise any blazon of the vintage earrings. However, the simple studs would add breeding to persona by highlighting their audacity bones. These tips will advice women in award the absolute earrings for themselves in any division and to buy the the cheap brooches for dresses cufflink is small,but it has lots of styles,in accession to the acceptable annular and square,there are baptize droplets,thread,Chinese knots

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this

26 Mar 2010 9:44 AEST

Chris Wang

From: Sydney

Re: Hughsey

Peter, yes, you can't argue with 86 from 75 balls to win a Test match. Full credit to Hughes for stepping up and continuing to play his shots. Although it was an exciting innings I still think it was a little scratchy, and it will be interesting to see what happens if Hughes has to step in against Pakistan or England later this year.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this

25 Mar 2010 13:13 AEST

Peter Schmidt

From: New Zealand


I don't see further comments after his swashbuckler in the 2nd dig to win it for Oz. He plays it the way he sees it. I seem to remember Michael Slater had the same detractors when it didn't come off. He still won a truckload of games for Oz by giving the team the extra time to defeat the opposition.

Agree (0 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this