No storm over salary cap

26 April 2010 | 12:00 - By SBS Sport

The National Rugby League's salary cap has come under scrutiny over the past week, but it must remain in place for the sake of the competition.


Billy Slater, Brett Finch and Cameron Smith are all part of Melbourne Storm's real-life dream team [GETTY]

The English Premier League is an exciting product on the pitch, but as a competition it is one of the most boring in the world.

Twenty teams contest the Premier League each season, but since 1995 only three clubs have won the title - Manchester United (nine times), Arsenal (three times) and Chelsea (twice). The Blues look likely to win the league again this season, with United once again the only threat.

Add Liverpool to the equation, and the "Big Four" clubs have dominated the Premier League for more than a decade, filling the top four places with mundane regularity. What must it be like for fans of the other 16 clubs in the league, having little chance of premiership glory year after year?

In contrast, the NRL – a competition started in 1998 after the Super League splinter, has had eight different clubs win the premiership in its 12-season history. In light of the recent stripping of Melbourne's 2007 and 2009 titles, you could argue that there may have been nine different champions in 12 years.

The Premier League has no salary cap. Clubs can buy any available player for any price. Sure, it takes more than just expensive players to win a title, but history shows the "Big Four" keep winning and constantly qualifying for the lucrative UEFA Champions League. The rich get richer, players receive outrageously high wages and there is no regulation in place to stop it.

The NRL imposes a salary cap on its clubs of $4.1 million per season to contract a squad of 25 players. This means clubs can afford to have some star players but must forgo others, thus promoting parity between teams and an even competition. Player salaries can not spiral out of control and all clubs, on their payroll bottom lines at least, should be equal.

A downside of the salary cap is that NRL players can be lured overseas or to other codes to play for more money. The English Super League, which also operates with a salary cap, is rife with ex-NRL players. Ex-Broncos star Karmichael Hunt is the big name player on the roster of AFL's new Gold Coast team. And now the Melbourne Rebels rugby union franchise is set to swoop on disgruntled Storm players.

Frankly, if players want to leave the best rugby league competition in the world in search of more cash, then the game doesn't need them. The NRL, born from working class roots, will always be a tough, competitive league no matter which 26 players run out on to the field. It's the nature of the game.

There are arguments that the Storm "team of the decade" is what all NRL clubs should strive to emulate. It is a fantastic team to watch. Outstanding, in fact. The strength, pace and skills shown in the 40-6 thrashing of the Warriors last night are testament to this.

But it's a dream team that was created under false pretence playing in reality. The "team of the decade" cheated to win three minor premierships and two premierships. The "team of the decade" should never have been assembled to begin with.

Over the past few seasons Manly, St George-Illawarra and Parramatta have all displayed qualities close to the class of the fabricated Storm. The Bulldogs, Broncos, Titans and Cowboys have not been far behind. The Tigers, Panthers, Roosters, Raiders, Rabbitohs and Knights all provide entertaining and competitive footy.

All these teams have, as far as we know, remained under the salary cap.

Exciting footy can happen without superstar teams, and without superstar teams the competition becomes more even, with all teams having a realistic chance of taking the title.

The salary cap will always have its detractors, but you can't argue with the quality of the  product on display and the closeness of competitions in recent years. Just ask anyone who is in an NRL tipping comp this season.

:: More from The Interchange

Share article: 

Comments (6)

02 May 2010 8:52 AEST


From: bribie island

cheating footballers

Too right, Taylor. They must have been cheating to beat queensland so often.

Agree (3 people agree)    Disagree (0 people disagree) Report this

28 Apr 2010 22:05 AEST

Dis Gruntled

From: Oz

Salary cap

As we get more and more talented plyers-either created by clubs or bought, their salaries should reflect their skill and talent!There are more people coming through playng league and to keep up the "competition" between each other and clubs the salary cap MUST be increased!!!!!Wake up...the money IS there people!!!

Agree (7 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this

28 Apr 2010 20:59 AEST


From: Brisbane

What about the coaches?

Let's face it. Melbourne Storm is a "super team" because it has a "super coach". Likewise, St George will become a "super team" because it has a "super coach". Super coaches will always build super teams. The down side to this is that these great teams are then penalised by the salary cap. I'm not sure what the NRL chiefs can do to change this. But it would be a shame to see these great teams disassembled so that we can have a more even (and mediocre) competition.

Agree (8 people agree)    Disagree (1 people disagree) Report this

27 Apr 2010 11:12 AEST


From: Maclean


Attentioin NRL.......turn the lights out, switch the life support off,shut the door, walk away, and throw away the key. Enough is enough already.

Agree (7 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this

26 Apr 2010 22:02 AEST


From: Melbourne

NRL salary cap in urgent need of review.

The "team of the decade" was hardly "assembled". Billy Slater, Cameron Smith, Greg Inglis and Cooper Cronk have never played for another NRL team and have been in the Storm system since they were juniors. Broke the rules? Yes. But surely the NRL system can't punish teams for developing their own talent.

Agree (13 people agree)    Disagree (2 people disagree) Report this

26 Apr 2010 16:52 AEST


From: brisbane

artical by Chris WANG

. Storm management broke the rules. If you still say "CHEATED", then by your criteria most of the great NSW teams of 1950-80's were cheats also. In that period rich Sydney bought their Premierships with cold cash at the expense of poorer clubs not to mention the raids north of the border. Players went where they got the best deal, which is still peanuts compared to other codes such as RUGBY.Gallup has made a ballsup of this which will be as big as the Super league fiasco.

Agree (10 people agree)    Disagree (4 people disagree) Report this