Australia

Deputy PM says Adani justified in demanding names of CSIRO scientists

0:00

The deputy prime minister says he understands why Adani sought the names of government scientists who reviewed a crucial plan for its Queensland coal mine.

Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack says he understands why Adani wanted the names of government scientists who reviewed a crucial plan for its Queensland coal mine.

Adani has confirmed it wrote to the federal environment department on January 25, asking for the names of government scientists from the CSIRO and Geoscience Australia.

Protesters opposing to the construction of the Adani coal mine block a main road in Southbank during a rally in Brisbane.
Protesters opposing to the construction of the Adani coal mine block a main road in Southbank during a rally in Brisbane.
AAP

At that time, the scientists were reviewing a groundwater management plan that Adani needed approval for in order to build its contentious mine.

Adani has told AAP there was nothing untoward about the request, which was ultimately refused.

It says it was simply seeking peace of mind that no bias would creep into the review process.

Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack has defended Adani after revelations it tried to get the names of scientists reviewing plans for its Queensland mine.
Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack has defended Adani after revelations it tried to get the names of scientists reviewing plans for its Queensland mine.
AAP

Mr McCormack says he understands the Indian mining company's actions.

"No doubt they wanted to determine that, I suppose, those arguing against their proposals were not just some sort of quasi, anti-development groups or individuals," he has told the ABC.

Adani has told AAP it sought the names of all CSIRO and Geoscience Australia scientists working on the review because it wanted to ensure the process was fair and free from bias.

Queensland gives Adani the green light to begin building its controversial coal mine
The Adani Abbot Point coal terminal and the Caley Valley Wetlands
AAP

In the January email, Adani told the department: "You may be aware of recent press coverage regarding an anti-coal and/or anti-Adani bias potentially held by experts reviewing other Adani government approvals.

"Those media reports have caused great concern for Adani. As a result of those reports, Adani wants to ensure that it is being treated fairly and, in a manner consistent with other industry participants."

Adani wrote that it was "not suggesting any bias in relation to these organisations" and promised not to contact individual personnel.

"Adani simply wants to know who is involved in the review to provide it with peace of mind that it is being treated fairly and that the review will not be hijacked by activists with a political, as opposed to scientific, agenda," the email read.

The first stages of construction are underway.
The first stages of construction are underway.
Supplied

The environment department said Adani's request for the scientists' names was ultimately refused.

But CSIRO staff association secretary Sam Popovski says he's alarmed by Adani's request.

"It was clear that Adani seemed to be suggesting bias, or potential bias, way before any of the scientific evidence was actually presented to the department," he told the ABC.

Adani was unable to proceed with constructing its mine until the groundwater plan was approved by both the state and federal governments.

The plan won federal ministerial approval on April 8, two days before the May 18 election was called, while the Queensland government gave it the nod in mid-June.

AAP has sought comment from the CSIRO and Geoscience Australia.

Stay up to date with SBS NEWS

  • App
  • Subscribe
  • Follow
  • Listen
  • Watch