New York must allow religious exemptions to COVID-19 vaccine mandate, judge rules

It comes as 17 workers sued over a mandate to vaccinate healthcare workers.

entrance to a vaccine centre in the United States.

Less than 60 per cent of the United States' population is vaccinated. Source: New York Times

A US judge on Tuesday ruled that New York state cannot impose a COVID-19 vaccine mandate on healthcare workers without allowing for religious exemption requests.

The decision by US District Judge David Hurd in Albany, New York prevents the state from interfering with religious exemptions requests.

Seventeen workers sued over the mandate, alleging their employer revoked an exemption or refused to consider it because of the state's emergency vaccine requirement, which was announced on 26 August.

The ruling provides a test case as vaccine opponents gear up to fight plans to be unveiled soon by the Biden administration to extend COVID-19 vaccine requirements to tens of millions of unvaccinated Americans.

New York's Department of Health on 26 August ordered healthcare professionals to be vaccinated by 27 September and the order did not allow for the customary religious exemptions.

The plan was challenged by a group of healthcare workers who said they opposed COVID-19 vaccines because some vaccines were developed from cell lines of aborted fetuses.

The workers sued using pseudonyms because they said they feared being vilified in the media and because they shared sensitive health information in their lawsuit.

The employees argued that by granting medical exemptions, the state and healthcare companies were treating those with religious objections to vaccines less favourably, violating the US Constitution's equal protection clause.

The workers said they sued under different names to avoid discrimination.
Source: Getty Images North America

Earlier, Justice Hurd ordered on 20 September that healthcare companies could not deny requests for religious exemptions until he had ruled on the request for an injunction.

Vaccines have become highly politicised in the United States, where less than 60 per cent of Americans are vaccinated, well short of the initial goals of the Biden administration.

At least 24 states have imposed vaccine requirements on workers, usually in healthcare.

Published 13 October 2021 at 7:20am
Source: Reuters - SBS