• A man plants a Pride flag at a makeshift memorial prior to an evening vigil for the victims of the Pulse Nightclub shootings. (Getty Images)Source: Getty Images
"We must reiterate the queerness of our dead brothers and sisters and refuse to have their lives strategically turned into disembodied, undifferentiated and abstract “human” lives in the name of the 'War on Terror'," writes João Florêncio.
By
João Florêncio

Source:
The Conversation
14 Jun 2016 - 4:02 PM  UPDATED 14 Jun 2016 - 4:02 PM

In the immediate aftermath of the worst mass-shooting in US history, debates in the media are already focusing on what to call the tragic event. Was it a queerphobic attack, yet another instance of Islamist terrorism targeting “the West” – or simply the case of a man who, in the words of his ex-wife, was “mentally unstable”?

Contributing to the heated debate, the father of the shooter told NBC News that his son was “enraged” after seeing two men kissing in front of his family a few months ago. The public discussion eventually escalated to spectacular proportions in the UK when Guardian journalist Owen Jones walked off the set of Sky News, outraged at what he saw as the unwillingness of Mark Longhurst and Julia Hartley-Brewer to accept it as a queerphobic attack.

Let us, however, call the tragic event for what it was: an attack on Orlando’s queer Latinx club night, Pulse. Regardless of the allegiances the shooter might have pledged, this was, without a shadow of a doubt, a queerphobic attack.

When the lives of a specific group of the population are targeted purely on the basis of their sexual, racial and/or gender identifications, we are talking about a hate crime. And hate crimes must not be co-opted into dominant logics of “us versus them”. This simply serves to feed dominant and dangerously simplistic views of a world that, in positing the “free” West against an “oppressive” Islam, conveniently overlook its political complexities and nuances.

Stigmatising mental health disorders

Other prejudices have surfaced: principally the issue of whether the shooter was mentally “unstable”, as his ex-wife suggested in an interview. Reproducing, without questioning, such a portrayal of the attacker as “a normal being that cared about family” only to then be found to be unstable and “bipolar” is problematic in several ways.

Reducing such a heinous crime to an issue of mental health stigmatises people all over the world who have been struggling with mental illness. Further to that, it also glances over the problems associated with standards of “normality” and the enduring regimes of oppression and segregation that a politics of the “normal” always requires, whether consciously or not.

But perhaps most importantly here, it also uses “mental illness” to cover up all the ways in which queer people have historically been disciplined and controlled by the heterosexual establishment and its definitions of what is “normal” and/or “acceptable”.

This is not to claim that Mateen was not suffering from mental illness. Instead, what I believe is important to stress is that the boundaries between “normality” and “abnormality” are always defined in a social landscape that is always already political. And that, similarly, the power structures that allow an individual, regardless of their mental health state, to target and kill members of a social minority are the same power structures that have, for centuries, operated to classify, discipline, tame, control and, in some cases, even “heal” the bodies of those who identify with that minority.

Mourning queer lives

This leads me to my second and final point: whether the lives of those killed at Club Pulse should be mourned as queer lives or simply as “human” lives. Claiming, like many have been doing, that those were, first and foremost, “human” lives and only then accidentally queer, is yet another example of the complexities of LGBTQIA+ politics in the West.

We are living through a time when the transgender homicide rate has hit an historic high in the US, when more than 1,700 murders of transgendered individuals were reported around the world between 2008 and 2014, and when North Carolina passed a law banning people from using government-owned bathrooms that don’t match the gender they were assigned at birth.

Meanwhile, in Britain, we are still being denied free access to PrEP, a new treatment to prevent HIV infection. Let’s not forget that gay men are still rejected as blood donors and LGB youths are four times more likely to attempt suicide.

So it is telling that it only takes a brown, (supposedly) Islamist “terrorist” for queer lives to suddenly be worth mourning publicly as “human” lives. What this reveals is how the net worth of queer bodies changes depending on who or what threatens their existence, how queer lives are only grieved for when threatened by someone with an even less grievable life – in this case, a brown Muslim.

As philosopher Judith Butler has noted, “[the] differential distribution of public grieving is a political issue of enormous significance”.

It is for this reason that today – in the aftermath of the mass shooting – we must reiterate the queerness of our dead brothers and sisters and refuse to have their lives strategically turned into disembodied, undifferentiated and abstract “human” lives in the name of the “War on Terror”. Only when we do this will we be able to stress that the difference that made those bodies targets in Orlando is the same difference that makes queer people look over our shoulders and fear for our lives on an almost daily basis no matter where we are in the world.

This article originally appeared on The Conversation. Click here to view the original.

MORE ON ORLANDO
Russian gay couple 'arrested for Orlando tribute'
A gay couple were arrested 'immediately' when they tried to leave a tribute to the Orlando shooting victims at the US embassy in Moscow.
Orlando Gay Chorus sings Cyndi Lauper's "True Colours" as beautiful tribute to massacre victims
The Orlando Gay Chorus performed at a prayer vigil held for the victims of the Pulse nightclub massacre, singing Cyndi Lauper's "True Colours", as well as "You'll Never Walk Alone".
J.K Rowling grieves for Orlando victim who worked on Harry Potter ride
Luis Vielma, a man who worked on the Harry Potter ride at the Universal Orlando Resort theme park, was among those killed over the weekend.
The Orlando shooting is hitting Latinos especially hard
For gay Latinos, the shooting was especially cruel. It came on the night of Pulse nightclub's Latin Night.
Here’s why Disney has made a statement on the Orlando nightclub shootings
Orlando is the home of Disney World, supports the LGBT+ community with its annual Gay Days event during Pride month, and many of the 74,000 employees of the park frequented Pulse nightclub.
Here's where Australia is holding candlelight vigils for the victims of the Orlando massacre
In the wake of the gun massacre at LGBT+ nightclub Pulse in Orlando, Florida, Australians are coming together to mourn the 50 lives lost.
This is how it feels to be in Orlando right now
Friends are checking hospitals, and they say that police have told them there are still bodies in the nightclub.
Gay bars and safe spaces: Why Orlando has impacted me so much
Comedian Rebecca Shaw had never felt completely safe before she stepped into her first gay bar at 18. Here she explains why the impact of the events in Orlando have resonated with her so much.
These are the faces of the Orlando massacre victims
Names of some of the victims from the Orlando gay bar Pulse Nightclub shootings have been released, with the list to be updated as more bodies are identified. Authorities have reported 50 people dead, with 53 more injured.
Australian LGBT+ community reacts to mass shooting in Orlando
A host of prominent LGBTQIA+ Australians have taken to social media to stand in solidarity with the victims of the Orlando shooting and voice their opinions on what needs to change.