SBS Radio App

Download the FREE SBS Radio App for a better listening experience

Advertisement
  • Sidhak Singh Arora and his father Sagardeep Singh Arora. (SBS)
The Victorian Civil Administrative Tribunal has ruled that Melton Christian School has breached the Equal Opportunity Act by discriminating against a five-year-old turban wearing boy, Sidhak Singh Arora.
English
By
19 Sep 2017 - 3:39 PM  UPDATED 7 Nov 2018 - 2:50 PM

A Melbourne Sikh family has a favourable outcome against a Christian college that refused entry to their son because he wears a turban.

Sagardeep Singh Arora told SBS Punjabi that VCAT has ruled MCC has breached the state's Equal Opportunity Act by placing uniform conditions on his son’s enrolment. 

“It is a great outcome. We are very pleased to hear this decision,” said Mr Arora.

“The case will set a precedent for everyone else who wants their children to practice their religion or faith and cannot do it because some schools’ uniform policy excludes them from enrolment due to their appearance or their religious beliefs.”

“We’ll be in touch with the school to resolve this issue.”

Also Read
Court reserves decision on Sidhak Singh Arora case
The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) has reserved its judgment on whether a Melbourne school discriminated against a five-year-old Sikh boy for wearing a patka - a small turban.

Melton Christian College , which during the hearing insisted its decision was lawful under exemptions to the Equal Opportunity Act, said it would work with the family to find "a constructive way forward".

"We had thought that we were acting in accordance with the law, and so we respect the finding of VCAT," principal David Gleeson said.

The decision, which was handed down on Tuesday, could have wide-ranging implications for schools and the uniform policies they set, reported The Age.

The VCAT decision is also a win for the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission (VEOHRC), who intervened in the case as the independent watchdog for equality law.

During the VCAT hearing, the commission's head of legal and dispute resolution, Sarah Bendall, said it's an important test case for the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

"We would encourage all schools to look at their polices and make sure they are compliant with the legislation," said Ms Bendall.

Also Read
Australian Sikh student denied school enrolment for wearing turban

A Sikh family from Melbourne has approached the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) after a school allegedly refused to enrol their son because his turban doesn't align with the school's uniform policy.  

UNITED SIKHS provided legal representation to Singh family with the support of a local law firm the Herbert Smith Freehills.

Mejindarpal Kaur, International Legal Director from UNITED SIKHS told SBS Punjabi that their organization is raising this issue in the interests of all religious minorities.

A joint statement issued by Sagardeep Singh (applicant), UNITED SIKHS, Victorian Sikh Gurduaras Council, Sikh Interfaith Council of Victoria and Supreme Sikh Council of Australia, states that the Sikh community is pleased with the VCAT decision.

“We the undersigned, on behalf of the Sikh community of Victoria, Australia, welcome VCAT's decision that the Melton Christian College (MCC) had violated the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 by indirectly discriminating against 5 year old Sidhak Singh, when the school refused to enrol him because he wears a patka, a head wear worn by Sikh children.”

“We are very pleased that religious freedom, as protected by the Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities and the Equal Opportunity Act, is alive in Victoria. We look forward to sitting down with the MCC to find an amicable resolution, as ordered by VCAT.”

The story that was first broadcast on SBS Punjabi triggered a nation-wide debate about the ‘right to education’ of children struggling with issues of ‘identity’ and ‘religious freedom’.

Video - The family of 5-year-old Sidhak Singh is fighting for what they call his right to study in a Christian school.

For more news and updates, follow SBS Punjabi on Facebook and Twitter.

Related Article
Melbourne Sikh family approaches court against alleged discrimination by school
A Melbourne tribunal has started hearings to decide if a school discriminated against a Sikh boy for wearing his patka - the youth version of a turban.
School turban issue: Victorian Education minister refuses to intervene
Seven Sikh families from Victoria are upset after they were denied entry to schools because their children wear turbans. SBS Punjabi contacted Victorian Minister for Education and the Minister for Multicultural Affairs for their comments on this matter.
International lobbying to stop 'school turban discrimination'
International civil rights and humanitarian organization ‘UNITED SIKHS’ plans to provide legal representation to Sikh families affected due to the ‘school turban discrimination’ in Australia.
Six more Sikh families complain of discrimination in Victorian schools
After Melton resident Sagardeep Singh Arora, six more Victorian Sikh families have alleged that their children have been subject to discrimination during the school enrollments.
Australian Sikh student denied school enrolment for wearing turban

A Sikh family from Melbourne has approached the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) after a school allegedly refused to enrol their son because his turban doesn't align with the school's uniform policy.