Comment: What if boat people were white?

Behind all the loaded language, thought-terminating clichés and monolithic psychology that has come to characterise asylum seeker policy is a question we dare not ask, let alone answer.

A detained woman and child asylum seeker from Pakistan gather at a hotel in Western Java after they were intercepted by the Australian Navy while bound for Christmas Island. (AAP)

A detained woman and child asylum seeker from Pakistan gather at a hotel in Western Java after they were intercepted by the Australian Navy while bound for Christmas Island. (AAP)

Forget racism. This has got nothing to do with the colour of people’s skin. I am sick of talking about racism.  Let’s talk about gardening.  No one gets angry about gardening.

Let’s talk about spades.

Imagine a lot of white people holding spades. Millions of them. They are driven away by other people holding guns. Some kind of super-sized Zimbabwe. Desperate families trying to escape a war zone. White mothers trying to save their white kids from being killed. White fathers wanting to escape to a better life.

If boat people were white people, we’d still lock them up. Right?

I am being divisive. Our refugee policy has got nothing to do with race. I am accusing the government of racism. I am indulging in reverse racism. Our refugee policy is supported by people from all backgrounds. No one should be labelled a racist for doing their job.

If boat people had long blonde hair, we’d still lock them up. Right?

I am being provocative. I am advocating open borders. A flood of refugees will enter our country. Our way of life will be destroyed. People will die. Our current policy is saving lives. We have to be tough to be kind. We are already being kind.
Immigration Minister Scott Morrison commenting on the Manus Island asylum seekers unrest, February 17, 2014. (AAP)
If boat people had gorgeous blue eyes, we’d still lock them up. Right?

I am playing the race card. I am introducing race into a debate that is really about law and politics and economics. This is not about the colour of refugees’ skin. Boat people are illegal. The law applies to all, regardless of religion, race or country of origin.

If boat people were white and Christian, we’d still lock them up. Right?

I am being emotional. My arguments are thin, I am dealing in hyperbole. The law is there for a reason. We must deter people from making dangerous journeys to enter our country illegally. We have the right to decide who comes into this country. We have a right to enforce our laws.

We really should talk about gardening. No one gets angry about gardening.

Imagine white men and women sewing up their lips. Blonde teenagers searching for sheets and rope. Pretty blue-eyed kids staring out from behind wire fences. Lots of would-be Australians who look exactly like most other lucky-to-born-here Australians.
Shadow Immigration Minister Richard Marles commenting on the Manus Island situation and the release of asylum seeker's personal details, February 19, 2014. (AAP)
I am stirring the pot. The law is the law. I am encouraging people to play the victim. I am over-simplifying. I have an agenda. I am playing the race card. People are always playing the race card.

If boat people were white people, we’d still lock them up. Right.

This is just my point of view. I am an armchair critic. This just another opinion piece that will never make any difference. I am not making a difference. You are not making a difference.

Let’s talk about something else. Let’s talk about gardening.

A spade is a spade is a spade. You and I are both holding a spade and we are all digging this hole together. Let’s just not call it a spade, or a hole. Let’s not have the courage to call it anything.

Let’s just keep digging.

Shourov Bhattacharya is a technologist, writer and singer-composer with The Bombay Royale.

Share
3 min read

Published

Updated


Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News daily and direct to your Inbox

Sign up now for the latest news from Australia and around the world direct to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Download our apps
SBS News
SBS Audio
SBS On Demand

Listen to our podcasts
An overview of the day's top stories from SBS News
Interviews and feature reports from SBS News
Your daily ten minute finance and business news wrap with SBS Finance Editor Ricardo Gonçalves.
A daily five minute news wrap for English learners and people with disability
Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS
SBS World News

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service
Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world
Comment: What if boat people were white? | SBS News