Watch FIFA World Cup 2026™ LIVE, FREE and EXCLUSIVE

Concerns from business, Migration Council over 457 visa's demise

The Turnbull Government is pressing ahead with sweeping changes to Australia's skilled migration system, as its abolition of the contentious 457 visa comes into effect. (wed) The new system means many migrant workers will no longer have any prospect of getting permanent residency. The Migration Council says the change has serious implications, and some businesses are warning it could make it harder to convince skilled migrants to travel to Australia.

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull Source: AAP

The Turnbull Government has ended the 457 visa, and split some of the jobs it used to cover into two separate visas.

 

One list is meant to be for higher skilled jobs, mostly in medicine and engineering.

 

Those migrant workers can still get four-year visas, and can then apply to stay in Australia permanently.

 

But the other list, which contains mostof the jobs previously under the 457, can only stay for two years.

 

Immigration minister Peter Dutton says those workers will neverget to settle in Australia.

 

f1520a                         DUTTON                     15 secs

"We now with the short term skills visa, we don't have a permanent pathway, for those people applying under that new arrangement.  That is a big change it's not an as of right that you'll become a permanent resident and an Australian citizen."

 

The CEO of the Migration Council, Carla Wilshire, says closing the pathway to permanent residency for so many workers creates a two-tier system.

 

f1520b                         WILSHIRE                              24 secs

"One of the concerns is that this will break up our temporary migration program into two different tiers: one that has an option for permanent residency and one that doesn't.  And the one that doesn’t might end up looking a lot more like a guest worker system in Australia, rather than an option for permanent residency. And that has really big implications for the types of migrants that come here and for the incentives in terms of staying in Australia."

 

Ms Wilshire says many migrant workers who come to Australian on 457s are motivated by the prospect of one day gaining permanent residency.

 

She says removing that incentive will make it harder for businesses to convince workers to make the journey.

 

f1520c                         WILSHIRE                              20 secs

 

"One of the things that the Australian migration program really relies on is being able to attract the best and the brightest in all different skills categories, across all different positions, all different sectors of the economy. What we need to be able to do is to provide really strong incentives to get the best and the brightest, and permanent residency in Australia is a really big part of that."

 

The majority of IT jobs have been moved to the two-year visa, with no prospect of permanent residency.

 

Nick Ingall is from tech company Safety Culture.

 

f1520d                         INGALL                                   9 secs

"It's already a very competitive market as is, so having the ability to top up our workforce with individuals from abroad is key to us being a successful business."

 

One of his staff is Ben Morrison, a 31 year-old American who moved from Silicon Valley to work in Australia on a 4-5-7 visa.

 

Workers already here on 4-5-7s won't be affected by the change.

 

But Mr Morrison says he might not have come, if the possibility of a life in Australia wasn't on the table.

 

f1520e                         MORRISON                20 secs

"What attracted to the 457 was the ability to actually stay. to come to Australia and stay. It's a place that I've always wanted to visit when I was a kid and it kind of stuck with me, and the fact that I have an occupation that allows me to come to another country that I want to be in and visit, and possibly stay indefinitely, is a pretty amazing opportunity. "

 

But not everyone in the IT industry thinks there is a problem with incentives.

 

CEO of the Australian Computer Society, Andrew Johnson, says most 457s working in the sector work for multinationals, and don't expect permanent residency.

 

f1520f                          JOHNSON                  22 secs

"I think the bulk - you know, anecdotally - the bulk of people participating on 457s in technology-related areas would be in the multinational-type space and they're filling a gap that's an immediate need. So I couldn't come up with a number as to how many would be not incentivised to pursue that, but we have other migration pathways for permanent residency."

 

The government is reportedly planning a broader overhaul of immigration.

 

The Prime Minister is expected to announce major citizenship changes, including limits to the number of times people can fail the citizenship test.


4 min read

Published

Updated

By James Elton-Pym

Presented by Majlinda Lulo, Sani Kajtazi



Share this with family and friends