Health experts counter 'new year, new me' diet dangers and weight stigma

Overhead view of young Asian woman using fitness plan mobile app on smartphone to tailor make her daily diet meal plan, checking the nutrition facts and calories intake of her meal, sourdough toast with smashed avocado and cherry tomatoes in a restaurant

Overhead view of young Asian woman using fitness plan mobile app on smartphone to tailor make her daily diet meal plan. Source: Moment RF

Every new year, the media is flooded with ads for exercise and weight-loss programs promising to make you healthier. But with scientific evidence showing dieting is actually more likely to cause physical and psychological harm, increasing numbers of health professionals are encouraging a weight-neutral approach to wellbeing.


The end of one year and beginning of another is often a time for reflection. It's also a period when weight-loss companies spend most of their advertising dollars. Alicia Holmquest says that's no coincidence.

Ms Holmquestis a qualified dietitian and co-founder of WIRL - a mental well-being app that uses food to improve young women's mood. She says the multi-billion dollar diet industry weaponises the guilt and shame many people experience after the festive period to encourage them to lose weight at all costs.


Highlights

  • Dr Fiona Willer, dietitian and lecturer at Queensland University of Technology says given the variety of factors that influence a person's size, it isn’t a reliable indicator of their physical health.
  • People typically lose five to 10 % of their starting weight within the first six months of their diet, studies show the vast majority of them regain it all - and sometimes more - within two to five years
  • Moving from a weight-centric to weight-neutral approach of assessing and treating wellbeing concerns  that underpins Health At Every Size or HAES Approach.

 Listen to podcast here:



"The top two goals that people set are around improving their fitness or losing weight, and the entire health and wellness industry, particularly, prey on people's insecurities at this time of year and people's willingness to want to make a change. 

Even though they say 'you'll feel better, you'll look better', all these promises that they make, we know from the science that following these things actually leads to things like body dissatisfaction, things like poor self-esteem, low self-confidence, because all we then know is that ' if I live in a smaller body, I'm going to be more confident', and that is just simply untrue.

And it also leads to things like disordered eating behaviours. So they teach us, they are literally teaching us how to cut foods of our diet, how to demonise foods and label them as good or bad or putting moral value on foods."

 

 


Share
Follow SBS Filipino

Download our apps
SBS Audio
SBS On Demand

Listen to our podcasts
Independent news and stories connecting you to life in Australia and Filipino-speaking Australians.
Understand the quirky habits of Aussie life.
Get the latest with our exclusive in-language podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS
SBS News in Filipino

SBS News in Filipino

Watch it onDemand