Transplant tourism and forced harvesting expose the dark side of organ donation

Unsettling evidence of forced organ harvesting in China continues to emerge, with some even travelling to China to receive human organs, says Sophia Bryskine, but improving local donation systems may help fight the problem.

JAPAN MINISTRY GRANTS PERMISSION FOR HISTORIC HUMAN-ANIMAL HYBRID EXPERIMENTS

JAPAN MINISTRY GRANTS PERMISSION FOR HISTORIC HUMAN-ANIMAL HYBRID EXPERIMENTS Source: Getty Images

In June, the China Tribunal, a London-based independent tribunal investigating forced organ harvesting in China, delivered a final, damning report on the subject. It concluded that there is no doubt that organs are being forcibly removed from Chinese prisoners of conscience, and transplanted into other individuals.

Sophia Bryskine, a spokesperson for Doctors Against Forced Organ Harvesting (DAFOH), tells SBS Russian that she welcomes the report.

“We [DAFOH] were waiting for this report because it is the first independent in-depth official assessment that sends a very strong message to the international community,” Bryskine says.
Sophia Bryskine, spokesperson for Doctors Against Forced Organ Harvesting, Australia
Sophia Bryskine, spokesperson for Doctors Against Forced Organ Harvesting, Australia Source: Submitted by S. Bryskine
DAFOH has campaigned against forced organ harvesting since 2007, and Bryskine was a prominent critic of the ‘Real Bodies: The Exhibition’ last year, which was believed to feature plastinated cadavers belonging to Chinese political prisoners.

“The world first heard about these illegal practices in 2001, when Dr Wang Guoqi testified before the US government committee that he’d been involved in these operations,” she says.

“But since 2006, more information started to appear in the media about organs being removed from living prisoners of so-called labour camps and sold to wealthy local and foreign patients.”

Transplant Tourism

The organs harvested in China are not only destined for Chinese consumers, with evidence emerging of a disturbing trend of organ transplant tourism emerging in recent years.

A 2017 South Korean documentary on China’s transplant tourism featured three Korean journalists travelling to China under the pretence of purchasing a kidney for a fictitious relative.

In a meeting with a nurse at a Chinese hospital, they receive assurances that their ‘relative’ can get a kidney in a few weeks for about US$130,000. 
Falun Gong members practicing meditation at Circular Quay, Sydney.
Falun Gong members practicing meditation at Circular Quay, Sydney. Source: SBS News
The documentary claims that South Koreans are one of the largest consumer groups of organ transplants in China, where any organs are available for purchase in the matter of weeks.

“There’s just no explanation of this extraordinarily short waiting time,” Bryskine says. “Culturally, Chinese people tend to believe the body must remain intact after death, and that is why the number of voluntary donors remains low. Until 2013, China did not have a public organ donation scheme, their national donation programme is just six years old.”

But Bryskine says there are thousands of involuntary donors among prisoners in China, and Chinese officials have even admitted using death row prisoners as a source of organs in the past. Beijing denies all allegations of forcibly harvesting the organs of living prisoners of conscience.
Organisers of the Real Bodies, The Exhibition say specimens are "unclaimed bodies" from China.
Organisers of the Real Bodies, The Exhibition say the specimens featured are "unclaimed bodies" from China. Source: AAP

Calls to ban Transplant Tourism in Australia

It is not clear exactly how many Australian citizens have travelled to China for organ transplants, though federal parliamentary submissions say up to 55 people travelled for transplants between 2005 and 2016.

Organ trafficking is a serious criminal offence in Australia, but Bryskine says there is no official database of people who received transplants in other countries, and that the Australian Government must do more to stop human organ trafficking. 

“It is important to inform people that when they are travelling to China, or other countries known for their illegal practices, they probably get an organ which was forcibly removed,” she says. 

According to the Australian Parliamentary Report for the inquiry into Human Organ Trafficking and Organ Transplant Tourism,  transplant tourism is considered as "both unethical and medically hazardous for patients to travel overseas to receive a commercial organ transplant".

The 2018 report’s recommendations include strengthening Australia Government's involvement in international efforts to stop human organ trafficking, collecting data on Australians involved in illegal organ trafficking overseas and the introduction of new laws around organ harvesting.
Members of Falun Gong or Falun Dafa protest the alleged improsonment, torture and organ harvesting of fellow members in China.
Members of Falun Gong or Falun Dafa protest the alleged improsonment, torture and organ harvesting of fellow members in China. Source: Getty Images

Falun Gong victims in Australia

The China Tribunal’s final report states that “imprisoned Falun Gong members are probably the principal source of organs for forced harvesting” and the stories of Australian Falun Gong members confirm the Tribunal's findings.

They spoke to SBS News about being subjected to regular blood tests and X-rays while in China’s detention centers.

"One day I remember very clearly, they didn't take us to hospital to get a health check, instead they took two vials of blood from each of the inmates in jail ... and provided no explanation”, Tony Liu, one of the Falun Gong members, told SBS News.

Improving ethical transplantation to save lives and combat trafficking

Different organ donation and transplantation schemes are in place across the world, with varying degrees of success.

Spain has led the world in organ donation systems for the last 25 years, and performed 5,314 donations in 2018, compared to 1,618 in Australia over the same period. China performs between 60,000 and 90,000 transplants per year, according to the China Tribunal.

The World Health Organisation considers Spain’s opt-out donation system, where a patient is presumed to consent to organ donation even if they have never registered as a donor unless they opt out, as one of the world’s best.
organ donation utsav
Organ Donation has doubled in Australia during past decade Source: Getty Images
Australia operates an opt-in system, where a person must register to donate their organs or tissues.

“One in three Australians are registered donors despite the majority (69 per cent) believing that registering is important,” says the Donatelife website, where Australians can quickly register to become a donor.

Today, around 1,400 Australians are currently waitlisted for a transplant, and the Australian transplant waiting list can contribute to demand on the human organ black market.
Donate Life Week 2019
Source: Facebook

Share
5 min read

Published

Updated

By Svetlana Elgina

Share this with family and friends


Follow SBS Russian

Download our apps
SBS Audio
SBS On Demand

Listen to our podcasts
Independent news and stories connecting you to life in Australia and Russian-speaking Australians.
Understand the quirky parts of Aussie life.
Get the latest with our exclusive in-language podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS
Russian News

Russian News

Watch in onDemand