It was the afternoon of September 12, the second-to-last major mountain leg of the Tour of Spain, finishing on the formidable special category climb of Sierra Nevada.
For Evans, sitting pretty in second on the overall classification, seven seconds off the lead of Alejandro Valverde, he knew what was required: stay in touch with the maillot oro (golden jersey) till the final climb, and if he could, distance himself from the Spaniard and Rabobank's Robert Gesink, the Dutchman eleven seconds behind Evans at the start of the day.
But the Australian never got his chance to discover what might have been, and for this tour at least, never will.
His puncture on the penultimate climb of the first category Monachil came at a bad time, just as the favourites' group was nearing its crest. However, it wasn't so much the puncture that cost Evans, but the following one-and-a-half minutes where he was left standing at the roadside.
A neutral spares motorbike with two mechanics soon arrived. Evans' Silence-Lotto team uses Campagnolo equipment and Shimano was the sponsor of the neutral spares vehicles at the Vuelta, but that wasn't the problem: for some unknown reason, neither of the two mechanics could pop the new wheel back in; a relatively straightforward task you'd expect both to have done thousands of times before.
"Err... slight problem when the GC group is riding away from you on the second-last hilltop finish of the Vuelta," Evans wrote on his website post-stage.
Other photographers' bikes made a bad situation worse by blocking the road behind, and by the time his team car arrived to hand him a new bike, a minute and twenty-three seconds had past.
Evans ended the day one minute and eight seconds behind Valverde – it was fifty-eight seconds, but to add insult to injury the officials awarded him a ten-second penalty for being handed a water bottle – and dropped to eighth overall.
The events bore a strong resemblance to an edition of the Vuelta twenty-five years ago.
Entering the penultimate leg, a 200-kilometre medium-mountain stage from Alcala to Segovia, Scotsman Robert Millar, riding for the Peugeot team, was leading the 1985 race, set to become the first English-speaking rider to triumph in a grand tour.
The only rival he needed to concern himself with was Colombian Pacho Rodriguez, just ten seconds behind on the general classification. Millar wasn't worried: till then, he had been the strongest rider throughout - and showed no signs of waning.
On the Cotos, second-last climb of a three-climb stage, Millar punctured on its lower slopes, but unlike Evans, he received a quick wheel-change and with the aid of team-mates Pascal Simon andRonan Pensec, he rejoined the lead group. Or had he?
On this inclement, dog of a day, punctuated by rainstorms and hail, the Scot soon realised Rodriguez and the rider placed third on the overall standings,Pello Ruiz Cabestany (a team-mate of Spanish cycling's next big thing, Pedro Delgado), in contravention of cycling's unwritten rule of the road, had attacked whenMillar punctured. So, after another effort and over the top of the Cotos, he was back with the leaders.
Accounts of what then unfolded vary somewhat. But this is fact: unknown to Millar, Spaniard José Recio had broken away just before the crest of the Cotos, and Delgado, his team clothing camouflaged by a rain cape, was soon in tow, with 69km left to race.
Delgado was the best placed, though 6:13 behind Millar on the overall. Still, Millar had no idea that Delgado was one of the escapees till 26km from the finish, when his sport director came up and told him the lead pair was nearly 4 min in front.
Without any team-mates, Millar found himself isolated among his group of ten, seven of whom were Spanish. The other three initially helped him before the Colombian Rodriguez told the Scot he'd rather see Delgado win than keep his second place overall.
Delgado gifted the stage victory to Recio. Millar's group came in 6:39 down. He'd just lost what would have been the biggest win of his career.
In a repugnant gesture, Delgado publicly thanked the other Spanish teams; and Recio's manager told Colombian journalists that as much as it pained him to hold his rider back, "anything was preferable to allowing Millar the victory".
There's also the story of the twenty-man chase group behind Millar's that contained his team-mates Simon and Pensec, and seemed to be closing in till road barriers came down at a level train crossing – but the train never came.
The antipathy towards Millar – or perhaps more correctly, an Anglophone winning the Vuelta – was obvious not just among the peloton, but on the roadside, too. One banner read: 'Españoles, valientes, Que no gane El Pendientes' (Brave Spaniards, don't let the one with the earring win).
"I am completely disgusted with it all," Millar told veteran journalist John Wilcockson the following day, when it was official he had lost the Vuelta.
"I haven't lost the race because I cracked up. You can't compete against the whole peloton. I feel betrayed. After all my efforts, it's sickening to lose like this."
Now read Evans' words immediately after the stage to Sierra Nevada: "I don't deserve that. I do everything f****** right in this sport. I don't deserve that shit."
Hours later, he reiterated those feelings on his Web page. "After the BS I have been through just to get to this race, I am not so sure I deserved that."
If history is anything to go by, it's been a while since the Spanish has played fair at their home tour.
Watch the FIFA World Cup 2026™, Tour de France, Tour de France Femmes, Giro d’Italia, Vuelta a España, Dakar Rally, World Athletics / ISU Championships (and more) via SBS On Demand – your free live streaming and catch-up service. Read more about Sport
Have a story or comment? Contact Us

