David and Margaret clash over whether Ben Elton\'s <i>Maybe Baby </i>is delightful or puerile. <br>

David and Margaret clash over whether Ben Elton\'s Maybe Baby is delightful or puerile.

Sam and Lucy Bell, Hugh Laurie and Joely Richardson, want desperately to have a baby. Sam is a commissioning editor at the BBC, and Lucy works at a talent agency, but a lot of their time is spent trying to get Lucy pregnant. Demoted by an arrogant new boss, and relagated to producing a kiddies` programme, Sam`s in urgent need of material for a new drama - he gets the idea of writing a comedy based on his own, and Lucy`s, experiences - but he doesn`t get round to telling her.. Ben Elton`s foray into feature film direction is a frequently hilarious comedy, which is sometimes deliberately painful, at others a bit repetitive. There`s plenty of well observed and very funny jibes at the British film and TV industry and some wonderful characters - a vain, arrogant Scottish film director, amusingly played by Tom Hollander, a vain, sexy actor, played by James Purefoy, who joins the talent agency and who gets cast in Sam`s script, while taking his place in Lucy`s affections. In one of many cameo roles, Rowan Atkinson is very funny as every woman`s nightmare gynaecologist. Hugh Laurie, in a Hugh Grant-ish kind of role, is very good, and Joely Richardson is, once again, delightful. I had a really good time with this unpretentious, very British comedy. Margaret`s Comments:This terribly self-congratulatory work is embarrassingly adolescent in its attempts at humour. Dialogue and performances are overcooked to a self-consciousness rarely seen in modern cinema. Considering the real pain involved in not being able to conceive a child and going through the process of IVF I found this film rather tasteless as well. And considering the talent involved Maybe Baby, although ostensibly meant to be a comedy, is actually tragic. Joely Richardson can give charming performances, here she`s irritatingly twee. Hugh Laurie tries to retain a stiff upper lip about the whole thing but never manages to convince us he`s in anything other than a television skit. Casting Rowan Atkinson as a slavering obstetrician is merely another example of writer/director Ben Elton`s lack of judgement. And Dawn French as a coarse Australian nurse! For a first film from a comic talent like Elton this is a major disappointment.

Share

3 min read

Published

By David Stratton

Source: SBS


Share this with family and friends


Download our apps
SBS On Demand
SBS News
SBS Audio

Listen to our podcasts
SBS's award winning companion podcast.
Join host Yumi Stynes for Seen, a new SBS podcast about cultural creatives who have risen to excellence despite a role-model vacuum.
Get the latest with our SBS podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch SBS On Demand
Over 11,000 hours

Over 11,000 hours

News, drama, documentaries, SBS Originals and more - for free.