Watch FIFA World Cup 2026™

LIVE, FREE and EXCLUSIVE

Comment: Democracy and dreams don’t always mix

As Joko Widodo soaks up the glory of becoming Indonesia’s seventh President, spare a thought for those who aspire to similar lofty heights, only to come crashing to the ground.

Joko Widodo
Joko Widodo, soaking up the glory of becoming Indonesia’s seventh President.

Born and raised in a riverside squat in the city of Surakarta, also known as Solo, in Central Java province, Jokowi was declared the winner of Indonesia’s presidential election on Tuesday, with a convincing 53 per cent of the national vote.

Meanwhile his challenger, ex-general Prabowo Subianto, a successful businessman who comes from a prominent and wealthy Javanese political family, was reduced to suggesting the outcome was rigged.

The rags to riches theme is big business in contemporary Indonesia, if the deluge of books containing inspirational and motivational tales is anything to go by.

One of these, Laskar Pelangi (The Rainbow Troops), has sold more than five million copies, making its author, Andrea Hirata, the best-selling writer of all time in the country.

It tells of overcoming poverty and standing up to the powerful, and in 2008, was made into an award-winning film.

News that makes sense

Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Such was the appeal of the film, candidates vying for presidency in the lead up to the 2014 Indonesian election connected with the theme, by hiring writers to pen similar tales starring themselves. They included Aburizal Bakrie, also a media mogul and one of Indonesia's richest men, who commissioned Anak Sejuta Bintang (Child of a Million Stars).

Direct presidential elections started a decade ago, as part of Indonesia’s return to democracy, following the fall of long-time dictator Suharto, in 1998.

Jokowi stands out as extraordinary among politicians in Indonesia and beyond, for being so ordinary in appearance, speech and background, says ANU College of Asia and the Pacific academic Ariel Heryanto.

That someone like him could rise from a slum to president elect in a country formerly ruled by a dictatorship is cause for celebration in the world’s third-largest democracy.

But, as Indonesia’s entertainment industry fuels the notion that democracy can allow anyone to be plucked from obscurity or poverty and turned into a leader, star or billionaire, Heryanto has a cautionary tale.

In his newly published Identity and Pleasure: The Politics of Indonesian Screen Culture, he suggests the huge success of the reality television singing show, Indonesian Idol, lies in its “emphasis on the democratic voting system via SMS to elect the Idola”.  

Among those who perhaps got far too wrapped up in the hype were candidates vying for seats in the 2009 Indonesian parliamentary elections.

“Candidates were moved to imitate the television hit program,” Heryanto says.

“Apparently, it was precisely this show that gave many of the candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds the inspiration and the requisite hope to run for the elections in the first place.”

The result was hoards of massively distressed people who did not win seats.

“The mass media reported psychiatric wards being overwhelmed with former candidates, who were experiencing mental disorders following their defeat in the polls,” Heryanto says.

 “Elsewhere, a significant number of failed candidates decided to commit suicide.

“As in their favourite show Indonesian Idol it appears that many contestants had been lured by false promises of extraordinary success and paid a high price when reality finally hit home.”

Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (SBY) was never seriously considered a political leader, let alone a presidential candidate, before he formerly ran for elections in 2004.

Heryanto suggests the mass media probably played a big part in his securing a second term in 2009. His main contender for the presidency, Megawati Sukarnoputri, on the other hand, disappointed the Indonesian public by evading the media.

When confronted by journalists, she said little, if anything at all.

“In contrast, SBY not only paid generous attention to the demands of the media, the former military officer even went as far as singing at public functions , published three albums of his songs, and attended the finals of the Indonesian Idol competition,” Heryanto points out.

The need for politicians like SBY to pursue celebrity like status was partly due to new regulations introduced in 2009 that didn’t allow party leaders to secure their re-election, as they had in the past, through placing themselves at the top of party rankings.

“Under the new laws, politicians had no choice but to invest in new and extensive campaign efforts in order to maintain their positions,”  Heryanto explains.

“As a side effect of this more competitive electoral system, a new type of candidate emerged to challenge the dominance of old party functionaries: ‘celebrities’, more specifically television and film actors, musicians and comedians.”

He says of the 11,000 candidates who ran for parliamentary seats in 2009, 61 were celebrities – a small overall percentage, but nonetheless, highly effective.

Among the success stories were television drama actor Rieke Dyan Pitaloka, who obtained the single largest number of votes for PDIP (Partai Demokrasi Indonesia Perjuangan) in the West Java II district, leaving party leader Taufiq Kiemas behind.

Similarly, former film star Nurul Arifin ranked first in West Java VII district, defeating senior politician Ade Komarudin from the same party.

Another effect of the amended electoral law was that it encouraged an upsurge in the desire among ordinary citizens to run in regional elections.

“The 2009 electoral laws made democratic procedures more equal, leading many to the illusion that all citizens are politically equal in elections, regardless of their socioeconomic strength and connections,” Heryanto says.

But the delusion of many commoners and their ambition to run for the parliamentary elections at local and national levels ended in disappointment both in 2009 and 2014.

Perhaps only a chosen few are destined for the limelight. After all, if everyone got to shine, there’d be no one clapping on the sidelines.

Identity and Pleasure: The Politics of Indonesian Screen Culture is published by National University of Singapore Press.

Belinda Cranston is a writer at the ANU College of Asia and the Pacific.


6 min read

Published

Updated

By Belinda Cranston


Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News straight to your inbox

Sign up now for daily news from Australia and around the world. You can also subscribe to Insight's weekly newsletter for in-depth features and first-person stories.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Follow SBS News

Download our apps

Listen to our podcasts

Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service

Stream now

Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world