Watch FIFA World Cup 2026™

LIVE, FREE and EXCLUSIVE

How does a goalkeeper win a penalty shootout? Two Aussie legends explain

With four decades of experience between them, Lydia Williams and Andrew Redmayne share their insights into penalty shootouts.

A woman in a blue shirt stands holding a ball next to a man wearing a white shirt holding a ball on a green football field
Both Lydia Williams (left) and Andrew Redmayne have worn the green and gold for Australia in the net. Source: AAP / AAPIMAGE

It's a moment in football that can make the world's largest arenas fall silent and soften the steeliest of nerves: the penalty shootout.

For two Australian legends of the game, the key to winning one is preparation and process.

On-field preparation is easy, according to former Socceroo and Central Coast Mariners player Andrew Redmayne.

"You've already had 120 minutes of football, so you're fairly warm physically," he told SBS News.

Given that, he said it's mainly about how a player comes into the game.

News that makes sense

Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

"There are some technical things that you can work on in training.

"The biggest thing in recent history is data, analytics and videos of where players go historically, and under what circumstances they go to each side ... you do your research in that regard."

'The pressure's on the striker'

Former Matilda and Noongar woman Lydia Williams guarded the net for Australia for almost two decades.

She said despite all eyes being on the goalkeeper, the pressure rests with the striker.

"The pressure's on the striker, so you want to put doubt in their mind," Williams said.

"Whether that's not going to your line right away, doing up your shoelace ... you buy time for yourself and put pressure on the striker."

Goalkeeper Lydia Williams in the Matilda's kit, grabbing a ball from above her head standing inside the net.
Lydia Williams retired from the Matildas in August 2025, ending a career of more than two decades in the net. Source: AAP / Dan Himbrechts

Williams would often grab a drink of water or take time tightening her gloves.

Not only would it spook the striker, but it also gave her valuable time to step through her process and stay grounded.

"You do all of the work prior, through training, through video sessions — so when it does happen, you kind of already have an awareness, you're calm and at peace and going through the process," she said.

The art of distraction

With over 21 years of experience in the A-League, Redmayne celebrated his 300th game in the competition in April.

In 2022, his save of the intercontinental play-off penalty shootout against Peru in Qatar secured Australia's ticket to the 2022 FIFA World Cup.

Like Williams, Redmayne has his own unique process — involving a "jig".

"Players are really set in their focus and their processes ... We came up with my little jig and routine to try and distract the taker," he explained.

"Anytime you can ... take someone's mental clarity, or train of thought away from their process, even for a split second, then you're winning the battle."

In that monumental moment at Qatar, failure never crossed Redmayne's mind.

"I never envisaged failure.
It wasn't till I got back that a good friend of mine asked if I ever thought what would happen if I went on and did my thing and it didn't work? And in that moment, my heart literally sank," he said.

"I was almost physically ill in that moment; failure had never crossed my mind — and that was probably a good thing."

Redmayne expressed his sympathy for Socceroo Matt Ryan — who didn't save a single penalty shot against Egypt in the World Cup knockout round.

"He's copped a lot of flak. I feel so sorry for him because the pressure isn't on the goalie here," Redmayne said.

"He's gone out and executed this to the best of his abilities, and it just didn't work."

How to cope with failure

Both Redmayne and Williams have their methods of coping with failure.

"Whether you have a positive action or negative action, communicating is huge," said Redmayne.

"Goalkeepers can be a bit disjointed from a team; we're at the back for large parts of the game ... staying involved in the game can help distract you from the bad things and pull you back down from any highs you have too."

A bearded goalkeeper in a teal jersey and shorts kicks a ball down the field during a match.
Andrew Redmayne celebrated his 300th game in Australia's A-League in April 2026. Source: AAP / Darren Pateman

For Williams, the best way to stay grounded was to self-reflect.

"For me, it was visually learning. So, going back and watching games, talking things through with my goal coach and players to keep everything level and make sure everyone was on the same page."

In situations where things didn't go to plan, Williams stayed committed to moving forward.

"If you do save it, you continue to play. If you don't, there's probably another opportunity in the match, so you just continue doing what you're doing," she said.

"And there was always another game the following week ... I'd just go to training the next day, make sure I caught the balls, and I didn't let it affect me."

Redmayne still uses an old trick from "park football" in the big moments.

"I had a coach say to me ... bad action happens, scrunch it up in your head and look around and find a bin around the local park and mentally throw it in the bin," he said.

"Getting a bit older now, I do like to pause in those moments and take a few deep breaths ... that just grounds me.

"It also reminds me that you're not going to play forever, so enjoy being out there, soak in the atmosphere and find the positive."


For the latest from SBS News, download our app and subscribe to our newsletter.


5 min read

Published

By Rachael Knowles

Source: SBS News



Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News straight to your inbox

Sign up now for daily news from Australia and around the world. You can also subscribe to Insight's weekly newsletter for in-depth features and first-person stories.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Follow SBS News

Download our apps

Listen to our podcasts

Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service

Stream now

Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world