Is it cheaper to rent or to buy? The RBA may have the answer


It's one of the biggest debates held in households across the country: is it cheaper to rent or buy? A new paper by the Reserve Bank has tried to tackle the question.

Is housing overvalued? It's not only the question on everyone's lips, but it's also the title of a research discussion paper published by the Reserve Bank of Australia on Monday.

But don't expect to find a definitive pointer to whether housing prices will continue rising in line with the 11 per cent annual gain for mainland capital city housing prices reported on Monday by RP Data, stagnate, or turn down.

The paper, by RBA economists Ryan Fox and Peter Tulip, represents the views of the authors, and "not necessarily" the RBA.

But such papers are often a good guide to the sort of things being looked at closely by the central bank. The paper asks as its starting point whether it would be better to rent than to buy a home.

It found that if house prices keep growing at the average rate of the past sixty years, then buying a house would be as costly, as renting. 

But if the pace drops, renters would be the real winners.

If it's cheaper to rent than to buy, taking into account interest and other costs as well as expect capital gain from rising prices, then housing is overvalued. 

The paper found that housing prices have increased at an average annual rate of around 2.4 per cent. 

If that continues - as it has so far - then owning a home, costs the same, as renting.

The RBA's advice is that if homebuyers expect house prices to rise faster than 2.9 per cent a year, then buying would be more attractive.

"If this rate of appreciation is expected to continue then our estimates suggest that houses are fairly valued," Tulip and Fox concluded.

But, as they acknowledge, forecasting housing prices is a business plagued by uncertainty and "many observers have suggested that future house price growth is likely to be somewhat less than this historic average," they said.

"In that case, at current prices, rents, interest rates and so on, the average household is probably financially better off renting than buying."

In other words, housing prices are not overvalued if prices are going to rise at the average rate. But they are overvalued if price rises, in retrospect, turn out to be slower than normal.

The RBA analysed a range of costs involved in owning a house but not applicable to renters, such as council fees, interest rates, and the purchase price.

There are also non-financial benefits of owning a home, for example security of tenure, free of debt and freedom to renovate.

The authors say their measures of overvaluation may help to predict future house price growth, but that is yet to be tested.

Source AAP

Stay up to date with SBS NEWS

  • App
  • Subscribe
  • Follow
  • Listen
  • Watch