Britain's great scone debate: to jam or cream first

We never knew scones could make people this upset. #sconegate

To jam or cream first: Britain is locked in a scone debate

The original post that sparked the debate had jam on top but plenty say that's the wrong order. Source: Pinterest

Up until recently, we thought scones were relatively harmless baked goods – fluffy, white, high-tea staples topped with sweat cream and strawberry jam. Yummy, quaint and entirely British, but hardly worth starting an Internet war over, right? 

How wrong we were. 

In a Facebook advertisement for a Mother’s Day afternoon tea, Cornish National Trust property Lanhydrock House and Garden accidentally sent the Internet into a meltdown by posting a picture of a scone topped with cream and then jam (not the other way around). 

This seemingly innocuous act is actually the modern-day British ‘shot heard around the world’, re-igniting a long-standing debate (read: fight) between two English counties, Cornwall and Devon, over how scones should be consumed.
Lanhydrock’s Facebook followers are NOT taking this indiscretion lightly. 

“Come on Lanhydrock, this will never do…😳being in Cornwall you should know that the jam ALWAYS goes first and clotted cream ON TOP....... seriously!!!” One Facebook use said. 

“I am a Dutch woman who loves Cornwall and EVEN I know that JAM on top is "not done" in Corwall. This must be a Joke from Lanhydrock,” said another. 

Someone even went so far as to call it “cultural vandalism,” which, while we’d never try to downplay the significance of scones for the Brits, seems a bit extreme.  

A user by the name of Justin Parkhouse seems to think it’s okay, though. “There are some pathetic people on here, cream first is the proper way and well done national trust for showing these people the correct way, I can only commend you for trying to teach them right from wrong,” he says. 

The debate has raged on Twitter (yes, the trending hashtag is #sconegate), to no real end other than to leave everyone who’s not from the UK wondering what all the fuss is about.
This guy reckons Jam Firsters should go straight to the slammer. The jury’s still out on whether he’s joking or not.
Of course, Australian’s might draw paralleles between #sconegate and the jam-or-no-jam lamington debate that’s been raging for decades now. While traditional laminations may have been all sans-jam, some modern lamington lovers prefer to add a layer of jam in between two slabs of the trademark sponge cake. The debate has inspired enough controversy for an entire book on the subject: The Lamington Enigma, A survey of the Evidence by Maurice French. 

Amidst the uproar, Lanhydrock apologised for the oversight and any offence caused.
Thank goodness for that. 

Follow the #sconegate hashtag on Twitter for more British overreactions about baked goods.

Share
Follow SBS Food
SBS Food is a 24/7 foodie channel for all Australians, with a focus on simple, authentic and everyday food inspiration from cultures everywhere. NSW stream only. Read more about SBS Food
Have a story or comment? Contact Us

SBS Food is a 24/7 foodie channel for all Australians, with a focus on simple, authentic and everyday food inspiration from cultures everywhere. NSW stream only.
Watch nowOn Demand
Follow SBS Food
3 min read

Published

Updated

By Lucy Rennick


Share this with family and friends


SBS Food Newsletter

Get your weekly serving. What to cook, the latest food news, exclusive giveaways - straight to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Download our apps
SBS On Demand
SBS News
SBS Audio

Listen to our podcasts
You know pizza, pasta and tiramisu, but have you tried the Ugly Ducklings of Italian Cuisine?
Everybody eats, but who gets to define what good food is?
Get the latest with our SBS podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch SBS On Demand
Bring the world to your kitchen

Bring the world to your kitchen

Eat with your eyes: binge on our daily menus on channel 33.