Election 2016: Can the Greens win the Vic seat of Batman?

The voice of the Greens seems to be growing in Melbourne, where the party is confident it can capitalise on changing inner-city demographics and claim its second lower-house seat. Their strongest hope is the seat of Batman, where Labor is seemingly in trouble.

Voters in Batman

Voters in Batman Source: SBS

The electorate of Batman, in Melbourne’s north has changed dramatically in the past few years.

Traditionally populated with working-class migrants, there’s been a shift in demographics, particularly in the inner suburbs, as affordability has pushed people out.

The electorate has long been a safe Labor seat. It’s been held by David Feeney since 2013, following Martin Ferguson’s resignation.

Mr Feeny is one of the powerbrokers behind the Rudd-Gillard switch and considered a strong campaigner, by Labor strategists.

But he's now facing the fight of his political life, compounded by a series of campaign gaffs, including not declaring his 2.3 million dollar Northcote home.

The multicultural electorate starts with Clifton Hill bordering the CBD in the south, moves into gentrified Northcote and Thornbury, before crossing Bell Street further north into Preston, and working-class Reservoir and Thomastown.

Editor of Melbourne University’s Election Watch, Cathy Harper, described the shift in demographic within the seat. 

“There's a bit of a divide, south of Bell street it's becoming a lot younger, it's becoming a lot more highly-professional, but in the north there's the sort of more traditional migrant family type situation,” she said.

Greens have hope

After four elections, the Greens Batman candidate, Alex Bhathal, thinks she can finally wrestle victory.

She's targeting education and health, and is increasingly hearing from people living in the northern part of the electorate who are wanting to know more about Greens policies.

“I had a phone call from a grandmother a couple of weeks ago,” Ms Bhathal told SBS.

“She felt that Liberal and Labor were looking really similar, and she could see that the Greens was a party that was sort of standing out on our own principles.”

Preferencing deals have been hotly debated this election campaign, and perhaps nowhere more so than in the seat of Batman.

Though Labor holds it with a healthy 10.6 per cent margin, Cathy Harper says it’s likely to swing towards the Greens if the Liberal party sends its preferences their way.

“In 2013, had that happened, the Greens would have won," she said.

"And if that happens this time around, if the Liberal party does that for strategic reasons, rather than ideological reasons, you'd expect to see a Greens win in Batman.”

The Greens say they’ll preference Labor in the inner Melbourne electorates, but haven’t committed to other seats across the country, saying preferences are up to the voters.
former Victorian Labor Premier Steve Bracks told SBS: “If they do a deal, it will hurt their primary vote.” 

“Most Green political party voters don’t like the fact that their party would do a deal with the Liberal party,” Mr Bracks said.

Mr Bracks doesn’t believe Batman will become the Greens second lower house seat, and is hopeful the ALP can hold on.

“In the end I think people will realise it is largely a protest vote, it is not a party that's ever going to form government, even if it has an influence on who's going to be in government," he said.

“You're better off making a decision on who might be in government in the future.”

While former Liberal Premier, Jeff Kennett, isn't so sure.

“The reality is, increasingly, more seats are going in to, what I would call, prospectively doubtful seats,” Mr Kennett said.

David Feeney declined our request for an interview.

Over two weeks SBS quizzed residents on their political leanings and discovered a shift to the Greens.

Thornbury resident Shayne Dennehy was traditionally a Labor voter but will back the Greens on July 2.

“Like most Labor people, I was disaffected, they’re just not dealing with the issues that I think the Australian community wants,” she said.

“The carbon tax now is a dirty word. Clearly the asylum seekers, we need to deal with that. They’re the people talking that language, so that’s who I’ll go to.”

Another local is going Green too.

“Because the other two have had plenty of chances and it's same old, same old, year after year after year,” the voter said.


Share
4 min read

Published

Updated

By Sarah Abo


Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News daily and direct to your Inbox

Sign up now for the latest news from Australia and around the world direct to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Download our apps
SBS News
SBS Audio
SBS On Demand

Listen to our podcasts
An overview of the day's top stories from SBS News
Interviews and feature reports from SBS News
Your daily ten minute finance and business news wrap with SBS Finance Editor Ricardo Gonçalves.
A daily five minute news wrap for English learners and people with disability
Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS
SBS World News

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service
Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world
Election 2016: Can the Greens win the Vic seat of Batman? | SBS News