Pauline Hanson censured over remarks there are no 'good Muslims'

The One Nation leader was criticised after making the inflammatory comments during an interview last month.

Pauline Hanson, wearing a floral dress, gesticulating in a room with red seats and pink carpet.

Pauline Hanson dismissed the censure motion as a political attack. Source: AAP / Lukas Coch

IN BRIEF

  • The censure motion passed with Labor and Greens' backing, but not the support of the Coalition.
  • A censure motion is a formal motion of disapproval of an MP or senator for their actions.

One Nation leader Pauline Hanson has been censured by the Senate following her inflammatory remarks against Muslims.

The Queensland senator came under fire after claiming in an interview last month there were no "good Muslims", which was roundly condemned by Labor and Liberal MPs as well as the Islamic community.

The motion called on the Senate to censure Hanson for "inflammatory and divisive comments seeking to vilify Muslim Australians, which do not reflect the opinions of the Australian Senate or the Australian people".

The censure motion passed 36 to 17, with Labor backing it as well as the Greens.

Foreign Minister Penny Wong moved the motion against Hanson on Monday, saying the comments distressed not just Islamic Australians but all Australians.

"[Muslims] are the first to condemn the radical extremists who commit terrorist acts in the name of religion. And to claim that none of them are 'good' is to say that there are no good Australians amongst them," Wong told parliament.

"Words of parliamentarians echo into classrooms, workplaces, communities.

Penny Wong, wearing a blue blazer, with a pink carpet floor behind her.
Foreign Minister Penny Wong, who moved the censure motion, said the words of parliamentarians echoed far throughout Australia. Source: AAP / Lukas Coch

"They help shape how others see each other and how they see themselves. A nation divided against itself is a nation diminished."

A censure motion is a formal motion of disapproval of an MP or senator for their actions, but does not come with a punishment or suspension from the chamber.

Hanson calls censure a 'stunt'

Hanson dismissed the censure motion as a political attack following One Nation's rise in opinion polls.

"This is a stunt and the people out there are fed up with this," she said. "The fact is in your gut, you can't stand the fact is that One Nation is now on 27 per cent and 28 per cent. You can't stand it."

The latest Newspoll indicated Hanson's party had the second-highest primary vote and was in front of the Coalition.

While the Coalition backed parts of the government motion affirming support for multiculturalism and rejecting vilification, Liberal senator Michaelia Cash said the Opposition would not support a censure.

"The censure is one of the Senate's serious institutional sanctions and it should therefore be rare and sober, not used as a routine tactic to score political points," she said.

Two moderate Liberal senators, Paul Scarr and Andrew McLaughlan, crossed the floor to support the censure. Scarr held the immigration portfolio under former Liberal leader Sussan Ley and took a more moderate approach to multiculturalism than his colleagues, before being dumped by Angus Taylor after he assumed the leadership.

The censure debate followed Hanson storming out of the chamber after calling independent Lidia Thorpe a "bitch" and later refusing to apologise for the slur.

The insult came amid a heated back-and-forth between the two MPs during a debate on US-Israel strikes on Iran, during which Thorpe continuously called Hanson a liar.

Hanson subsequently said she apologised "if the public heard me call Senator Thorpe a bitch", but added she didn't take back the comment.

"The Senate chamber is meant to be a place for debate, not constant screaming and yelling over the top of senators like we see from Senator Thorpe," she told the Australian Associated Press following the insult.

"I will not be repeatedly called a liar ... I've had a gutful of her and so too has the vast majority of Australians."

The heated exchange comes as the Coalition faces pressure to reject a preference deal with the resurgent One Nation in an upcoming by-election for the NSW seat of Farrer.


For the latest from SBS News, download our app and subscribe to our newsletter.


4 min read

Published

Source: AAP, Reuters



Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News daily and direct to your Inbox

Sign up now for the latest news from Australia and around the world direct to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Follow SBS News

Download our apps

Listen to our podcasts

Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service

Watch now

Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world