Sick refugee takes on Peter Dutton over coronavirus detention fears

An immigration detainee is launching court action against the federal government, arguing it failed to provide safe conditions during the coronavirus pandemic.

Refugees have protested for three weeks at Kangaroo Point detention centre over COVID-19 infection fears.

Refugees have protested for three weeks at Kangaroo Point detention centre over COVID-19 infection fears. Source: SBS

A refugee in immigration detention has launched a High Court challenge against Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton and his department over the threat of COVID-19 infection risk while held in immigration detention.

The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, will argue the government is breaching its duty of care by failing to provide safe conditions during the pandemic.

Australia’s Human Rights Commissioner, peak medical bodies advising the federal government, the World Health Organization and the UN have called for the release of immigration detainees where it is safe to do so to reduce the threat.

Legal documents filed late on Monday state that the unnamed man has “complex medical conditions” including asthma, a heart condition and diabetes which puts him at higher risk of “severe illness or death” if a coronavirus outbreak accurs.

Border Force has repeatedly said no detainees have contracted COVID-19 across the detention network and has infection control measures in place.

The refugee bringing the case was transferred to Australia from Papua New Guinea early last year for medical treatment and claims the government is failing its “duty of care.”

“Minister Dutton has a legal duty to protect the people in the Government’s care in immigration detention. Instead, he is choosing to hold men and women in crammed detention centres that make it impossible to practice physical distancing,” Human Rights Law Centre legal director David Burke said.

“Medical experts have been clear that the people in these detention centres, especially those with underlying health issues, are at severe risk from COVID-19.

“We are asking Minister Dutton to listen to the medical experts - just like the Government is asking all of us to do - in response to this public health crisis.

“He can avoid placing lives at risk by simply releasing people into safe housing where they can socially isolate,” Mr Burke said.

Human rights organisations have warned the case may be the first of many brought by people in immigration detention.

Australia's Human Rights Commissioner Edward Santow last week called for the "urgent" and "immediate" release of immigration detainees.

"We need to heed experts who have been guiding all the government's activities here," Mr Santow told SBS News.

"They've been crystal clear, the Australasian Society for Infectious Diseases (ASID) has said people in detention who don't pose a significant security risk be released into the community immediately.

“Right now the most urgent issue is for people in detention to practice social distancing and at the moment the density of the number of people in immigration detention facilities, including APODS, is so great it is practically impossible to do that,” Mr Santow said.

Two weeks ago where about 120 men are being held, and said she would speak with the Federal Government about the safety of immigration detainees.

A spokesman told SBS News the Queensland government “has sought reassurances from Border Force”.

“At the time of its reply, Border Force said it had no COVID-19 in any of its facilities and strict protocols to manage risks,” the spokesman said, adding further enquires should be directed to the agency.

The Home Affairs minister and department have been contacted for comment.

People in Australia must stay at least 1.5 metres away from others and gatherings are limited to two people unless you are with your family or household.

If you believe you may have contracted the virus, call your doctor (don’t visit) or contact the national Coronavirus Health Information Hotline on 1800 020 080. If you are struggling to breathe or experiencing a medical emergency, call 000.

SBS is committed to informing Australia’s diverse communities about the latest COVID-19 developments. News and information is available in 63 languages at .

4 min read
Published 22 April 2020 at 11:06am
By Stefan Armbruster
Source: SBS