Hawaiian Tatiana Weston-Webb thought she had snatched the win with the last ride of the final but the six-time world champion held on take it out 14.17 to 13.94.
The victory gives Gilmore the world No.1 ranking after two events.
"Incredible. It really is such a special feeling to be out there ... it's a magical event," Gilmore said.
She is the first Australian winner of the women's title at Bells since 2012 and Gilmore most recently rang the iconic Bell trophy in 2010.
News that makes sense
Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.
Weston-Webb needed a 6.80 when Gilmore gave up priority with less than a minute left in the decider.
It was an incredibly risky decision but also a calculated gamble which paid off.
Weston-Webb was clapping when she returned to the beach, thinking she might have done enough.
But the wave was not quite big enough and Weston-Webb's last score was a 6.57 in her first Bells Beach final.
"I thought it could have gone either way, I know I surfed my all and gave everything I could," Weston-Webb said.
Earlier on Thursday, Gilmore had a riveting semi-final against 16-year-old American rising star Caroline Marks.
Marks still had the lead with less than five minutes left but Gilmore unleashed a 9.07 wave score.
The American prodigy then had one last chance to regain the lead but wiped out.
Gilmore won 17.00 to 15.44.
