'Extraordinary attack': Lawyers angry at Peter Dutton's 'Un-Australian' remark


The Law Council of Australia has labelled as "truly extraordinary" the Immigration Minister's remarks about lawyers representing asylum seekers.

The nation’s peak legal body has hit out at Immigration Minister Peter Dutton for claiming lawyers who represent certain asylum seekers are un-Australian.

Mr Dutton's comments around the issue came while discussing the federal government’s plans to kick off dozens of asylum seekers brought to Australia for medical treatment off welfare and public housing.

In an intervew with broadcaster Alan Jones, the minister criticised “political correctness” and “feel good events” taking place around the country.

“It extends to some of our major law firms where part of their social justice agenda is for pro bono work to be provided,” he told on 2GB radio.

“So there are lawyers across the country who are providing pro bono support to people in this situation. And they lodge their papers in the High Court and it costs taxpayers tens of millions of dollars to defend these actions.”

Mr Dutton said advocates knew when asylum seekers were arriving in Australia for medical help and accused lawyers of seeking out subsequent court action.

The minister, when asked by Jones if this was “un-Australian behaviour” said “of course it is".

“It’s gone on for too long and I think people believe in a fair go but this is ripping the system off,” Mr Dutton added.

“These people need to return to their country of origin or back to Nauru or Manus whence they came, and that’s the arrangement.

“These lawyers have been playing the game with these people who are willing participants.

“We are a generous nation but we are not going to be taken for a ride.”

'Un-Australian' - Peter Dutton on asylum seeker lawyers
'Un-Australian' - Peter Dutton on asylum seeker lawyers

'This is incredibly cruel': Human Rights Law Centre responds to Peter Dutton
'This is incredibly cruel': Human Rights Law Centre responds to Peter Dutton

'An extraordinary break with history'

The Law Council of Australia said the comments were regrettable and misguided, saying it was an attack on the profession.

"There is nothing more Australian than ensuring people are subject to the rule of law and have their legal rights protected,” President Fiona McLeod said.

Lawyers were helping asylum seekers pursue rights that exist under international and Australian law, she added.

"It is true that the legal rights of individuals can be an inconvenience to government, so attacking the legal professionals who work pro bono to defend those rights is truly extraordinary.”

"The Australian legal system reflects fundamental Australian values, including the right to have your case heard, the right to not be arbitrarily detained and the right not to be subjected to cruel or inhumane treatment.

"It is often the case that those seeking asylum are fleeing countries where the rule of law has broken-down.

"We have a long and proud history of politicians understanding the importance of showing respect for the independence of our legal system. Today's comments represent an extraordinary break with that history," Ms McLeod added.

Later on in the interview, Jones asked the minister if laws could be passed to force asylum seekers back to offshore detention when medical assistance was no longer required.

Mr Dutton said there were constitutional issues preventing such a move.

“We can’t pass legislation to dispense with that difficulty it’s a constitutional issue,” he said.

“We defend these matters and fight them in the courts and it is incredibly frustrating.”

The minister said many of the asylum seekers were in a better position than pensioners who paid taxes most their lives.

“Many of these people are provided with houses. This is the arrangement... because it’s cheaper ultimately than keeping people in detention.”

'It doesn't make you a citizen': Hanson and Hanson-Young fire up over Australian born refugee children
'It doesn't make you a citizen': Hanson and Hanson-Young fire up over Australian born refugee children

Stay up to date with SBS NEWS

  • App
  • Subscribe
  • Follow
  • Listen
  • Watch