How do three generations experience gender transition?

Three generations of one family are figuring out just how they respond to a loved one transitioning from female to male.

Father and daughter walking in street

Father and daughter walk in streeet. (Photo by David Ramos/Getty Images) Source: Getty Images

Toby Harrap first met Lauren Birch working in a café.

Both going through rough patches in their personal lives, they remedied their troubles with after-work drinks and formed a friendship.

Drinks turned quickly to dating.  

Back then, though, Toby was Megan: struggling with the knowledge that he didn’t identify with the female gender he’d been assigned to at birth.

Toby and Lauren, along with Toby’s mother Janet, are joining this week’s episode of Insight to discuss the profound impact gender transition can have on relationships with loved ones.
Insight guests Lauren Birch and Toby Harrap
Insight guests Lauren Birch and Toby Harrap Source: Insight
The couple also have a young daughter, Ruby-Rae, who will one day be told that her father is transgender.

For Toby, the experience of transitioning has been, individually, fraught but positive.

He has made these powerful videos showing his experience becoming the gender he identifies as.

But how has his transition affected the generations of family and friends before him, those with him now, and the ones to come after him?

“She had to make that decision: am I going to date a trans man?”

A previous relationship had become somewhat “tortured” when Toby revealed to his then-partner that he was transgender.

With Lauren, it was a different experience.

“The first time we hung out outside of work, he said to me, ‘Look, I actually think I’m transgender’,” says Lauren.

"I was like, oh my god, that’s so exciting, tell me more. I need to know all of the things about it.”

There was an attraction between them, but Toby was hesitant.

“I told her I was transgender before anything happened between us, we were just friends,” he says. 

“She had to make that decision: am I going to date a trans man?”

For Lauren, the prospect of dating someone who may, eventually, change genders, was not daunting.

“I was about 16 [when] I came out as bisexual … [but] I don’t particularly have a label,” she says. “I love Toby for who he is, not the gender he is.”
“I love Toby for who he is, not the gender he is.” - Lauren Birch
Her connection to the lesbian community, and the sexual identification that came with it, had been strong.

But she didn’t see it as mutually exclusive with her new relationship; rather, an evolution of her personal sexuality.

“It was fascinating for me,” she says. “I loved watching how the brain works, just watching myself evolve and watching me and Toby evolve as a heterosexual couple.”

Within two years the two were in a steadfast relationship.

Lauren became a catalyst for Toby’s transition, assisting and providing him with the confidence to pursue hormone therapy.
Communication – down to the “nittiest, grittiest details” of sex, cohabitation, parenting and coupledom – has also been crucial in contributing to their now “thriving” relationship and Toby’s fully-realised gender identity.

“If I think of Meg [Megan] I think of an overweight, angry, depressed alcoholic,” says Toby.

“I was a mess of a woman, and now I’m a really well together man.”

"I've basically got the perfect son."

For Toby’s mother, Janet, the transition was also powerful.

“He was heading down a path of destruction, at the time Toby was Meg back then,” she tells Insight’s Jenny Brockie.

“We had got to a point where the little contact that we had was volatile.”

From an early age she’d recognised Toby’s discomfort in his genetically female body, with Toby saying he was never encouraged to be a “girly girl.”

Janet says Lauren was a “saviour” when she came into Toby’s life, and as he began the transition process their relationship repaired.
The birthday before Toby began his hormone treatment, he decided he’d put a dress on one last time, “make-up and hair and the whole nine yards.”

“Mum [had] to say goodbye to her daughter,” Toby explains.

But Janet wasn’t fazed to be ‘losing’ a daughter. The opposite, in fact.

“I don’t feel like I’ve actually lost anything,” she says. “I have got my child back.”
"I have my child back." - Janet Harrap
“Toby was obviously struggling really badly with [his] gender and what that was meaning  and the pressures it was putting on him.”

"I’ve basically got the perfect son … I can’t feel bad about that. That’s a good thing.”
Insight guests Toby and Janet Harrap
Toby Harrap as a child with mother Janet Source: Supplied

"We plan to raise a very open-minded and aware little girl."

The final generation to experience Toby's transition will be his daughter with Lauren, Ruby-Rae. 

Born early last year, she was conceived via sperm donation from Toby's brother Nick, which fertilised Lauren's eggs.  

Knowing the transition was the right option, it was still hard for Toby to consider he may never have kids as hormone therapy approached. 

"I was a bit devastated that I was never going to have children," he says. "I was never going to have a little Harrap running around." 

Now, with the sperm donation a success and a baby to raise, the couple are beginning to discuss how they will tell their daughter that her father is transgender.
Insight guests Toby Harrap and Lauren Birch, with daughter Ruby-Rae
Toby Harrap and Lauren Birch, with daughter Ruby-Rae Source: Lauren Birch
"We have talked extensively with each other, our parents and my brother, and we all agree that she will grow up knowing the truth," he says. 

"The older she gets, the more detailed the information we will give her. She will also know that her uncle is the donor."

"Basically we plan to raise a very open-minded and aware little girl," he says. 

 

Insight, Love Transformed | Catch up online now: 

[videocard video="629302851567"]


Share
Follow Insight
Insight is Australia's leading forum for debate and powerful first-person stories offering a unique perspective on the way we live. Read more about Insight
Have a story or comment? Contact Us

Insight is Australia's leading forum for debate and powerful first-person stories offering a unique perspective on the way we live.
Watch nowOn Demand
Follow Insight
5 min read

Published

Updated

By Madeleine King


Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News daily and direct to your Inbox

Sign up now for the latest news from Australia and around the world direct to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Download our apps
SBS News
SBS Audio
SBS On Demand

Listen to our podcasts
An overview of the day's top stories from SBS News
Interviews and feature reports from SBS News
Your daily ten minute finance and business news wrap with SBS Finance Editor Ricardo Gonçalves.
A daily five minute news wrap for English learners and people with disability
Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS
SBS World News

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service
Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world
How do three generations experience gender transition? | SBS Insight