82 per cent of Australians support immigration despite population concerns

A report by the Scanlon Foundation found more than four in five Australians see benefits to immigration, but concerns remain around overcrowding and house prices.

Sydney commuters

Sydney commuters during rush hour in August 2018. Source: AAP

An annual national survey tracking public opinion on immigration and population issues has found a strong majority of Australians still see benefits in immigration despite heightening concern over population growth.

The 2018 Mapping Social Cohesion survey, conducted by the philanthropic Scanlon Foundation, found more than four in five Australians see benefits to immigration.

The survey, which canvassed the views of 1,500 randomly chosen Australians, also found 52 per cent of Australians consider the current intake of migrants either ‘about right’ or ‘too low’, challenging some recent media and political narratives about rising concern over immigration and its impact on Australian society.


But 43 per cent took the view that the migrant intake was ‘too high’, up from 37 per cent last year. The finding is the highest since 2010 when it peaked at 47 per cent following the Coalition's vow to cut migration after Kevin Rudd's speech supporting a "Big Australia". 

Researcher Andrew Markus, from Melbourne's Monash University
Researcher Andrew Markus, from Melbourne's Monash University Source: SBS

Researcher Andrew Markus, from Melbourne's Monash University, said despite concerns about population management, 82 per cent of those surveyed believed immigrants improve Australian society 'by bringing new ideas and cultures’. Eighty per cent also agreed ‘immigrants are generally good for Australia’s economy’.

"There are relatively low levels of concern about immigration from many different countries, about whether immigration is good for this country, creates jobs, gives us fresh ideas. All of those indicators remain, by large percentages, very positive," he said.

Over the course of the surveys, Australia’s population has increased by an estimated five million, from 19.9 million in 2006 to 25 million in August 2018. It is projected to reach 30 million between 2029 and 2033, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics.

Overcrowding and house prices

Despite Professor Markus said the survey found notable community concern around "perceived lack of government planning, about perceived overcrowding and house prices".

Fifty-four per cent of respondents indicated concern at the 'impact of immigration on overcrowding of Australian cities', 49 per cent at the 'impact of immigration on house prices' and 48 per cent at inadequate 'government management of population growth'. 

It was the first year questions about overcrowding and house prices were asked.

The results come as the government claims tighter migration could ease the pressure on Australian cities. Prime Minister Scott Morrison said last month he intended to cut Australia's permanent migration intake by about 30,000 people.

"They are saying: enough, enough, enough," Mr Morrison said.

"The roads are clogged, the buses and trains are full. The schools are taking no more enrollments. I hear what you are saying. I hear you loud and clear."

The immigration intake cap has been set at 190,000 since 2012-13. For most of those years, the real intake has nearly met the cap. But in 2017-18 the intake plummeted to its lowest level in a decade, with just 163,000 permanent arrivals – made up of both skilled and family visas.

Multiculturalism in a growing society

But Professor Markus said on the question of whether multiculturalism has been good for Australia, support remains steady with previous years.

"Over the course of 11 years of surveying, more than anything, we've seen stability," he said.

"We've got a question which asks people, 'Do you think multiculturalism has been good for Australia?' And there are lots of people out there telling you that multiculturalism is a disaster, it's ruining the country. And we're getting 85 per cent of people saying, 'Yes, multiculturalism has been good'."

"We've done that now more than five times. Each time, we've got pretty much the same result. It has always been in the range 83 to 86 (per cent)."

We're getting [a majority] of people saying, 'Yes, multiculturalism has been good. - Andrew Markus, Researcher
Most respondents saw multiculturalism as a two-way process of change, involving adaptation by both those people already in Australia and those arriving from overseas. In the survey, 54 per cent felt migrants should change their behaviours to be more like people already in Australia. Meanwhile, 37 per cent said ethnic minorities should receive government assistance to maintain their customs and condition.

Ethnic Communities Councils of Victoria chairwoman Kris Pavlidisis said overall the results offer a positive picture of Australian society's understanding of multiculturalism:

“That seems to be the general feeling out in the community. We see it in our neighbourhoods, in our local schools, in our shopping centres. Our neighbours, we are living among people. In fact we are all immigrants. Other than our Indigenous people we are all immigrants to this nation.”

Discrimination remains

Just under one in five of those surveyed said they had experienced discrimination because of their religion, ethnicity or skin colour. That figure has not increased since 2016.

Eighteen-year-old African-Australian Emmanuel Makor was born in Egypt and said while he has experienced discrimination in Australia, he feels a strong sense of belonging.

Emmanuel Makor
Emmanuel Makor Source: SBS

“I consider myself Australian. I feel very blessed to be here. I have been here for 15 years, I am 18 this is all I know. I am Australian," he told SBS News. 

"You have heard the term 'African-American', but you don't hear the term 'African-Australian'. You have people who are born here, but the media will not say 'African-Australian'. They will say 'Africans'. It's like we are on the outside looking in.”

The media will not say 'African-Australian'. They will say 'Africans'. It's like we are on the outside looking in. - Emmanuel Makor, 18
He receives support from Youth Activating Youth, a non-profit organisation which helps "disadvantaged multicultural Australian youth to re-engage in their communities". 

Around 23 per cent of respondents to the Mapping Social Cohesion survey showed negative views towards Muslims, a figure that has remained between 22 and 25 per cent since 2010.

Victorian Multicultural Commission chairwoman Helen Kapalos said negative views based on religion and race, are part of a global narrative taking place.  

“We know that there has been narratives based on these areas before, but I think more than ever race and religion are part of a global conversation, again one where fear is present, and where we have little understanding of faith in the contemporary context of society," she said.

"We often associate religiosity or the perception of someone's religiosity and what that might mean and what it might represent. Is that representation something that is real or is it a perception?"

Attitudes on parliament

Beyond immigration, Professor Markus says the changes in respondents attitudes towards members of the federal parliament in the survey were particularly notable.

He said there has been a significant drop in support for federal parliamentarians over the past decade.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Leader of the Opposition Bill Shorten pass each other in a division during Question Time in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra, Thursday, November 29, 2018. (AAP Image/Mick Tsikas) NO ARCHIVING
Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Leader of the Opposition Bill ShortenNovember 29, 2018. (AAP Image/Mick Tsikas) Source: AAP

“We ask questions about, 'Do you trust politicians in Canberra to do the right thing for the Australian people?' And the interesting finding there is that, at one point, it was 48 per cent of people said, 'Yes, I do' ... in 2009.

"Then that collapsed, and it hasn't recovered. So, it's gone from 48 per cent down to around 30 per cent, and that's where it's stayed."

7 min read
Published 4 December 2018 at 5:57am
By Peggy Giakoumelos, Abby Dinham
Source: SBS