Scott Morrison dismisses calls for independent inquiry into historical rape allegation against Christian Porter

Labor and the Greens are among those calling on Prime Minister Scott Morrison to hold an independent inquiry into the allegations.

Scott Morrison said it was the most senior appointment of an Australian candidate to an international body for decades.

Scott Morrison said it was the most senior appointment of an Australian candidate to an international body for decades. Source: AAP

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has dismissed calls for an independent inquiry into a historical rape allegation against Attorney-General Christian Porter, which he has strenuously denied.

The prime minister on Thursday also rejected calls for Mr Porter to stand down from his current role as Australia’s top law maker - saying he expected Mr Porter to return to the job after a short period of leave.

In a press conference on Wednesday, Mr Porter identified himself as the cabinet minister who had been accused of raping a 16-year-old girl in 1988, breaking his silence to reject the accusations. The woman, from Adelaide, died last year. 

Lawyers acting for the alleged victim’s family released a statement on Thursday saying the family is supportive of “any inquiry” that will shed light on the "circumstances surrounding" the woman’s death.

“The family of the deceased continue to experience considerable grief arising from their loss,” the statement said, as reported by News Corp.

“They are supportive of any inquiry which could potentially shed light on the circumstances surrounding the deceased’s passing.

“They ask that their privacy be respected during this difficult time.”

NSW Police closed their investigation into the rape allegation, put to them in February last year by the woman at the centre of the complaint, due to a lack of admissible evidence. 

The South Australian coroner is also investigating the circumstances around her death and currently considering whether to conduct an inquest. 

Meanwhile, political opponents have called on Mr Morrison to hold an independent inquiry to examine the allegation and whether further action should be taken.

Speaking to reporters on Thursday, the prime minister said he stood by Mr Porter and his right to the presumption of innocence.

“I have to make my decisions based on the process followed by the police. There is no other alternative for a Prime Minister than the rule of law,” he said.

“There is not some other process. There is not the mob process. There is not the tribe-has-spoken process. That’s not how we run the rule of law in Australia.”

Mr Porter has also rejected calls to stand aside from his role, saying he’s become a victim of trial by media and the rule of law would be worthless if people lost their job based on accusations alone.

“Nothing in the allegations that have been printed ever happened," Mr Porter said on Wednesday.

Labor Senator Penny Wong insists an independent inquiry is needed to review the allegations and whether Mr Porter should be stood aside from his role.

She said such an investigation would assure Australians whether they should have confidence in Mr Porter to remain the nation's first law officer.

“We have serious credible allegations about our attorney general and the prime minister really needs to really stop looking at this as an issue of clear political management,” she told ABC radio on Thursday.

“The reality is unless there is some form of investigation … these questions will continue.”

Independent MP Zali Steggall has also backed calls for an independent inquiry.

"That is what the Australian public is calling for, a proper and thorough independent investigation," she told SBS News. 

Greens Senator Larissa Waters has accused Mr Morrison of trying to sweep the allegations “under the carpet” by not pursuing an independent inquiry. 

“We need an independent inquiry into these allegations,” she told the ABC. “You cannot have unresolved allegations surrounding the most senior law office of the land.” 

Mr Morrison said on Thursday further investigation could undermine the rule of law, given NSW Police closed its probe because of a lack of admissible evidence.

"You will be aware of the terrible things that can happen in a country where the rule of law is not upheld and is not supported," he told reporters.

"The rule of law is essential for liberal democracies and we weaken it at our great peril."

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg has also rejected calls for a new inquiry.

“There is one authorised body to deal with such serious criminal allegations and that is the police,” he told ABC radio.

“Christian Porter is entitled to the presumption of innocence and the rule of law needs to apply here.”

Mr Porter has himself questioned the process of an inquiry going ahead, concerned it would force him to "disprove something" that he says "didn't happen". 

He has taken a short period of leave for his mental health.

If you or someone you know is impacted by family and domestic violence or sexual assault, call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 or visit . In an emergency, call 000.

Readers seeking support with mental health can contact Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636. More information is available at . supports people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

Like this story? Here's where else you can find SBS News content and follow us:

SBS News website: Save our website  as a favourite. 

SBS News app: Download our app from  or  and subscribe to the alerts.

SBS News newsletters: Get the latest delivered to your email inbox by 

Apple News: Follow the SBS News channel .

Twitter: Follow us at 

Instagram: Follow us at 

YouTube: Subscribe at 

TikTok: Follow us at 

Reddit: Join us at 

SBS also publishes news in 68 languages online and on radio. Find your language at .

You can also find stories from  and  on their websites and social media platforms.

6 min read
Published 4 March 2021 at 10:40am
By Tom Stayner