Daniel Aghion KC, president of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ), said in a statement Australia's intention to recognise Palestinian statehood "has departed from decades of bipartisan consensus which has envisaged Palestinian statehood and recognition as part of a comprehensive peace agreement between Israel, the Palestinians and the Arab States".
He welcomed the government's acknowledgement of "the need for all the hostages to be released and for Hamas to be disarmed and removed from power" but said there was a major flaw in the announcement.
"It relegates all of these conditions to the status of a mere promise to be fulfilled at some future time, and says nothing about what will happen if those conditions are not met," he said.
"We feel that the course of action announced by the government is a betrayal and abandonment of the Israeli hostages who continue to languish in appalling conditions in Gaza without even access to the Red Cross. This announcement gives them no hope for release.
"It leaves Hamas armed and in control of territory, and in a position to regroup and rearm, thereby creating the conditions for the next war rather than a comprehensive peace."
He said the move would make Israel feel "wronged and abandoned by a longstanding ally" and added that the Jewish community was "not surprised" by the announcement.
Ahead of the announcement, Jeremy Leibler, president of the Zionist Federation of Australia issued this statement: "Following reports the Australian Government is set to recognise a Palestinian state today, we are deeply concerned that the timing and substance of this policy reversal will embolden Hamas, further jeopardise the lives of Israeli hostages, prolong the war and the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and place more strain on the longstanding alliance between Australia and Israel, the only democracy in the Middle East."
— Alexandra Koster