'Unsafe' and 'unfairly scrutinised': How the Bondi terror attack changed Australia

The massacre during a Jewish Hanukkah festival — and its aftermath — have made indelible impacts on the country.

People form a circle around flowers and other tributes at a vigil.

Australians held several vigils in the wake of the Bondi attack to remember the victims. Source: Getty / George Chan

A month since the Bondi terror attack claimed the lives of 15 people, its impact is continuing to ripple across the country, from the streets to the parliament.

At 6.41pm on Sunday 14 December, two gunmen — who police allege were father and son Sajid and Naveed Akram — parked a car near a footbridge overlooking Bondi Beach's Arthur Park, where a Hanukkah event had begun earlier that evening, and opened fire.

50-year-old Sajid was killed during the attack, while his 24-year-old son Naveed has been charged with dozens of offences including murder and terrorism-related charges.

The massacre and its aftermath have indelibly shaped the country. It's in the reverberations felt by those in the community, the changes to a wide range of laws, the political discourse and — among it all — acts of unity and compassion.

Almost immediately after the shooting took place, stories emerged about acts of bravery. There were the emergency responders.

There were everyday Australians like tobacco shop owner Ahmed al-Ahmed, who ran towards one of the gunmen, tackled him and wrestled his weapon away, being shot twice in the process.
Local Jewish couple Boris and Sofia Gurman also confronted one of the shooters — ultimately paying with their lives.

The Red Cross' Lifeblood service recorded record-breaking numbers of people donating blood. Millions of dollars were contributed for al-Ahmed's recovery. And at vigils across the country, Australians paused to remember those who were killed in the attack, laying flowers and other tributes outside Bondi Pavilion.

On Tuesday, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced a national day of mourning will be held next week, as the country continues to process Australia's deadliest terror attack.

'There is fear, and there is anger'

Daniel Aghion is the president of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ) — the country's peak body of Jewish community organisations. He said the Jewish community in Australia remains "fragile" and is now grappling with the long-term consequences of the "terribly traumatic" attack.

"There is fear, and there is anger. The fear and anger come from the fact that we have been the targets yet again of hate-filled violence — on this occasion as victims of Australia's worst terrorist attack," Aghion told SBS News.

But Aghion said the "outpouring of support" from everyday Australians for the Jewish community, and a recognition that antisemitism is "an Australian problem, not exclusively a Jewish one", had been a source of comfort in the community.

"It tells us that we are valued, that we are part of this community, that we are part of Australian community and society, and that we belong here. It also tells us very strongly that Australians will not let hate win."
Levi Wolff, the rabbi of Bondi's Central Synagogue, said his small and close-knit community has been "exceptional" in its support for each other — whether visiting grieving families, bringing them food, organising support groups, or "simply showing up to lend a hand, a hug, or a kind word".

Wolff said he and other rabbis were trying to ensure spiritual and emotional support was available, and that people had been actively seeking that connection.

"There has been an increase in attendance at services and community events across synagogues in Australia, as people look for strength, comfort and solidarity in one another."
A man standing in front of rows of flower bouquets on the ground.
Community leaders say Jewish Australians are continuing to grapple with the impact of last month's attack. Source: Getty / James D Morgan
Ohad Kozminsky is an executive member of the Jewish Council of Australia (JCA) — a progressive Jewish group founded in the wake of Hamas' October 7 attacks in 2023, and Israel's retaliatory assault on Gaza.

He said many Jewish people were feeling deeply unsafe in the wake of the "heinous" antisemitic attack, and it would be difficult for the community to recover.

"We also know that racism against Jewish people is often accompanied by racism against other racialised groups, especially Muslim and Palestinian communities — and this is precisely what we have seen," Kozminsky told SBS News, citing an alleged violent attack on Melbourne Imam Ismet Purdic and his wife on Saturday.

Those acts of racism have been called out by groups like the Australian National Imams Council (ANIC), which said last month that Muslim communities were being "unfairly scrutinised and implicitly linked to acts of violence they categorically reject".
"Muslim Australians have experienced a marked escalation in hostility and blame being directed toward them as a community, despite having no connection whatsoever to the actions of the lone attackers," it said.

That surge in hate-driven incidents included vandalism at mosques and Islamic centres, dismembered pigs thrown onto graves at a Muslim cemetery in Sydney, and visibly Muslim women being spat at and verbally abused.

ANIC senior adviser Bilal Rauf told SBS News late last month the attacks had led to a heightened feeling of anxiety and distress among Australia's Muslim community.

"It is very confronting and traumatic," Rauf said.

Changes to gun and hate speech laws, protests

While communities continue to reel from the Bondi massacre and its aftermath, governments have already passed or proposed a raft of legislative changes.

The NSW government passed a bill in the early hours of Christmas Eve, tightening gun controls and controversially restricting public protest.

The latter decision — which NSW Premier Chris Minns has defended as necessary to reduce community tensions — has been met with fierce criticism and accusations that it infringes on democratic rights.
A white middle-aged man with brown and grey hair wearing a suit (NSW Premier Chris Minns) looks forward while speaking.
NSW Premier Chris Minns has defended controversial laws restricting protest. Source: AAP / Dean Lewins
Under the law, the police commissioner is given the ability to ban protests in certain areas following a declared terrorist incident, for an initial two-week period that can be extended up to three months.

NSW Police commissioner Mal Lanyon activated that power almost as soon as possible, restricting public assemblies in Sydney's southwest, northwest and central metropolitan areas.

On 6 January, Lanyon extended the restrictions by another two weeks, arguing public assemblies at this time could "cause fear and public safety issues".

Activists and legal services have expressed concern that the legislation will crack down on freedoms and suppress protests for all manner of causes, such as a First Nations-led rally on January 26.
Kozminsky said the measures were "dangerous and anti-democratic", and falsely conflated pro-Palestinian protests in Sydney with the Bondi attack.

Last month, Minns pledged to ban the chant "globalise the intifada", an Arabic word that refers to an uprising or shaking off that has been frequently used by pro-Palestinian activists in the past two years.

Kozminsky said the JCA had consistently opposed what he described as the "cynical politicisation" of the massacre.

He said the group has proposed "another path forward" via a petition it has been circulating, calling for steps like funding grassroots and cross-cultural community initiatives, adopting and fully funding the Australian Human Rights Commission's anti-racism framework, and protecting rights to peacefully protest.
On a federal level, the prime minister has recalled politicians back to Canberra weeks earlier than planned in the hopes of passing sweeping changes to hate speech and gun legislation.

Under the proposals, people who join or support proscribed hate groups would face 15 years in prison. Those who "publicly promote or incite" hatred against a person or group because of their race could face five years behind bars.

Disseminating "ideas of superiority or hatred towards another person or group of people based on their race, colour, or national or ethnic origin" would also be made illegal, the home affairs minister would be given new grounds to refuse or cancel visas, and hate symbol offences would be expanded.

The government would introduce an additional layer of security checks for firearm licenses, and a national buyback scheme could be established.
ECAJ J co-CEO Peter Wertheim said the draft legislation was "a significant step in the right direction, but it still suffers some significant shortcomings which will limit its effectiveness".

He particularly welcomed the serious vilification offence, saying in a statement released on Tuesday: "Many previous hate speech cases failed to result in prosecutions because of the impossibility of proving incitement [of an audience] beyond reasonable doubt."

However, he said the bill contained "four serious shortcomings", including a requirement to show proof of intention to promote racial hatred and an exemption for quoting or referencing religious texts for the purposes of religious teaching.

"We hope that the new laws will be passed and strengthened, and that the scourge of antisemitism, hate and extremism in our society will be neutralised," he added.

Albanese calls federal royal commission

In recent weeks, though, what has been given the most attention — at least when it comes to the official response — is how the federal government would investigate the factors that led to the Bondi attack.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese initially dismissed ordering a federal royal commission, instead backing NSW plans for a state-based commission and announcing an inquiry into federal intelligence and law enforcement agencies.

But after a chorus of voices — including the Opposition, independents, former federal ministers, public figures, victims' families and sections of the broader Jewish community — called for a federal commission, Albanese eventually backtracked and announced that one would be set up.
"I've taken the time to reflect, to meet with leaders in the Jewish community, and most importantly, I've met with many of the families of victims and survivors of that horrific attack,” the prime minister told reporters in Canberra when announcing a federal royal commission into antisemitism and social cohesion last Thursday.

Wolff said he looked forward to the findings and hoped they would be acted upon decisively to stamp out antisemitism.

"Our hope now is that this moment leads to lasting and meaningful change, so that no other community has to experience this again."


For the latest from SBS News, download our app and subscribe to our newsletter.

Share

9 min read

Published

By Alex Gallagher

Source: SBS News



Share this with family and friends


Get SBS News daily and direct to your Inbox

Sign up now for the latest news from Australia and around the world direct to your inbox.

By subscribing, you agree to SBS’s terms of service and privacy policy including receiving email updates from SBS.

Download our apps
SBS News
SBS Audio
SBS On Demand

Listen to our podcasts
An overview of the day's top stories from SBS News
Interviews and feature reports from SBS News
Your daily ten minute finance and business news wrap with SBS Finance Editor Ricardo Gonçalves.
A daily five minute news wrap for English learners and people with disability
Get the latest with our News podcasts on your favourite podcast apps.

Watch on SBS
SBS World News

SBS World News

Take a global view with Australia's most comprehensive world news service
Watch the latest news videos from Australia and across the world